making holes in mb or breaker boxes

[wireperson]

is it against the code to make your own holes in panels or MB boxes , and not use the pre made ones from factory?
another question , where in the codes is about light fixture in a clothe closet? distance from wall, or if it must be on wall not ceiling?

 

[jumper]

is it against the code to make your own holes in panels or MB boxes , and not use the pre made ones from factory?

Not that I know of.

another question , where in the codes is about light fixture in a clothe closet? distance from wall, or if it must be on wall not ceiling?

410.2

 

[augie47]

I agree with jumper but might add, if you are bringing in larger conductors you might watch 312.6

 

[tryinghard]

The box may not have factory punched knock outs, you just have to connect correctly. Check out Article 410 for your lighting (echoing jumper).

 

[roger]

is it against the code to make your own holes in panels or MB boxes , and not use the pre made ones from factory?

Sounds as though you only deal with residential load centers. I would say ninety five percent of the panelboard enclosures, gutters, cabinets, etc... I purchase have no factory KO's, so if we were not allowed to make our own KO's we never could wire anything.


It would also make manufacturers of KO punches and hole saws mad.


Roger

 

[wireperson]

I was just wondering if it's not a violation of the UL

 

[sameguy]

Try out the carbide hole saws, nice.
They have a ring on them that keeps the cutter from entering the "box" more than ~1-1/4" deep depending on size.

 

[jim dungar]

I was just wondering if it's not a violation of the UL

The UL label says how the device left the factory.

Technically, as soon as you do anything to it, like cut a hole or even knock out a knockout, you run the risk of "violating" the UL listing, and it becomes the responsibility of the AHJ to accept the installation. UL encourages the AHJ to contact them if there is a question concerning the field installation negatively impacting the listing.

 

[raider1]

I was just wondering if it's not a violation of the UL

Keep in mind that the box that the panelboard is installed in is listed as a cabinet, the panelboard is most likely listed separately.

If it is a violation of the listing to make your own holes in a cabinet then with most commercial panelboard cabinets it would be tought to get wires into since quite a few come without any factory knockouts.

I hate cabinets that have factory knockouts for anything other than residential. For commercial work I would much rather make my own holes where I need them.

As for the clothes closet lighting question, if you are uisng the 2008 NEC check out 410.16.

Chris

 

[lakee911]

You can generally order them with or without the knockouts.

Is it a violation to drill across the knockouts as I have done before? What I mean is say drilling a 2.5in hole between rows of 3/4in knockouts.

 

[tommy]

I would say yes to knocking out for bigger holes needed as long as connecter fills the hole completely otherwise you would need to use reducing washers to make a solid connection to the panel can or alot of cans come with concentric on top and solid on bottom or vice versa and I have flip flop the ends to be able to knockout my hole.No code reference though sorry.