Neutrals burning up in panel

Status
Not open for further replies.

E.Hall

Member
I have a friend who has a 200amp panel in an early 90s' house and he keeps having neutrals burn up at the neutral bar. I checked in the meter base, and all the line side wires in the panel, and nothing is loose. Incoming voltage is correct. It seems to be concentrated to only one of the neutral bars (panel has two). About 6 circuits had discolored insulation and two of the six were severly burnt up. I've been to his house once before, he had a circuit not working and in the panel the neutral for that circuit was burnt at the end. I stripped the wire back and landed it back on the nuetral bar and it worked. Should we start systematically taking the devices out related to those affected circuits? Does anyone have any ideas as to what is causing this? I think it could be in a receptacle where the wires are stabbed into the back of the device. I cleaned up the panel this time, stripped all the bad insulation back, cut the wire ends and reterminated them, we have been watching for a change for about a month, none of the wires are showing a problem.:?
 

charlie b

Moderator
Staff member
Location
Lockport, IL
Occupation
Retired Electrical Engineer
If a neutral wire is overheating, and you don't see corresponding signs of overheating at any of the breakers, I would suspect that you have two or more circuits from the same phase that are sharing the neutrals. This would only manifest itself when the combined running load exceeds the ampacity of the neutral wire. For example, if circuits 1 and 3 share a neutral (not legal, but certainly possible), and in the actual running load at any one time is 15 amps on each of circuits 1 and 3, then the shared neutral wire would see a load of 30 amps. That would cause it to overheat, without any problem showing up on the phase wires. On the other hand, if the actual running load was only 8 amps on each of circuits 1 and 3, this could continue indefinitely without any signs of overheating. So I would call this not so much of a "ghost problem," but rather a "lurking problem." By that I specifically mean that the fact that you haven't observed any symptoms for a while does not prove that there is no longer a problem.
 

pete m.

Senior Member
Location
Ohio
I have also witnessed where the installer (I say that instead of electrician for a reason) tightened the terminals to the point that the conductor was almost cut in half causing it to overheat.

Pete
 

glene77is

Senior Member
Location
Memphis, TN

Are you saying that two hots off the same phase,
returning on the single neutral could heat ?

And we realize that two hots off different phases,
returning on the single neutral is OK.
 

Little Bill

Moderator
Staff member
Location
Tennessee NEC:2017
Occupation
Semi-Retired Electrician
If a neutral wire is overheating, and you don't see corresponding signs of overheating at any of the breakers, I would suspect that you have two or more circuits from the same phase that are sharing the neutrals. This would only manifest itself when the combined running load exceeds the ampacity of the neutral wire. For example, if circuits 1 and 3 share a neutral (not legal, but certainly possible), and in the actual running load at any one time is 15 amps on each of circuits 1 and 3, then the shared neutral wire would see a load of 30 amps. That would cause it to overheat, without any problem showing up on the phase wires. On the other hand, if the actual running load was only 8 amps on each of circuits 1 and 3, this could continue indefinitely without any signs of overheating. So I would call this not so much of a "ghost problem," but rather a "lurking problem." By that I specifically mean that the fact that you haven't observed any symptoms for a while does not prove that there is no longer a problem.



Are you saying that two hots off the same phase,
returning on the single neutral could heat ?

And we realize that two hots off different phases,
returning on the single neutral is OK.

Probably not what Charlie was saying in the red above, but if it was circuit 1 & 3 in the panel, they would be on different phases and could share a neutral.
 

charlie b

Moderator
Staff member
Location
Lockport, IL
Occupation
Retired Electrical Engineer
Are you saying that two hots off the same phase, returning on the single neutral could heat?
It could overheat the neutral, because current flowing from the two breakers will add together to become the neutral current. You could have 20 amps flowing in each breaker, without either breaker tripping, and the neutral current would be 40 amps.
And we realize that two hots off different phases, returning on the single neutral is OK.
That is because when the two currents flowing from the two breakers add together to become the neutral current, they will be in opposition to each other. I mean that one current will be at (or near) its positive peak and the other current will be at (or near) its negative peak, so they tend to cancel each other out.
 

charlie b

Moderator
Staff member
Location
Lockport, IL
Occupation
Retired Electrical Engineer
For example, if circuits 1 and 3 share a neutral . . . .
Probably not what Charlie was saying in the red above, but if it was circuit 1 & 3 in the panel, they would be on different phases and could share a neutral.
Since we are talking about a house, I infer that the panel is rated at 120/240 volt single phase. That would put circuits 1 and 3 on the same phase. That, at least, was the intent of my comment.
 

cowboyjwc

Moderator
Staff member
Location
Simi Valley, CA
I would agree with Charlie's thinking, including the parts about circuits 1 & 3 being on the same phase.

If split breakers (or thins, if you like) were installed, sometimes when the "installer" isn't thinking they go with the standard blk/red, blk/red instead of blk/blk, red/red.
 
If split breakers (or thins, if you like) were installed, sometimes when the "installer" isn't thinking they go with the standard blk/red, blk/red instead of blk/blk, red/red.

I've seen this a few times where someone, I assume, thought they were creating a MWBC with a single tandem breaker, often to a quad receptacle fed with 12/3 NM in the garage. Definitely unclear on the concept of MWBC.
 

jumper

Senior Member
Since we are talking about a house, I infer that the panel is rated at 120/240 volt single phase. That would put circuits 1 and 3 on the same phase. That, at least, was the intent of my comment.

I would agree with Charlie's thinking, including the parts about circuits 1 & 3 being on the same phase.

Charlie's theory is correct, but 1 and 3 are not on the same buss/pole in most panels. Odd is left side and even is right.

1 and 3 are A and B.
 

Cow

Senior Member
Location
Eastern Oregon
Occupation
Electrician
Just some ideas:

Improper MWBC's
Broken/cracked neutral bar
Bad connection between neutral bar and jumper from other side.
 

marti smith

Senior Member
we have been watching for a change for about a month, none of the wires are showing a problem.:?

It will be over a longer time period that you'll have to watch, but if you are unsure of the arrangement of conductors to phases, it is best to get with someone who understands it; have them go through the troubleshooting with you. It will be a really good learning experience. Otherwise, depending on the loads on the conductors compared to time, you will be cleaning up the neutrals all over again.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

charlie b

Moderator
Staff member
Location
Lockport, IL
Occupation
Retired Electrical Engineer
Charlie's theory is correct, but 1 and 3 are not on the same buss/pole in most panels. Odd is left side and even is right. 1 and 3 are A and B.
Mea culpa. I see that now. I should have used circuits 1 and 5 as my example, or perhaps 1 and 2.
 

Takideezy

New member
Location
Williamsport PA
Measurement?

Measurement?

If over current is suspected why not measure with a clamp on ammeter?

Also, using a clamp on to measure the affected neutral... cycling breakers and identifying the hot to neutral relationship might be helpful. If the neutral current does not fall to zero - keep looking to determine if there is another breaker sharing the same neutral.

Good luck and Takideezy
 

jusme123

Senior Member
Location
NY
Occupation
JW
Since we are talking about a house, I infer that the panel is rated at 120/240 volt single phase. That would put circuits 1 and 3 on the same phase. That, at least, was the intent of my comment.

Charllie, when a panel is wired, it is done in such a way that the odd ckts are on the left and the even on the right. Ckts 1 and 3 would be on different phases (phase A and phase B respectively) , making it impossible for the neutral to have both phase currents on it at the same time, MWBC are legal.
 

cowboyjwc

Moderator
Staff member
Location
Simi Valley, CA
Charllie, when a panel is wired, it is done in such a way that the odd ckts are on the left and the even on the right. Ckts 1 and 3 would be on different phases (phase A and phase B respectively) , making it impossible for the neutral to have both phase currents on it at the same time, MWBC are legal.

Most main panels, at least here on the west coast, are not side by side, so Charlie would be correct.
 

defears

Senior Member
Location
NJ
I always see the GE thin panels wired incorrectly for 3 wire circuits. The first two breakers are on the same phase.:lol:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top