slight mismatch in ratings between generator and transformer

Status
Not open for further replies.

sigshane

Member
Location
Elberton, GA USA
Hi all. a few years ago, I spent many hours trying to find the answer to this question. I seem to remember finding one, but now I can't remember the answer, nor the source for the answer.

We have 8 hydroelectric generators, rated at 13.8kV output, that are tied in two's to four oil-filled transformers, with low-side voltage rating of 13.2kV.

I am trying to find a good explanation why, when this plant was designed, the generators and transformers were not matched in terms of voltage...was this simply a logistics/availability issue, or is there some engineering explanation?

Thanks,

Shane
 

templdl

Senior Member
Location
Wisconsin
Hi all. a few years ago, I spent many hours trying to find the answer to this question. I seem to remember finding one, but now I can't remember the answer, nor the source for the answer.

We have 8 hydroelectric generators, rated at 13.8kV output, that are tied in two's to four oil-filled transformers, with low-side voltage rating of 13.2kV.

I am trying to find a good explanation why, when this plant was designed, the generators and transformers were not matched in terms of voltage...was this simply a logistics/availability issue, or is there some engineering explanation?

Thanks,

Shane

It is interesting that you have not provided more information about the transformer. Is this a step up or step down transformer? What is the output voltage? Is the output voltage correct or not?
Since the input as nd output voltages of a transformer are proportional I wonder why the output voltage hasn't been the issue here.
With the lack of information provided one would have to assume that the output voltage is incorrect unless thhere are sufficient transformer taps to compensate for the input voltage.
 

charlie b

Moderator
Staff member
Location
Lockport, IL
Occupation
Retired Electrical Engineer
It is interesting that you have not provided more information about the transformer. Is this a step up or step down transformer? What is the output voltage?
The answers are in the OP's description. The transformers are step-down. The primary is 13.8 kv. The secondary is 13.2 kv. I, for one, cannot imagine why they would have been designed this way. Perhaps the generator's output voltage is simply what the generator manufacturers could provide, and the transmission system is designed for 13.2.

 

sigshane

Member
Location
Elberton, GA USA
Sorry for that mess I posted before.

Four 75MW, 13.8kV generators, connected in pairs to two 189MVA transformers, 13.2kV:230kV, 3-phase.

Four 86MW, 13.8kV generators, connected in pairs to two 230MVA transformers, 13.2kV:230kV, 3-phase.

The transformers step up generator output for transmission to the grid when gens are running, and step down 230kV from the grid to feed our station service (plant power) when the gens are not running. Also, both types of transformers have high-side tap changers which allow for up to 5% variance up or down from the nameplate rating, which is where we have them set - 230kV.

the question was why are 13.8kV generators directly connected to 13.2kV transformer primaries. That's a 600 volt difference between generator and transformer - why?

I have attached a partial print of our plant to show the relationship between one of the transformers, and the two generators it is connected to.

Shane
 

Attachments

  • Main 1-Line Diagram portion.pdf
    50.8 KB · Views: 2
Last edited:

GoldDigger

Moderator
Staff member
Location
Placerville, CA, USA
Occupation
Retired PV System Designer
It is a 600V difference, but also less than 5% so it is OK.
Why there are two different nominal voltages is a better question than whether they can be interconnected (they can).
 

Bugman1400

Senior Member
Location
Charlotte, NC
What is the typical operating generator bus voltage? Is it 13.8kV or 13.2kV? If a 230/13.2kV xfmr operates at a 13.8kV gen bus voltage, it allows the primary voltage to run higher at no load (240kV). As you reach the full output of the generators, the higher primary voltage will be reduced by the xfmr impedance down towards the 230kV nominal...assuming the 230kV system operates at 230kV.

Let me know when you guys are ready for a relay upgrade.
 
I dont know what type of generators or turbines these are, and this is a bit out of my league anyway, but it could be a matter of the "mismatch" just shifting your theoretical efficency a bit. For example if this is an induction type generator, you have some slip in the system so you may just end up operating the turbine at a slightly different RPM due to different loading - different from its theoretical design.
 

templdl

Senior Member
Location
Wisconsin
Sorry for that mess I posted before.

Four 75MW, 13.8kV generators, connected in pairs to two 189MVA transformers, 13.2kV:230kV, 3-phase.

Four 86MW, 13.8kV generators, connected in pairs to two 230MVA transformers, 13.2kV:230kV, 3-phase.

The transformers step up generator output for transmission to the grid when gens are running, and step down 230kV from the grid to feed our station service (plant power) when the gens are not running. Also, both types of transformers have high-side tap changers which allow for up to 5% variance up or down from the nameplate rating, which is where we have them set - 230kV.

the question was why are 13.8kV generators directly connected to 13.2kV transformer primaries. That's a 600 volt difference between generator and transformer - why?

I have attached a partial print of our plant to show the relationship between one of the transformers, and the two generators it is connected to.

Shane
I figured as much per my previous reply.
Can you post a picture on the name plates for the transformer?
If the transformer has taps you can correct for the 13,200 under voltage with a 5% below normal tap.
Is you set up for load shaving to prevent being gigged by the POCO? I assume by your description you are not cogenerating with the POCO.
 

topgone

Senior Member
@sigshane,
There's no problem with your unit ratings. You can set your generator voltage at 13.2 kV and you don't even have to change the taps on your transformers,imo.
 

GoldDigger

Moderator
Staff member
Location
Placerville, CA, USA
Occupation
Retired PV System Designer
@sigshane,
There's no problem with your unit ratings. You can set your generator voltage at 13.2 kV and you don't even have to change the taps on your transformers,imo.
I did not even think about the possibility that the generator voltage lists a default or maximum value and is subject to adjustment of 5% or more.
 

Bugman1400

Senior Member
Location
Charlotte, NC
I dont know what type of generators or turbines these are, and this is a bit out of my league anyway, but it could be a matter of the "mismatch" just shifting your theoretical efficency a bit. For example if this is an induction type generator, you have some slip in the system so you may just end up operating the turbine at a slightly different RPM due to different loading - different from its theoretical design.

These size units are typically synchronous.
 

Bugman1400

Senior Member
Location
Charlotte, NC
@sigshane,
There's no problem with your unit ratings. You can set your generator voltage at 13.2 kV and you don't even have to change the taps on your transformers,imo.

I think operating at 13.2kV would require at highside tap change at least 2 taps (probably the highest tap of 241500).
 

Bugman1400

Senior Member
Location
Charlotte, NC
If the transformer is, as it should be, specified as a step up transformer the taps will be on the low voltage side, yes?

I think the NLTC taps are on the highside and are typically -5%,-2.5%,0,+2.5%,+5%. Look at the attached nameplate of GSU at the last hydroplant I did work for.
 
Last edited:

topgone

Senior Member
I think operating at 13.2kV would require at highside tap change at least 2 taps (probably the highest tap of 241500).

The OP said his generators are rated 13.8 kV while his transformers are rated 13.2 kV. Setting the terminal voltage of the generators to 13.2 kV fits the transformer low-side voltage.:)
 

Besoeker

Senior Member
Location
UK
Hi all. a few years ago, I spent many hours trying to find the answer to this question. I seem to remember finding one, but now I can't remember the answer, nor the source for the answer.

We have 8 hydroelectric generators, rated at 13.8kV output, that are tied in two's to four oil-filled transformers, with low-side voltage rating of 13.2kV.

I am trying to find a good explanation why, when this plant was designed, the generators and transformers were not matched in terms of voltage...was this simply a logistics/availability issue, or is there some engineering explanation?

Thanks,

Shane
Do the generators have an AVR? Most I've dealt with do and can be adjusted to alter the open circuit voltage. Would that solve your problem - assuming that there is one.
 

Bugman1400

Senior Member
Location
Charlotte, NC
The OP said his generators are rated 13.8 kV while his transformers are rated 13.2 kV. Setting the terminal voltage of the generators to 13.2 kV fits the transformer low-side voltage.:)

Do you think the generator bus is operated at the generator rating or the xfmr low-side terminal rating? Think about the high-side to low-side ratio of the xfmr. Then, think about what the high-side voltage would be when you are generating at the full MW capability.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top