Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Transformer Secondary

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Transformer Secondary

    Hello,

    A 25 kva transformer is being installed. When sizing my OCPD for the secondary conductors and the single phase 120/240 panel board (70' from transformer) I multiplied secondary current by 125% (104 x 125% = 130 amps). If I use the next size up OCPD, I get a 150 amp OCPD. I was looking at a single phase chart from Mike Holt that states the 25kva single phase transformer should have a secondary OCPD of 125 amps. Would anyone be willing to help clarify which OCPD (125a or 150a) would be correct and why?

    Chart: https://www.mikeholt.com/files/PDF/T...rmer_Chart.pdf

    Thank you,

    Carl

    #2
    Either would be acceptable in general. As would a 15 Amp breaker. The code only tells you the max rating.
    Bob

    Comment


      #3
      Originally posted by petersonra View Post
      Either would be acceptable in general. As would a 15 Amp breaker. The code only tells you the max rating.
      That would mean that whoever created the chart arbitrarily picked 125 as the acceptable ocpd. Does anyone else have any helpful information or reasoning?

      Comment


        #4
        Originally posted by knifeswitch View Post

        That would mean that whoever created the chart arbitrarily picked 125 as the acceptable ocpd. Does anyone else have any helpful information or reasoning?
        it is inherently an arbitrary choice. The chart you linked to has other arbitrary choices in it as well such as wire and conduit sizes.

        In fact, conduit is an arbitrary choice as there are other wiring methods that could be employed and still meet code.
        Last edited by petersonra; 10-09-19, 11:52 AM.
        Bob

        Comment


          #5
          Click image for larger version

Name:	
Views:	0
Size:	147.1 KB
ID:	2538702

          Note that the title of table 450.3(B) says "Maximum rating". As long as you are under that rating you are in compliance with that section of the code.
          Bob

          Comment


            #6
            Originally posted by knifeswitch View Post
            Hello,

            A 25 kva transformer is being installed. When sizing my OCPD for the secondary conductors and the single phase 120/240 panel board (70' from transformer) I multiplied secondary current by 125% (104 x 125% = 130 amps). If I use the next size up OCPD, I get a 150 amp OCPD. I was looking at a single phase chart from Mike Holt that states the 25kva single phase transformer should have a secondary OCPD of 125 amps. Would anyone be willing to help clarify which OCPD (125a or 150a) would be correct and why?

            Chart: https://www.mikeholt.com/files/PDF/T...rmer_Chart.pdf

            Thank you,

            Carl
            70 feet of secondary conductor does not comply with 240.21(C).

            Comment


              #7
              Originally posted by texie View Post

              70 feet of secondary conductor does not comply with 240.21(C).
              How so?

              Comment


                #8
                Originally posted by knifeswitch View Post

                How so?
                Maybe I'm not understanding where your secondary OCPD is. Is it at the transformer and the panel is 70 feet away?

                Comment


                  #9
                  Originally posted by texie View Post

                  Maybe I'm not understanding where your secondary OCPD is. Is it at the transformer and the panel is 70 feet away?
                  No, it's in the panel. I have primary protection in the mcc. Transformer next to the mcc. Up and over 70' to main breaker panel. I'm just wondering if I'm missing something on ocpd sizing after looking at the chart. The 37.5kva secondary is the max at 200 butt the 25kva doesn't give the max..... Seemed odd. We were going with a 150amp main in the panel and I'm just trying to double check that. I thought I might get helpful answers here...

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Originally posted by knifeswitch View Post

                    No, it's in the panel. I have primary protection in the mcc. Transformer next to the mcc. Up and over 70' to main breaker panel. I'm just wondering if I'm missing something on ocpd sizing after looking at the chart. The 37.5kva secondary is the max at 200 butt the 25kva doesn't give the max..... Seemed odd. We were going with a 150amp main in the panel and I'm just trying to double check that. I thought I might get helpful answers here...
                    You can't run 70' from the xfmr to the first OCPD, as Texie noted. 240.21(C) limits you to 25' to the first OCPD, unless it is in a "Supervised Industrial Installation" per 240.90.

                    The 150A breaker would be fine. It looks like the chart uses the nearest breaker to the 125% rating. 25kva rounds down, 37.5kva rounds up, 50kva rounds down.

                    Comment


                      #11
                      Originally posted by david luchini View Post

                      You can't run 70' from the xfmr to the first OCPD, as Texie noted. 240.21(C) limits you to 25' to the first OCPD, unless it is in a "Supervised Industrial Installation" per 240.90.

                      The 150A breaker would be fine. It looks like the chart uses the nearest breaker to the 125% rating. 25kva rounds down, 37.5kva rounds up, 50kva rounds down.
                      It limits running farther than 25' without ocpd on the secondary. The last sentence states we can't use 240.4(B).

                      Comment


                        #12
                        Originally posted by knifeswitch View Post

                        It limits running farther than 25' without ocpd on the secondary. The last sentence states we can't use 240.4(B).
                        70' is farther than 25'. You can't run 70' from the transformer to the first OCPD.

                        Comment


                          #13
                          Originally posted by david luchini View Post

                          70' is farther than 25'. You can't run 70' from the transformer to the first OCPD.
                          You can run up to 25' without ocpd and longer with ocpd. Where does it limit the run? I'm looking at it now....

                          Comment


                            #14
                            Originally posted by knifeswitch View Post

                            You can run up to 25' without ocpd and longer with ocpd. Where does it limit the run? I'm looking at it now....
                            That's not what 240.21(C) says. It permits you to connect conductors to the secondary transformer, without an OCPD at the point the receive their supply (the transformer secondary terminals), under the conditions listed in 240.21(C)(1) through (C)(6).

                            (C)(1) doesn't apply to your three wire secondary.
                            (C)(2) limits the conductors to 10'
                            (C)(3) limits the conductors to 25' in an industrial application
                            (C)(4) has no length limit where the secondary conductors are outside
                            (C)(5) limits the primary and secondary to 25' for feeder tapped transformers
                            (C)(6) limits the conductors to 25'.

                            You can't run the conductors from the transformer 70' to the panel main circuit breaker. You need and OCPD to comply with the length limit requirements of 240.21(C).

                            Comment


                              #15
                              Originally posted by knifeswitch View Post

                              . I thought I might get helpful answers here...
                              We are trying to help by explaining the requirements of 240.21(C) in addition to your OCPD sizing question.
                              You can solve this by locating the secondary OCPD at the transformer. Then use a MLO panel or just keep the panel with the (now redundant) main breaker if you wish.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X