single phase transformer overcurrent protection less than 600v

Status
Not open for further replies.

petersonra

Senior Member
Location
Northern illinois
Occupation
engineer
:? How does that make it moot? You can still protect the Transformer as "primary only" or "primary and secondary."
Granted that in a legalistic sense you end up having to do both, but most times when you end up being required to have OCPD on the secondary, it is a moot point in a practical matter whether the secondary OCPD protects the xfmr or the conductors. It is going to do both unless the secondary conductors and its corresponding OCPD are way oversized for the actual xfmr secondary current.
 

david luchini

Moderator
Staff member
Location
Connecticut
Occupation
Engineer
It is going to do both unless the secondary conductors and its corresponding OCPD are way oversized for the actual xfmr secondary current.

Not necessarily way oversized. Certainly not way oversized with the OPs transformer.

The secondary conductors could be #8awg with a 40A secondary OCPD (not more than 125%) with a "primary and secondary" protected transformer.

Or they could be #8awg with a 50A secondary OCPD (more than 125%) with a "primary only" protected transformer. The secondary conductor size doesn't need to change at all between the two methods.
 

petersonra

Senior Member
Location
Northern illinois
Occupation
engineer
Not necessarily way oversized. Certainly not way oversized with the OPs transformer.

The secondary conductors could be #8awg with a 40A secondary OCPD (not more than 125%) with a "primary and secondary" protected transformer.

Or they could be #8awg with a 50A secondary OCPD (more than 125%) with a "primary only" protected transformer. The secondary conductor size doesn't need to change at all between the two methods.

In both cases you would end up with OCPD on both sides of the xfmr.

However, as I pointed out, he cannot use the primary OCPD to protect the secondary conductors in this case because it is not a 2 wire secondary.
 

david luchini

Moderator
Staff member
Location
Connecticut
Occupation
Engineer
In both cases you would end up with OCPD on both sides of the xfmr.

However, as I pointed out, he cannot use the primary OCPD to protect the secondary conductors in this case because it is not a 2 wire secondary.

Of course there is an OCPD on both sides in both cases. But with a 50A secondary OCPD, you would have to protect the transformer as "primary only."
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top