lighting contactor

Status
Not open for further replies.

Jraef

Moderator, OTD
Staff member
Location
San Francisco Bay Area, CA, USA
Occupation
Electrical Engineer
My bet is on this being OP's troubles. Perhaps OP needs undervoltage relay wired into the control circuit so the contactor coils are isolated when there is not full voltage.

Fuses as initially suggested might protect the coils, but will still be left with equipment not working just as frequently because of blown fuses. Find the problem, don't just treat the symptoms.

Ding ding ding... We have a winner! :thumbsup:

Something else to look at: if you have mechanically latched contactors, the coils are typically NOT rated to be energized continuously, they are intended to be momentary pulses to open or close. Take a look at your controls to make sure someone didn't screw up.
 

Ingenieur

Senior Member
Location
Earth
You're probably thinking of MV breakers, which sometimes people use as contactors. But that's not a good idea.

standard practice in mining worldwide
a circuit breaker uses the exact same vacuum contactor as a starter
the only difference being the controls

in fact in the starter it serves dual purpose
protection and starting
 

templdl

Senior Member
Location
Wisconsin
Ding ding ding... We have a winner! :thumbsup:

Something else to look at: if you have mechanically latched contactors, the coils are typically NOT rated to be energized continuously, they are intended to be momentary pulses to open or close. Take a look at your controls to make sure someone didn't screw up.
Finally! This is my thought also but the OP provided just enough information to csuse guessing. If the contactor is marginally energized not enough to pull the contactor in and disconnect power to the coil as normally happens with a magnetically latching contactor the coil will fry.
 

Smart $

Esteemed Member
Location
Ohio
...
Something else to look at: if you have mechanically latched contactors, the coils are typically NOT rated to be energized continuously, they are intended to be momentary pulses to open or close. Take a look at your controls to make sure someone didn't screw up.
There are some mechanically held contactors on the market which the terminals are the same as and energized, de-energized exactly like a basic electrically-held relay. Internal electronics develop the pulses for the change of state. Don't recall make and model, but I do recall having run across them in research for a design-build project.
 

iwire

Moderator
Staff member
Location
Massachusetts
A typical contactor's AC coil will draw more current when energized in the open position than it will once the armature has moved and the magnetic circuit is complete. .

Are you sure on that?

I have had AC coils burn out because the contactor was mechanically stuck.
 

iwire

Moderator
Staff member
Location
Massachusetts
Something else to look at: if you have mechanically latched contactors, the coils are typically NOT rated to be energized continuously, they are intended to be momentary pulses to open or close. Take a look at your controls to make sure someone didn't screw up.

Every latched contactor I have wired had internal contacts that open the coil circuit once the contactor changes position.
 

GoldDigger

Moderator
Staff member
Location
Placerville, CA, USA
Occupation
Retired PV System Designer
Why would the coil burn up if drawing less current?
It would burn up while drawing less current if it was intended to be momentarily energized and the break contacts failed.
But if it was stuck in the open or partially closed position it would be drawing *more* current not less.
 

iwire

Moderator
Staff member
Location
Massachusetts
It would burn up while drawing less current if it was intended to be momentarily energized and the break contacts failed.

It was made to be energized, it was an electrically held contactor.

But if it was stuck in the open or partially closed position it would be drawing *more* current not less.

That is what I would expect but seems to be the opposite of what you said above.


Edit, I believe I misread your post. :)
 

mgookin

Senior Member
Location
Fort Myers, FL
I think OP needs to post some part #'s or pictures and give us some voltage readings.
All we know is his contactors are burning out coils.
Being there's more than one, I'd first guess someone put something together wrong.
As someone previously stated, fixing the problem is better than treating the symptoms.
 

rippledipple

Member
Location
New Jersey
Occupation
Electrical contractor
coils

coils

I think OP needs to post some part #'s or pictures and give us some voltage readings.
All we know is his contactors are burning out coils.
Being there's more than one, I'd first guess someone put something together wrong.
As someone previously stated, fixing the problem is better than treating the symptoms.
I know that it is the surge burning them out when power comes back on its the only time it happens!!!
 

rippledipple

Member
Location
New Jersey
Occupation
Electrical contractor
fuses

fuses

My bet is on this being OP's troubles. Perhaps OP needs undervoltage relay wired into the control circuit so the contactor coils are isolated when there is not full voltage.

Fuses as initially suggested might protect the coils, but will still be left with equipment not working just as frequently because of blown fuses. Find the problem, don't just treat the symptoms.
we're ok with replacing fuses,no problem
 

SceneryDriver

Senior Member
Location
NJ
Occupation
Electrical and Automation Designer
I find it pretty common when only one ungrounded line is dead.

I assume it is because they end up with a under voltage backfeed of sorts through other equipment.

Exactly correct. Undervoltage kills AC-coil contactors. If the coil is L-L, and one line is dead, the coil will see ~50% voltage by backfeeding through other loads connected to that phase. It's enough voltage to heat up the coil, but not enough to pull the armature in. Until the armature pulls in, the coil draws significantly more current with its poles open than it does when the magnetic circuit becomes "sealed." The coil typically melts, smells funny, and burns out.

Fusing won't help in this situation at all. Your two options are to use a L-N contactor; if the phase feeding it is dead, it won't work, but it won't burn up. If you must use a L-L contactor, an undervoltage release relay will protect it.

I faced this exact situation a few years ago, albeit with 3-phase power, but the protection concept should be the same:
http://www.plctalk.net/qanda/showthread.php?t=75605



SceneryDriver
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top