for what i think he is doing i dont see any problem with it. i think he ment to say the 3 wire circuit goes back to the panel. if so then you do need a handle tie or a 2 pole breaker to do this. and if you do do this, then the plug is FINE for a disconnect, just that i think you misspoke yourself and put at the SERVICE end of it. no, you didn't mean that did you ? if you did, how do you even DO that?
i read the code site and don't see where you guys are having an issue, other than that he used the word 'service end'.
split recepts with 3 wire is quite common in canada from what i understand and allowable here as well to satisfy the 2 circuit for countertop recept requirement. seems pretty vague right now tho, but there is something in the back of my mind that says i heard in canada they require (somewhere) kit countertops to be wired as above. abody know anything about canukia?