225.39 (D) Pool equipment panel installation

Status
Not open for further replies.

Mt61

Member
Location
Florida
Occupation
Inspector
When installing a pool sub panel on the exterior of a home in Florida, are the feeders required to be 60 amp rated per 229.39(B)?
 

Dennis Alwon

Moderator
Staff member
Location
Chapel Hill, NC
Occupation
Retired Electrical Contractor
When installing a pool sub panel on the exterior of a home in Florida, are the feeders required to be 60 amp rated per 229.39(B)?

No, I think you mean 225.39(D). That section is for feeders or branch circuits that feed an separate structure. It appears you are talking about a sub panel on the same building
 

Mt61

Member
Location
Florida
Occupation
Inspector
Sorry 225.39 (D) is correct. A pool is a separate structure. Conductors are run outside of the main structure to a panel sometimes mounted on the main structure. What I am trying to grasp is #12 thhn conductors run in 3/4” conduit to a 60 amp panel for a pool. Yes it works for the pump and a light, but as soon as you add the additional equipment (pool heater) everything is to small.
I appreciate your replies as it helps all of us!
225.39 (D) not less than 60 amperes
 

retirede

Senior Member
Location
Illinois
Even if you consider a pool a separate structure, I’d think 239(B) would allow a 30A feeder in this case since there are only 2-2 wire circuits.

But I agree with Dennis since the panel is mounted on the house.
 

brantmacga

Señor Member
Location
Georgia
Occupation
Former Child
Sorry 225.39 (D) is correct. A pool is a separate structure. Conductors are run outside of the main structure to a panel sometimes mounted on the main structure. What I am trying to grasp is #12 thhn conductors run in 3/4” conduit to a 60 amp panel for a pool. Yes it works for the pump and a light, but as soon as you add the additional equipment (pool heater) everything is to small.
I appreciate your replies as it helps all of us!
225.39 (D) not less than 60 amperes


225.39 Rating of Disconnect. The feeder or branch-circuit
disconnecting means shall have a rating of not less than the
calculated load to be supplied, determined in accordance with
Parts I and II of Article 220 for branch circuits, Part III or N of
Article 220 for feeders, or Part V of Article 220 for farm loads.
Where the branch circuit or feeder disconnecting means
consists of more than one switch or circuit breaker, as permitted
by 225.33, combining the ratings of all the switches or
circuit breakers for determining the rating of the disconnecting
means shall be permitted. In no case shall the rating be
lower than specified in 225.39(A), (B), (C), or (D).

(D) All Others. For all other installations, the feeder or
branch-circuit disconnecting means
shall have a rating of not
less than 60 amperes.

This code is specifically about the rating of the Disconnect Means, not the minimum feeder size.
 

Buck Parrish

Senior Member
Location
NC & IN
Sorry 225.39 (D) is correct. A pool is a separate structure. Conductors are run outside of the main structure to a panel sometimes mounted on the main structure. What I am trying to grasp is #12 thhn conductors run in 3/4” conduit to a 60 amp panel for a pool. Yes it works for the pump and a light, but as soon as you add the additional equipment (pool heater) everything is to small.
I appreciate your replies as it helps all of us!
225.39 (D) not less than 60 amperes
Are pool heaters common in Florida?
 

Mt61

Member
Location
Florida
Occupation
Inspector
Exactly,
Required 60 amp disconnecting means in the main panel would require 60 amp rated conductors.
Or
30 amp minimum for the two-2 wire branch circuits.
So is a 20 amp breaker feeding #12 wire to a pool panel compliant?
Are pool heaters common in Florida?
yes, very common because of pool screen cages.
 

Buck Parrish

Senior Member
Location
NC & IN
Exactly,
Required 60 amp disconnecting means in the main panel would require 60 amp rated conductors.
Or
30 amp minimum for the two-2 wire branch circuits.
So is a 20 amp breaker feeding #12 wire to a pool panel compliant?

yes, very common because of pool screen cages.
Do they provide shade?
 

Mt61

Member
Location
Florida
Occupation
Inspector
yes. Enough to block the warming of the pool. keeping it from year round use, someone down here from up north would swim in one. LOL
 

Little Bill

Moderator
Staff member
Location
Tennessee NEC:2017
Occupation
Semi-Retired Electrician
Exactly,
Required 60 amp disconnecting means in the main panel would require 60 amp rated conductors.
Or
30 amp minimum for the two-2 wire branch circuits.
So is a 20 amp breaker feeding #12 wire to a pool panel compliant?

yes, very common because of pool screen cages.
Are you asking if a pool panel feeder can be 20A?
 

suemarkp

Senior Member
Location
Kent, WA
Occupation
Retired Engineer
This has been debated multiple times before. I agree that the requirements in 225.39(D) don't apply to the feeder size or source breaker. It applies to either the main breaker in the pool panel or the sum of the breakers in that panel. So if that panel has two 20A breakers, no it isn't enough and you'd need a 60A backfed main if possible in that pool panel or maybe another 20A breaker to something. Another way around it is to remove the pool panel and just run a 20A multiwire circuit from the house and skip the panel at the pool (or just remove its overcurrent devices turning it into a splice box) and maybe just use two snap switches as the disconnecting means (but watch the rules for where that disconnecting means needs to be).

Also note that 225.39 only applies to detached structures. If the pool panel is mounted to a post, it doesn't apply (a post is not a structure). If it is mounted to the house where the source service is, then it doesn't apply. If it is mounted on a detached pool shed, then it does apply and that panel would also need a ground electrode system there.
 

retirede

Senior Member
Location
Illinois
No one in my area would consider a panel mounted on the main dwelling as “feeding a separate structure.” What you have is subpanel on the house that happens to have 2 branch circuits that supply pool equipment.
 

brantmacga

Señor Member
Location
Georgia
Occupation
Former Child
Exactly,
Required 60 amp disconnecting means in the main panel would require 60 amp rated conductors.
Or
30 amp minimum for the two-2 wire branch circuits.
So is a 20 amp breaker feeding #12 wire to a pool panel compliant?

yes, very common because of pool screen cages.

No, that's absolutely not what that means. You can fuse a circuit in a 60A disconnect at any level equal to or below that.

the feeder or
branch-circuit disconnecting means
shall have a rating of not
less than 60 amperes.

Nowhere in there does it say the ampacity rating of the feeder must be 60A. Its the feeder disconnect, not the feeder fuse.



On point #2; if the equipment load calc only calls for a 20A circuit, then yes, that would be compliant. On a pool w/ a 1.5HP filter pump and a pool light, that's plenty. That's actually common now to have a single pump and an electric robotic pool cleaner plugged into a receptacle.

I've wired hundreds of pools in Florida. Maybe 20% of them have heater/chillers. And a 60A pool feeder isn't large enough for 90% of those installs, as the typical MCA of a heat pump is >50A, and usually that pool will have multiple pumps as well. Typical pool feeder for me on a pool w/ a heat pump is 90A-125A.
 

Dennis Alwon

Moderator
Staff member
Location
Chapel Hill, NC
Occupation
Retired Electrical Contractor
I wrote a code change proposal to try and clarify this section because it makes no sense. Why can I run #10 or #12 wire to a separate structure, install a breaker panel and then install a 60 amp main breaker. That is what this section is allowing. When I wrote the proposal they rejected it and said that it is written exactly as they want it.

Again, if the panel is mounted to the building then there is NO code that states 60 amps or, anything else for that matter, is required. It would be the same as a panel mounted inside the structure.

If the feeder went out to a structure by the pool and mounted out there that would be different but the feeder does not have to be 60 amps.
 

brantmacga

Señor Member
Location
Georgia
Occupation
Former Child
I wrote a code change proposal to try and clarify this section because it makes no sense. Why can I run #10 or #12 wire to a separate structure, install a breaker panel and then install a 60 amp main breaker. That is what this section is allowing. When I wrote the proposal they rejected it and said that it is written exactly as they want it.

Again, if the panel is mounted to the building then there is NO code that states 60 amps or, anything else for that matter, is required. It would be the same as a panel mounted inside the structure.

If the feeder went out to a structure by the pool and mounted out there that would be different but the feeder does not have to be 60 amps.

I don't know why this section exists at all.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top