And THAT, Hendrickson, is why we wear hard hats on the job!

Status
Not open for further replies.

LawnGuyLandSparky

Senior Member
36800732.jpg

36830084.jpg

36800992.jpg


New York City crane collapse kills 4

BY ANDREW STRICKLER | andrew.strickler@newsday.com
12:45 AM EDT, March 16, 2008

A crane tower at an East Side construction site toppled out of a blue sky without warning Saturday, killing four construction workers and injuring at least eight, three of them critically, authorities said.

One woman remained unaccounted for Saturday night.

The violent collapse at a site that has drawn complaints from neighbors sent a massive cloud of debris and smoke into the air, damaged buildings and cars, and triggered a rescue effort that stretched into the night.

The construction site has been cited 13 times for violations since January 2006, said city officials, who added that the number was not unusual.

Abeer Shofani, 33, was asleep in a friend's apartment on East 50th Street when she awoke to a sound she described as "big trucks crashing down off a highway ramp."

"I thought it was thunder but it kept going on and on and on," she said. Shofani, a singer, rushed outside to a scene of pandemonium: overturned and smashed cars, pulverized brick and wood, the air darkened with choking dust.

"I walked out in tears," she said.

The towering metal structure, which stood next to a partially completed residential building on the north side of 51st Street near Second Avenue, toppled at 2:22 p.m. under calm winds. As it fell south, the lower section of the tower, about 19 stories high, clipped a corner of a brick residential building across the street, seriously damaging apartments but causing no serious injuries to residents, officials said.

The crash snapped the crane and sent its upper section sailing south, where it crashed into two buildings on East 50th Street and landed on a town house, which contained apartments, offices and a bar. The five-story town house was destroyed.

At least one man in the town house was pulled out alive but seriously injured, while rescue workers continued to search for a woman believed to be inside when the building came down, fire officials said.

"This is going to be a painstaking, hand operation as we try to remove the rubble," said New York Fire Commissioner Nicholas Scoppetta.

The four confirmed killed were construction workers at 303 E. 51st St., where construction crews have built about 19 stories of a concrete-and-metal frame of a planned 43-story residential building. The three critically injured victims were taken to Bellevue Hospital Center, where another person was listed in serious condition, fire officials said. Others were treated at Lenox Hill Hospital and Metropolitan Hospital Center. Five firefighters also sustained minor injuries.

"It is a horrible situation. It's very gory; there is blood in the street," said incoming New York Gov. David Paterson, who arrived at the crash scene just before sunset. New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg called the construction crash "one of the worst the city has had."

Stephen Kaplan, who owns the Reliance Construction Group, which manages the site's construction, told The Associated Press a piece of steel fell and sheared off one of the ties holding the crane.

"It was an absolute freak accident," Kaplan said.

Kerry Walker, a retired iron worker whose family owns the crushed town house, said he had been concerned by the feverish pace of work at the nearby tower. Walker said he recently spoke with his brother about the state of the site. "I told my brother if you don't hear from me next week it's because the crane fell through my house. I was kidding," he said.

A city Department of Buildings official said the crane was inspected Friday and that the agency issued Reliance a variance to use it Saturday to lift a new section to lengthen the tower. The crane was in that process, known as "jumping," when it fell, officials said.

Emergency workers planned to work deliberately to avoid causing further environmental damage and in case there were still missing people in the rubble, a fire official said.

Late Saturday night, a crane was brought in to help in the disassembly of the collapsed crane.

City officials opened a shelter for displaced residents, at a school on East 57th Street. The cleanup effort is expected to take several days.

John LaGreco, 38, the owner of Fubar, which was on the ground floor of the destroyed building, identified one of those injured as Juan Perez, who he said worked as a porter at the bar, which was closed at the time of the accident. LaGreco said Perez was at Bellevue being treated for a broken leg.

"He's one of the core employees of my business and I can't thank the Lord enough for him to still be alive," he said. LaGreco said a female cousin of a seriously injured male resident of the building was missing.

Leslie, 49, who would give only her first name, was standing at East 51st Street and Second Avenue when she heard a metallic "clink-clink."

"It was like rolling clouds of dust and debris down the street," said Leslie, an accountant. "I saw part of the structure flying and I said, 'How do I run fast enough?'"

Sarah Portlock, Patrick Falby and staff writer Sophia Chang contributed to this story.

Video link:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kUVnbJ2Rf5I
 
Last edited:

nakulak

Senior Member
yeah, that's messed up. my condolences for all the families involved.

you don't see tower cranes coming down like that very often, thank goodness.
 

480sparky

Senior Member
Location
Iowegia
No offense, but do you really think wearing a hart hat is going to save you from a 20-ton crane falling on your noggin?
 

LawnGuyLandSparky

Senior Member
No, I don't. But in situations like these, amazingly most deaths and injuries aren't due to the initial accident, but secondary fallout and flying debris. In this case though, the building under construction wasn't in the target zone.
 

cowboyjwc

Moderator
Staff member
Location
Simi Valley, CA
Not to make light of a disaster such as this, as it always strikes close to home. I read today that there may be three more dead.

Once when I was doing an inspection along side of the train tracks, the safety inspector told me that I must wear a hard hat and a vest, being a smarta** I asked "so these will stop the train?" He just looked at me and said "No, but it will make it easier to identify the body.":)
 

tom baker

First Chief Moderator & NEC Expert
Staff member
Location
Bremerton, Washington
Occupation
Master Electrician
There was a tower crane failure in Washington State two years ago and it has resulted in a new set of regulations. Inspection, certificaiton etc. Long overdue as there was no oversight.
There was a death in the tower crane incident, a lawyer for Microsoft in his condo.
All the cranes were inspected and one was found with cracked legs.

Tower cranes are in short supply and they have to be ordered way in advance. That may be part of the problem.
 

LawnGuyLandSparky

Senior Member
tom baker said:
There was a tower crane failure in Washington State two years ago and it has resulted in a new set of regulations. Inspection, certificaiton etc. Long overdue as there was no oversight.

Well in this case the City dept. of buildings just inspected the crane that afternoon and gave it a thumbs up. (I'd hate to be the inspector who signed off on that.)


[/QUOTE]
 

iwire

Moderator
Staff member
Location
Massachusetts
I have been reading a ton of articles about this and as understand it they where moving the crane up to the next level, when a part used for doing this fell and on the way down took out the support for the tower.

It seems this same crane company had a very similar incident not long ago when while moving the crane up on another site they drooped a heavy part on a taxi cab. If the same mistakes where made that is inexcusable.
 

LawnGuyLandSparky

Senior Member
36978432.gif


BY ANDREW STRICKLER | andrew.strickler@newsday.com
8:45 PM EDT, March 20, 2008

A city crane inspector faces felony criminal charges after he falsely claimed to have inspected a crane 11 days before it collapsed on the East Side, killing seven people and causing a wide swath of destruction, city officials said Thursday.

While the city's top building official asserted it is "highly unlikely" a real inspection before the collapse would have prevented the tragedy, critics said the arrest was indicative of the building department's lax approach to inspections.

Edward J. Marquette, 46, a crane inspector with the city Department of Buildings, was arrested Wednesday night after "things didn't add up" with an inspection report he filed on the crane, said Department of Investigation Commissioner Rose Gill Hearn. Marquette had been sent to inspect the crane in response to a complaint that it had not been properly secured.

"According to our investigation, Marquette made false statements on his route sheet, indicating that he had inspected the crane," Hearn said. "He has admitted to DOI that he did not inspect the crane on March 4th."

Speaking near the site where workers spent another day clearing shattered walls and mounds of debris, Department of Buildings Commissioner Patricia Lancaster put distance between the alleged phony report and Saturday's collapse, which killed six construction workers and a Miami tourist whose body was pulled from the remains of the town house.

Lancaster said that most equipment believed to have been directly involved in the fatal collapse was not on the site on the day Marquette was to inspect the crane.

"It is highly unlikely that a March 4 inspection would have prevented the horrific accident," she said.

Building department officials said Marquette's falsified route sheet contained the address, time and type of inspection but no other details. It is the first time he has been disciplined.

Lancaster said she has ordered a "full audit" of Marquette's inspections over the last six months and a general review of his division, which focuses on cranes and derricks.

The construction site at 303 E. 51st St. had 13 open violations when the massive crane, which was being used on a planned 43-floor residential tower, broke free and fell, officials said.

Manhattan Borough President Scott Stringer, who has been a frequent critic of the Department of Buildings, reiterated his call for an overhaul of the department's procedures and personnel.

"I'm tired of this story from the buildings department, that the 13 violations didn't matter, that this false inspection didn't mean anything, that nothing matters," Stringer said. "Maybe we should look at if this laissez-faire attitude towards construction inspections contributed to this."

City Councilwoman Jessica Lappin, who represents the Upper East Side, said she was "beyond outraged."

"A constituent of mine called to complain about a dangerous situation, but this inspector was allegedly too lazy to do his job and as a result people may have died," Lappin said.

The investigation into the collapse has focused on nylon straps that may have given way while a 6-ton piece of steel was being hoisted to "jump" the crane. Inspectors believe the steel may have fallen and broken lower supporting braces. The cause of the accident has yet to be determined.

Department of Buildings officials said previously that the crane was inspected the day before the crash, when it was cleared to undergo the extension on Saturday.

Marquette, who joined the department as an inspector in October 2001, was arraigned yesterday in a Manhattan criminal court on charges of falsifying business records and offering a false instrument for filing. He was released without bail. Both charges are E felonies; if convicted, Marquette faces a maximum of four years in prison. He has been suspended from his $52,200-a-year job.

Marquette declined to comment outside his Manhattan apartment.

The March 4 report includes Marquette's name and states that the 311 caller reported that "the crane does not appear to be braced to the building" and that the "upper part ... is unsecured." The report concluded: "no violation warranted for complaint at time of inspection."

Pervaiz Shallwani and Patrick Falby contributed to this story.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top