Disconnect sizing - When the minimum Disco size is larger than the fuses you need

Status
Not open for further replies.

brstilson

Member
Location
Michigan
I'm having some confusion reconciling 430.110 and fusing.

I'm currently designing an industrial panel being fed by 460/3/60. My loading is thirteen, 2 HP motors. According to my calculations and 430.24, my panel FLA is 45.70. (1.25 * 3.4) + (12 * 3.4) + (0.65 A for control power supplies) = 45.70

I always figure on at least an extra 25% for future expansion, so I'm sizing my conductors to 57.13 amps, which means #6 for the current-carrying conductors and #10 for the ground.

The issue comes when I'm sizing my disconnect. I'm using 430.110. So my first step is 115% sum of all currents at full load. Since these motors are all on Variable Frequency Drives, I remember reading somewhere I should use the drive input rating in that case, which is 4 amps a piece (1.15 * 3.4 is 3.91 anyway). That works out to be 52.52 amps. The thing is, though, according to 430.110 I also have to account for the locked-rotor current, and after re-reading it in the code I don't see any exceptions for inverter-driven motors. So my total locked-rotor current (using Table 430.251(B)) works out to 325.52. Going by that table, I need at least a 50 HP rated disconnect. By amp load, a 60 A disconnect will suffice, but by horsepower rating, I need a 100 A disconnect since the manufacturer I use (Allen-Bradley) only rates their 60 A disconnects at 30 HP and the 100A disconnects at 60 HP.

I don't know the relevant codes, but if I recall correctly, to calculate the correct size fuse for the feeder circuit, I need 150% of the largest motor and 100% of the rest of the loads. So 5.1 + (12 * 3.4) + 0.52 which is 46.42. Next fuse size up is 50A. Problem is, I don't think I can physically install a 50A fuse in a 100A Allen-Bradley fused disconnect. Minimum fuse size there is 70A because it's a 100A class disconnect. Unless there is some kind of adapter I can use.

So what do I do in this situation?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top