Electrical equipment/device failure due to lack of preventative maintenance

Status
Not open for further replies.

bravo69

Member
Location
Fishkill, NY
Hello,

Not sure if the correct section of the forum to ask this question. I am looking for cases or real life events where electrical equipment and devices such as medium voltage and 480V circuit breakers failed due to lack of preventative maintenance (PM). Are there any data on a company, organization, mission critical facility's, etc that showed an event occurred where a circuit breaker failed to trip, or did not properly trip due to lack of or inadequate maintenance?

I am looking for real life events where theses have occurred. For example;

On October 12, 1995, GE power plant in upstate NY, during a routine startup, a medium voltage circuit breaker failed to open automatically to a steam generator. This event occurred due to an overload of a binding latch assembly.

Cause of failure: Subsequent investigation revealed malfunctioning of internal components of the circuit breaker failed due to lack of PM.


Just making this up of course. The reason I am requesting this information is because I am trying to present to my company that lack of PM of electrical equipment/devices can cause failure.

Upon my research I come across case studies with mathematical statistical data but no real life events.

If anyone can point in the right direction that would be great.
 
I have breakers sent into my shop every day that have failed due to lack of PM's. Today I have 28 breakers in production, all of them are here because they failed in some way. More often mechanical binding from worn mech parts or improper lubrication.

http://www.netaworld.org/sites/default/files/public/neta-journals/SurveySays-pg72-74.f.pdf

Thank you. A step in the right direction. Maybe I can contact the author and find out if he can provide data of real life events where equipment failed due to lack of PM.
 
Thank you. A step in the right direction. Maybe I can contact the author and find out if he can provide data of real life events where equipment failed due to lack of PM.

I have a larger more detailed study I can send you, PM me your contact info
 
I have breakers sent into my shop every day that have failed due to lack of PM's. Today I have 28 breakers in production, all of them are here because they failed in some way. More often mechanical binding from worn mech parts or improper lubrication.

http://www.netaworld.org/sites/default/files/public/neta-journals/SurveySays-pg72-74.f.pdf


would you happen to know the frequency of when equipment and devices shall be maintained per manuf's recommendation? Per NFPA 70E (2012) Art 205.3/205.4 there isnt any specific time when they shall be maintained. The manufacturer can dictate 1 yr, 3 yr, 5 yrs doesnt mean the owner has to do it, correct?
 
would you happen to know the frequency of when equipment and devices shall be maintained per manuf's recommendation? Per NFPA 70E (2012) Art 205.3/205.4 there isnt any specific time when they shall be maintained. The manufacturer can dictate 1 yr, 3 yr, 5 yrs doesnt mean the owner has to do it, correct?

Usually equipment specific and listed in the IB. They will typically have different levels of maintenance and intervals (Testing, lubrication, complete overhaul, etc...)

The owner doesn't HAVE to follow those guidelines unless they want to use the exceptions in the 70E tables calling the equipment properly maintained.
 
Usually equipment specific and listed in the IB. They will typically have different levels of maintenance and intervals (Testing, lubrication, complete overhaul, etc...)

The owner doesn't HAVE to follow those guidelines unless they want to use the exceptions in the 70E tables calling the equipment properly maintained.

I apologize but what is IB and what table in the 70E tables are you referring to?
 
Legal Liability

Legal Liability

Depending on the insurance policy, sometimes the underwriters dictate the frequency of the IR scans (usually once a year) and PM maintenance on distribution equip: xfmrs, breakers, cables, ATSs, MCCs, gensets, etc. (every 3 years) These are the people that usually have to pay out after the stuff blows up and/ or someone gets killed :eek: :slaphead:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top