I wanted to confirm my understanding of the feeder tap rule. This question kind of goes along with my other Chiller post but thought I'd post it separately to not confuse topics.
There is currently a 1600A Service entrance switchboard with only a 1600A main breaker which feeds another downstream 1600A MLO switchboard. This existing service entrance switchboard is being upgraded to a 2000A switchboard in order to re-feed the downstream switchboard as well as feed a new 1200A Chiller Switchboard.
Because of space constraints it was proposed that the new service entrance switchboard only have a single 2000A Main breaker and then off of that main breaker there will be two taps to feed the existing downstream switchboard as well as the new 1200A switchboard.
The new 1200A switchboard will have a 1200A main so as long as the feeder cables from the tap are (3) sets of 600MCM (1260A ampacity) then this feeder tap is o.k.
The issue I see is with the feeder to the existing downstream 1600A Switchboard. Because this existing switchboard is a 1600A MLO switchboard the switchboard itself and the existing (5) sets of 500MCM would not be adequately protected by the new 2000A main breaker in the service entrance switchboard. In order to be adequately protected under this arrangement a 1600A main breaker would need to be added to the existing switchboard. Is this correct?
Of course the best solution would be to add two feeder breakers to the new service entrance switchboard but this may not be possible due to switchboard footprint available. All of these switchobards and feeders are located outdoors so they fall under 240.21(B)(5).
There is currently a 1600A Service entrance switchboard with only a 1600A main breaker which feeds another downstream 1600A MLO switchboard. This existing service entrance switchboard is being upgraded to a 2000A switchboard in order to re-feed the downstream switchboard as well as feed a new 1200A Chiller Switchboard.
Because of space constraints it was proposed that the new service entrance switchboard only have a single 2000A Main breaker and then off of that main breaker there will be two taps to feed the existing downstream switchboard as well as the new 1200A switchboard.
The new 1200A switchboard will have a 1200A main so as long as the feeder cables from the tap are (3) sets of 600MCM (1260A ampacity) then this feeder tap is o.k.
The issue I see is with the feeder to the existing downstream 1600A Switchboard. Because this existing switchboard is a 1600A MLO switchboard the switchboard itself and the existing (5) sets of 500MCM would not be adequately protected by the new 2000A main breaker in the service entrance switchboard. In order to be adequately protected under this arrangement a 1600A main breaker would need to be added to the existing switchboard. Is this correct?
Of course the best solution would be to add two feeder breakers to the new service entrance switchboard but this may not be possible due to switchboard footprint available. All of these switchobards and feeders are located outdoors so they fall under 240.21(B)(5).