General SUb-Panel Question

Status
Not open for further replies.

horrorsix

Member
Location
Harrisburg PA
What is the correct way to ground a sub-panel box. I know the ground and neutral must be separated. But does the ground of the sub-panel have to go to the grounding rod or can it ground to the main panel box.
Is a 4 wire feed required from the main to the sub. 2 hot, 1 neutral, 1 ground?
 
1. The subpanel enclosure is bonded to the grounded service conductor at the service equipment.
2. Yes, the egc is for grounding all non current carrying metal parts on the load side of the service.
 
horrorsix said:
What is the correct way to ground a sub-panel box. I know the ground and neutral must be separated. But does the ground of the sub-panel have to go to the grounding rod or can it ground to the main panel box.
Is a 4 wire feed required from the main to the sub. 2 hot, 1 neutral, 1 ground?

"But does the ground of the sub-panel have to go to the grounding rod ....."
When I hear a question like this I realize that the asker doesn't understand the conductor categories.

#1 Ungrounded Conductor, commonly called "phase conductor" or "hot wire"

#2 Grounded Conductor, most often the neutral wire [but also a grounded phase conductor on a corner grounded delta transformer]

#3 Grounding Conductor, commonly called "ground wire"
#3a Equipment Grounding Conductor
#3b Grounding Electrode Conductor
#3c Equipotential Bonding Conductor
#3d various types of bonding conductors, most commonly covered by 250.104

The subpanel is connected to the grounding system thru an Equipment Grounding Conductor back to the main disconnect.

The Equipment Grounding Conductor is required to be run with the other circuit/feeder conductors and can't go "solo" [250.134(B) + 300.3(B)] except in very limited situations such as 250.130(C). . The Equipment Grounding Conductor can not be connected to a ground rod. . Focus on Article 250 part 6 + 7 [250.110 - 250.148] when dealing with the Equipment Grounding Conductor.

The Grounding Electrode Conductor is run "solo" all the time. . It is the one that would be connected to a ground rod. . Focus on Article 250 part 3 [250.50 - 250.70] when dealing with the Grounding Electrode Conductor.

There are very limited situations when you can connect a Grounding Electrode Conductor to a subpanel. . Separate buildings must have to have their own electrode [250.32 + 250.50]. . The panel in the separate building is a subpanel even if you bond the neutral under the conditions allowed before '08 under 250.32(B)(2). . You connect your Grounding Electrode Conductor to the separate building subpanel.

A strip store single service with feeders to individual tenants could be another uncommon example of a Grounding Electrode Conductor to a subpanel. . If there's separate individual metal watermains for each tentant, the tenant subpanel would need to bond its individual watermain [250.52(A)(1) + 250.104(A)(2)]. . But if its a single watermain for the whole strip but distributes from unit to unit in non-metallic, the conductor to your panel is classified as a Bonding Conductor, sized by 250.122, and is not classified as a Grounding Electrode Conductor.

First disconnect/panel on the load side of a transformer, let's not even "go there" right now. . Just get your basics straight first.

Equipotential Bonding Conductor is separate subject. . You'll find it in 547.10 [Ag Buildings], 680.26 [Pools], 680.74 [Whirlpools], 682.33 [Bodies of Water].

"Is a 4 wire feed required from the main to the sub. 2 hot, 1 neutral, 1 ground?"
In almost all situations, the answer is YES.
You have a very limited situation for separate buildings covered by 250.32(B)(2) that allows a 3 wire from the main to the sub. 2 hot, 1 neutral, 0 ground [Equipment Grounding Conductor]. . This allowance/exception to the general rule is almost totally cut out in '08. . For '08 only existing runs can remain, no new 3 wires from building to building [unless the 3 wire is 1 hot, 1 neutral, 1 equipment ground].

David
 
You might be asking why there are multiple categories of grounding conductors. . The bigger picture is to keep your grounding "clean". . If you limit connection between the various pieces to one single connection point, you keep your grounding "clean".

The grounded will carry operating current under normal operation.
The grounding will carry no operating current and only carry fault current during the short time it takes to trip the OCPD.

Ideal is a 5 point "star" connection all coming together in one spot at the service main disconnect.
#1 service neutral from the utility
#2 all circuit/feeder neutrals, grounded
#3 all circuit/feeder grounds, equipment grounding
#4 all solo grounds, grounding electrode
#5 the enclosure can itself

Sometimes the code allows you to deviate from the "star" such as separate buildings under the terms of 250.32(B)(2) up thru 2008 and such as running an electrode conductor to your meterbase instead of your main disconnect. . But the allowances are rare and come with conditions plus don't confuse being allowed to do something with it being a good idea.

The general rule for subpanels is always keep your grounded isolated from your grounding and the enclosure. . And keep your categories of grounding straight. . Each category has different requirements.

David
 
David, I knew the code pretty well but after reading your post I have no clue any more. It is certainly not making things clearer for the OP. :confused:

What is the correct way to ground a sub-panel box. I know the ground and neutral must be separated.

Correct, but we need to be clear so use NEC terms.

Neutral is the grounded conductor.

The 'ground' is grounding conductor.


But does the ground of the sub-panel have to go to the grounding rod or can it ground to the main panel box.

In all cases the grounding conductor (green / bare) must go all the way back to the main panel.

If the sub panel is in a separate structure, like a detached garage then you will have to install grounding electrodes like a service and connect those to the grounding conductor at the sub panel.


Is a 4 wire feed required from the main to the sub. 2 hot, 1 neutral, 1 ground?

Yes, under the 2008 NEC that is required, under previous codes there was a way to do it with a 3-wire feed.

Under the 2005 you could look at 250.32(B)(2).

What code cycle is your area on?
 
horrorsix said:
Not sure what you mean by code cycle.

What particular NEC is your area using, the 2002, 2005, 2008, or earlier?

Roger
 
horrorsix said:
Not sure. Shouldn't everyone use 2008?
You use what ever code that has been adopted by the AHJ for your area. In some cases that is the state and in other it is the local city or county. Some areas are still working off the 2002 code.
 
iwire said:
David, I knew the code pretty well but after reading your post I have no clue any more. It is certainly not making things clearer for the OP. :confused:

I'm at a loss for what you're struggling with. . The difference between grounded and grounding ? . The difference between different types of grounding ?

"It is certainly not making things clearer for the OP."
I can't make it any more simple then what is in the NEC. . If the NEC didn't create different categories of conductors, we wouldn't have to talk about them.

If you don't tell a person about the different between grounded and grounding, how can the requirements be clear ?
If you don't tell a person about the different between equipment grounding and grounding electrode, how can the requirements be clear ?


iwire said:
In all cases the grounding conductor (green / bare) must go all the way back to the main panel.

"In all cases ....." ? . The grounding conductor that the OP mentioned for the ground rod would be the grounding electrode and that wouldn't be taken back to the main panel in all cases.

You can't make something clearer by just oversimplifying. . You end up giving out the wrong info.

David
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top