How do I size a Neutral Grounding Resistor for a Transformer

Status
Not open for further replies.

REFELEC

Member
How do I size a Neutral Grounding Resistor for a Transformer?

Transformer rating : 7 MVA, 22/3.3kV, Fault level : 26 kA.

Please tell me what other data I need to specify for calculating the resistance value of NGR for the above transformer. And how do we normally calculate the NGR value of a transformer.

Thanks a lot in advance. Regards.
 
What Ground fault level ?

What Ground fault level ?

The size of the resistor will be determined by the amount of amperage you are trying to limit it to. 25 amps? 15 amps? 10 amps? 5 amps? 15 amps @ 3.3 kv (assuming 1.9 kv to ground) would be 28,500 watt - I normally size 2.5 X full rating so 71,250 watt with insulators rated 4 kv, and 126.7Ω ......

Edited by Charlie to add the 126.7Ω to the annswer.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Thank you Mr. jcormack

Thank you Mr. jcormack

jcormack said:
The size of the resistor will be determined by the amount of amperage you are trying to limit it to. 25 amps? 15 amps? 10 amps? 5 amps? 15 amps @ 3.3 kv (assuming 1.9 kv to ground) would be 28,500 watt - I normally size 2.5 X full rating so 71,250 watt with insulators rated 4 kv......

Thanks a lot Mr. jcormack for your prompt & useful reply. However my doubt is how do I approach to the problem of calculating / deciding the limiting the ground fault current? If possible, please tell me the way to calculate (in practice) or decide the same practically. If I know my limiting ground fault current at the source generator, will it help?

Thanks a lot for giving your valuable time. Regards.
 
What are you trying to acheive with the grounding impedance? Are you using it maintain continuity of power, and not initiate on overcurrent device? Or, perhaps, are you simply using it to limit fault current in order to help protect your equipment from high levels of fault current? Or perhaps you are doing both?

I know of designers that will set the impedance to the same value of the line to neutral voltage, so under fault condition it pulls one ampere. If this is greater than the charging current of the circuit, it works well. If you have more "noise" on the circuit than one ampere, you would need to set the resistance lower to avoid false alarms. This is assuming you are using the impedance to maintain continuity of power.

If you are simply using the impedance to limit currents and avoid damaging equipment, I would look at the damage curves of said equipment and take it from there.

*Edited for spelling.
 
REFELEC said:
Thanks a lot Mr. jcormack for your prompt & useful reply. However my doubt is how do I approach to the problem of calculating / deciding the limiting the ground fault current? If possible, please tell me the way to calculate (in practice) or decide the same practically. If I know my limiting ground fault current at the source generator, will it help?

Thanks a lot for giving your valuable time. Regards.

The ground fault current should be limited to something above the line to ground capacitive charging current and below equipment damage thresholds.

From a Post-Glover document:

The magnitude of zero-phase sequencecharging
current is determined by the line-toground
capacitance associated with system
components. The value of the current must be
known to properly coordinate the Post Glover
High-Resistance Grounding System.
In an industrial power system where the design
and components are known, the charging
current can be estimated with reasonable
accuracy. With a complex array of machines and
cables this may be tedious and yield less-thanaccurate
results. The discussion that follows
outlines a suitable test for determining the value
of current in a system.
A transformer’s capacitance-to-ground is usually
negligible because of the large spacing between
the transformer’s core and winding, and the
shielding effect of the winding layer adjacent to
the core. Shielding prevents the other winding
layers from significantly increasing the windingto-
ground capacitance. Cable and overhead line
capacitance, on the other hand, can be
significant if the circuit is large.
Major contributions to the overall system
capacitance-to-ground are made by rotating
machines. Attributes such as the type of
insulation and the number and depth of slots
can produce wide variations. A typical value for
a 200-hp, 2300-volt, 1800-rpm induction motor
might be 0.002 microfarads phase-to-ground
capacitance.
The most accurate way to determine the
maximum value of the charging current is by
test, since extreme variations can exist. The
charging current per phase is represented by Ic
while 3Ic corresponds to the total line-to-ground
charging current. To obtain the zero-phase
sequence charging current, a one-phase
conductor is intentionally grounded (Figure 7).
First, an estimate of the total charging current is
required for sizing of the test resistor (Table A).
This estimate does not include the contribution
from surge-protective capacitors.
The test resistor value is found by the following:
R, = 2*(Line-to-Neutral Voltage)
Estimated 3Ic
For example, if 3Ic is assumed to be 3A and
VL-n is 1390V, then the value of the test resistor
Rt will be about 926 ohms.
This example yields an Rt of about 900 ohms.
The resistor should be variable and connected
from one of the phases to ground. The
resistance is used to bring one conductor to
ground potential by progressively decreasing
the resistance to zero. The resistor is sized to
have a short-time current rating of about one
minute and not less than the estimated total
system-charging current 3Ic.
By connecting a portable ammeter in the path
between the grounded conductor and earth
ground, Ic can be read. Conducting the test
under varying load conditions throughout the
day allows more accurate measurement of the
maximum value.

They also list a typical values of charging current:


System Voltage ------- Charging Current (3I c) Amps/10000KVA of Capacity*
480V ------------------------------- 0.1-2.0
2400V ------------------------------- 0.1-2.0
* Does not include surge capacitor contribution

Edited to attempt to attach document...did not work
 
Thanks for the replies..

Thanks for the replies..

Thanks a lot ryan_618 and wirenut1980 for your great answers. It has been a remarkable feeling for me to get quick responses from you people. I was looking for a section where I could say thanks to the Moderators and Administrator for this great site. As I couldn't find any, I wish to express here my gratitude to the Moderators for this great intellectual forum. Regards.
 
ryan_618 said:
You're very welcome, and just because you got an answer doesn't mean you should be a stranger. :)

Thank you for being so courteous...I feel great to be among you intellectual people.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top