Nfpa 72 question

Status
Not open for further replies.
Location
33914
Occupation
Electrician
Hi.I got turned down today for a smoke detector being to close to a balanced air return above a door.Is that considered a forced air supply register?that's all the nfpa 72 warns you to stay away from,besides bathrooms and kitchens.thanks.
 

GoldDigger

Moderator
Staff member
Location
Placerville, CA, USA
Occupation
Retired PV System Designer
The practical problem that the NPFA rule is there to address is a condition where clean outside air is introduced into the protected space near the detector. This could keep the detector from seeing the effect of a fire in the protected space.

In my opinion whether the inspector is justified depends on just what the rate of air flow into the room is during various operating conditions. If with some combination of closed door, window open, an operating exhaust fan, etc. leads to noticeable air movement into the room through that vent then you really should move the smoke, regardless of the letter of the code.
 
Location
33914
Occupation
Electrician
The practical problem that the NPFA rule is there to address is a condition where clean outside air is introduced into the protected space near the detector. This could keep the detector from seeing the effect of a fire in the protected space.

In my opinion whether the inspector is justified depends on just what the rate of air flow into the room is during various operating conditions. If with some combination of closed door, window open, an operating exhaust fan, etc. leads to noticeable air movement into the room through that vent then you really should move the smoke, regardless of the letter of the code.
Thank you for the response.i greatly appreciate that.that makes sense and i think I will just move it and pick another battle another time.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top