Reliability and Beryl

drcampbell

Senior Member
Location
The Motor City, Michigan USA
Occupation
Registered Professional Engineer
The remnants of Hurricane Beryl passed through southeastern Michigan during the past 24 hours. We had moderately heavy rain showers -- maybe one inch per hour -- and didn't have any high winds.

I live in Ferndale, a hundred-year-old neighborhood serviced by DTE. DTE is rather lackadaisical about tree trimming, and they don't use squirrel guards at all.

All morning, I've been hearing arcs, snaps, crackles & pops, each accompanied by a brief (less than one second) outage. Ten or more per hour.

This is not at all confidence inspiring. How did we manage to let America's infrastructure sink toward turd-world nation status?
 

jim dungar

Moderator
Staff member
Location
Wisconsin
Occupation
PE (Retired) - Power Systems
The remnants of Hurricane Beryl passed through southeastern Michigan during the past 24 hours. We had moderately heavy rain showers -- maybe one inch per hour -- and didn't have any high winds.

I live in Ferndale, a hundred-year-old neighborhood serviced by DTE. DTE is rather lackadaisical about tree trimming, and they don't use squirrel guards at all.

All morning, I've been hearing arcs, snaps, crackles & pops, each accompanied by a brief (less than one second) outage. Ten or more per hour.

This is not at all confidence inspiring. How did we manage to let America's infrastructure sink toward turd-world nation status?
Is it really 'third world' if the outages are less than one second?
 

PaulMmn

Senior Member
Location
Union, KY, USA
Occupation
EIT - Engineer in Training, Lafayette College
We let greedy, profit-taking investors take over the control of formerly non-profit infrastructure and medical institutions.
Story goes a man left Blue-Cross/Blue-Shield (somewhere) a decent fortune in his will, because at the time they were a non-profit organization. In the mean time, 'investors' saw all the money BC/BS had in its control and re-arranged things so BC/BS was no longer non-profit. Man's other heirs sued BC/BS; courts made BC/BS return the money, because it was predicated on them being non-profit.
 

Ken_S

Senior Member
Location
NJ
Occupation
Electrician
The remnants of Hurricane Beryl passed through southeastern Michigan during the past 24 hours. We had moderately heavy rain showers -- maybe one inch per hour -- and didn't have any high winds.

I live in Ferndale, a hundred-year-old neighborhood serviced by DTE. DTE is rather lackadaisical about tree trimming, and they don't use squirrel guards at all.

All morning, I've been hearing arcs, snaps, crackles & pops, each accompanied by a brief (less than one second) outage. Ten or more per hour.

This is not at all confidence inspiring. How did we manage to let America's infrastructure sink toward turd-world nation status?
Greed.
 

hillbilly1

Senior Member
Location
North Georgia mountains
Occupation
Owner/electrical contractor
In our area, BREMC does a pretty good job considering the right of way clearing is pretty narrow. Folks complain if they cut it back to where it should be. We have a lot of old growth trees that are much taller than the power lines. The line just in front of my house has been broken and re-spliced many times over the years. Unless it’s a lot of trees and lines down, they can usually get it back on in an hour or so.
 

gadfly56

Senior Member
Location
New Jersey
Occupation
Professional Engineer, Fire & Life Safety
We let greedy, profit-taking investors take over the control of formerly non-profit infrastructure and medical institutions.
Story goes a man left Blue-Cross/Blue-Shield (somewhere) a decent fortune in his will, because at the time they were a non-profit organization. In the mean time, 'investors' saw all the money BC/BS had in its control and re-arranged things so BC/BS was no longer non-profit. Man's other heirs sued BC/BS; courts made BC/BS return the money, because it was predicated on them being non-profit.
Where in the world do you live?!? It certainly isn't Kentucky, because never have utilities been "non-profit" except by accident. In fact, before deregulation, most POCO's, as regulated monopolies, had guaranteed rates of return.
 
Top