SP GF breaker with load polarity reversed - what effect?

Status
Not open for further replies.
PetrosA

PetrosA

Senior Member
Location
Lancaster, Pennsylvania
I had a trouble call last week for some floor receptacles in a basement slab. The GF breaker feeding them had been nuisance tripping at various times, which also killed power to some lights on the same circuit. I found that the wiring from the breaker was reversed - white hot and black neutral, ground was ok. Aside from that, the wiring tested ok with the megger up to 1000V with plenty of resistance (800-1000 Mohms to ground on both white and black). Could the reversed polarity have been causing the nuisance tripping, or should I have swapped out the breaker? I've never come across a GF breaker wired backwards so my experience here is limited :)
 
erickench said:
Was it a GFCI? I thought it was a plain old ground fault breaker.
Click to expand...

Forgive the OP for not using proper terminology, he did use just 'ground fault' in his opening thread, but I thought it was reasonably clear reading it that he was talking about GFCI breakers, when he mentions unfinished basements and receptacles and single pole ground fault breakers as being the involved items with trouble.

I'm sure the devices you are talking about are ground fault protection of services and feeders of 1000 amps or more above 250 volt systems. Maybe he is asking about that but I think there is less than 1% chance of it.
 
I've seen several old houses wired that way, from what I've been told, it was old military electricians. Their color code was white is hot, black is the grounded conductor. Urban legend? I don't know, maybe some old military electricians will chime in.
 
iwire said:
Reverse load polarity should not be the cause of the nuisance tripping. I suspect there is more going on.
Click to expand...

Never wired or seen a GFCI breaker wired reversed polarity, but most of the GFCI receptacles won't set if the conductors are reversed.
 
iwire said:
How would it know?

I think you may be thinking of putting the line on the load terminals not swapping black for white.
Click to expand...

It has an "electric eye" in it and it sees how you wire it.:p

I think that's what I was thinking that you thought I was thinking!:dunce:
 
Sorry for any fuzziness in the OP. It is a 15A SP GFCI breaker that I'm dealing with (Eaton's catalog# would be GFCB115, which is where I came up with the GF - that's just how I keep it in my own head...). It actually is a finished basement with wiring in conduit to two floor boxes, then out to lighting in the bathroom. The basement was finished about 10-15 years ago and the GFCI was the only one with wires reversed, so I don't think it's a case of old school electrician - maybe just Old Grand Dad helping out at the end of the day...
 
PetrosA said:
Sorry for any fuzziness in the OP. It is a 15A SP GFCI breaker that I'm dealing with (Eaton's catalog# would be GFCB115, which is where I came up with the GF - that's just how I keep it in my own head...). It actually is a finished basement with wiring in conduit to two floor boxes, then out to lighting in the bathroom. The basement was finished about 10-15 years ago and the GFCI was the only one with wires reversed, so I don't think it's a case of old school electrician - maybe just Old Grand Dad helping out at the end of the day...
Click to expand...

I didn't think it was all that unclear what you were talking about. Yes GFCI is technically the correct term, but to just say "ground fault" in this trade, or even among non electrical professionals is (almost automatically) taken to mean GFCI, unless you are clearly engaged in a conversation about ground fault protection of higher amperage services and feeders.

The English language is so full of slang, words that sound the same but have different meaning, words that are spelled the same but have different pronunciation and meaning, acronyms, etc. it is amazing we ever get our point across to one another.
 
kwired said:
I didn't think it was all that unclear what you were talking about. Yes GFCI is technically the correct term, but to just say "ground fault" in this trade, or even among non electrical professionals is (almost automatically) taken to mean GFCI, unless you are clearly engaged in a conversation about ground fault protection of higher amperage services and feeders.

The English language is so full of slang, words that sound the same but have different meaning, words that are spelled the same but have different pronunciation and meaning, acronyms, etc. it is amazing we ever get our point across to one another.
Click to expand...

for example--and I am going to use phonetic spelling here--why is it Kan-sas and not Kan-saw or Arkan-saw and not Arkan-sas When the only differance is the Ar ??
 
RichB said:
for example--and I am going to use phonetic spelling here--why is it Kan-sas and not Kan-saw or Arkan-saw and not Arkan-sas When the only differance is the Ar ??
Click to expand...

The pronunciation of Arkansas was made official by an act of the state legislature in 1881, after a dispute between two U.S. Senators from Arkansas. One wanted to pronounce the name /ɑrˈk?nzəs/ ar-KAN-zəs and the other wanted /ˈɑrkənsɔː/ AR-kən-saw.[10]
Click to expand...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arkansas

Now you know.
 
:slaphead:DUH-OH--Never thought of looking there--and I use it alot!!:ashamed:

Thanks !
 
Especially trade words seem to differ. I use two branches of the same supply house 45 miles apart and at one, they know exactly what I mean when I say I want a 1900 box. If I ask for a 1900 box in the other branch, I get the deer in the headlights look from the guys behind the counter. Another strange one is termad vs. TA. None of these are even remotely confusing in comparison to when I was trying to learn the Polish names for electrical stuff, though ;) Here are some direct translations for your entertainment:

3-way switch - stairway contact
breaker - shutoff
switch - contact
fuse - safety
quart halogen lamp - ember
junction/device box - can
GFCI/RCD - current differential shutoff

Needless to say, it took me a while to adjust ;)
 
PetrosA said:
Especially trade words seem to differ. I use two branches of the same supply house 45 miles apart and at one, they know exactly what I mean when I say I want a 1900 box. If I ask for a 1900 box in the other branch, I get the deer in the headlights look from the guys behind the counter. Another strange one is termad vs. TA. None of these are even remotely confusing in comparison to when I was trying to learn the Polish names for electrical stuff, though ;) Here are some direct translations for your entertainment:

3-way switch - stairway contact
breaker - shutoff
switch - contact
fuse - safety
quart halogen lamp - ember
junction/device box - can
GFCI/RCD - current differential shutoff

Needless to say, it took me a while to adjust ;)
Click to expand...

How about military names for things. Only one that comes to my mind at the moment is "screwdriver, cross tip".
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top