Switchboard explosion

Status
Not open for further replies.

hhsting

Senior Member
Location
Glen bunie, md, us
Occupation
Junior plan reviewer
I have very simple question and was wondering if any one can share their experience. Equipment 1200A or over and more than 6 feet i can understand if it explodes it can explode from front however has anyone seen switchboard explode from side end? Has it over done that?
 
I have very simple question and was wondering if any one can share their experience. Equipment 1200A or over and more than 6 feet i can understand if it explodes it can explode from front however has anyone seen switchboard explode from side end? Has it over done that?
So forgive the frustration but i have no idea what you're trying to even ask.
  1. What do you mean by "Equipment 1200A or over and more than 6 feet"?
    1. What does the 6 ft have to do with anything, sorry I'm trying to understand.
  2. "can explode from front however has anyone seen switchboard explode from side end"
    1. Do you mean to say has anyone seen a switchboard explode from the side? And yes, there are records of major explosion's I have seen that exploded on every side to the point the gear was no longer still in the room.
  3. Has it over done that?
    1. See question TWO above please. And again yes at least i have been on one site that a 2000A Pringel Sitch style breaker was faulty and exploded upon use.
 
My simple answer is yes.
Of course it can blow up any side. It was dum dumms resting 500m on the sharp parts of gear.
I ve also seen a top hat completely cooked and blown off
 
If an enclosure has internally, a source and cause for an catastrophic explosive failure, the energy from such will escape from any weakest point. Absent a sufficiently weak point planned into the construction (like a blow off valve in Compressor tank) catastrophic equipment enclosure failure can occur at any point of the enclosure. A normal enclosure is designed only to prevent incidental contact with live parts and to support the internal components not to contain an explosive event. But that being, also the weakest point would be the enclosure's natural openings primary of which would be the equipment door. That is why they make explosion proof enclosure if a sufficient concern of such an event was to be expected and warranted.
This inquiry seems to be related to another inquiry you made similar to the equipment you currently are asking about. If door of enclosure is not aimed toward the egress path you had referenced, and in that the weak point of the enclosure (usuall the equipment door or opening) it would dissipate the majority of the explosive energy away from staircase. A fireball related to an explosive event may however make the person on the staircase within an area susceptible to potential injury from a fireball. But that could be said of any equipment and any egress design and the personnel in the environment from that perspective. Thus approach boundaries in OSHA and NFPA-70E.
 
So forgive the frustration but i have no idea what you're trying to even ask.
  1. What do you mean by "Equipment 1200A or over and more than 6 feet"?
    1. What does the 6 ft have to do with anything, sorry I'm trying to understand.
  2. "can explode from front however has anyone seen switchboard explode from side end"
    1. Do you mean to say has anyone seen a switchboard explode from the side? And yes, there are records of major explosion's I have seen that exploded on every side to the point the gear was no longer still in the room.
  3. Has it over done that?
    1. See question TWO above please. And again yes at least i have been on one site that a 2000A Pringel Sitch style breaker was faulty and exploded upon use.
1200 amp + and 6 feet + has additional requirements in 110.26, presumably because it is typical for this equipment to have higher incident energy possiblities.

And as others have said weakest points of a closure will normally be what gives easiest if there is an explosion within the closure. Often that will be the user/operator access doors on the "front", which is where the 110.26 clearances exist. "Two sided" gear would have "two fronts".
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top