The Big Picture Post

Status
Not open for further replies.

fireryan

Senior Member
Location
Minnesota
I was reading the big picture post by george and there is still a few things I dont understand so forgive me but I am gonna ask. I dont understand why if you were to put voltage to a groung rod why you wouldnt trip the breaker. wouldnt this be a ground fault and what are the dangers of multiple ground to neutral bonding. I guess just in general I dont understand ground and neutral bonding. I just know where to do it but not really why
 

peter d

Senior Member
Location
New England
fireryan said:
I was reading the big picture post by george and there is still a few things I dont understand so forgive me but I am gonna ask. I dont understand why if you were to put voltage to a groung rod why you wouldnt trip the breaker.

Simply put, the earth/ground rod interface has too much impedance (resistance) to trip a breaker at normal line voltages.

However, at utility voltages (7200, etc) a ground rod is quite effective.
 

JohnJ0906

Senior Member
Location
Baltimore, MD
Grounding - as in connecting to the planet earth, and grounding - as in bonding/providing a low impedance path to source to clear faults - these are 2 different things.

Check out 250.4(A)(1 through 5) Read the whole thing. Especially the last sentence of (5)
 

tryinghard

Senior Member
Location
California
fireryan said:
I was reading the big picture post by george and there is still a few things I dont understand so forgive me but I am gonna ask. I dont understand why if you were to put voltage to a groung rod why you wouldnt trip the breaker. wouldnt this be a ground fault and what are the dangers of multiple ground to neutral bonding. I guess just in general I dont understand ground and neutral bonding. I just know where to do it but not really why

Electricity is not looking to return to earth, it is returning to its source. The earth ground connections primary function is to route lightning (static) to earth, static is looking for earth. But because the source is grounded somewhere upstream there is some parallel path of current during an extreme overvoltage situation, ?unintentional contact with higher-voltage lines?. This earth parallel path is usually high resistance and the resistance is unknown at any given moment.

Amperes = Voltage divided by Resistance (I=E/R), higher amperes than the circuit supplying breaker is required to open it, operate the overcurrent protection. 120V divided by 20 ohms resistance = 6 amperes meaning if this short to earth has 20 ohms resistance to its source there will only be 6 amps used therefore a 15A breaker will not open and the short will remain ? dangerous touch voltage will remain.

The danger of multiple neutral bonds is it is a parallel path for current. Voltage will travel all paths to source not only the path of least resistance. It is important to contain the returning current on a conductor and not allow it on other conductive items.
 

JohnJ0906

Senior Member
Location
Baltimore, MD
fireryan said:
Good link md, thanks. I am still not understanding why we bond the neutral and ground at the first diconnect when it is already bonded at poco transformer

You aren't the only one! :grin:

POCOs don't run an EGC. Therefore we have to connect the EGCs to the neutral (or grounded conductor) at the service entrance. Also, the NEC doesn't have any control over POCO installations. They are under the NESC, I think.
 

M. D.

Senior Member
fireryan said:
Good link md, thanks. I am still not understanding why we bond the neutral and ground at the first diconnect when it is already bonded at poco transformer

does anyone have the 1913 ROP from the NFPA??


In 1913, the National Fire Protection
Association?s (NFPA) National Electrical Code (NEC) made
mandatory the connection to earth of any electrical system of
150 volts or less as measured to earth. However, when more
than one connection to earth exists on the same electrical
system, current can flow uncontrolled over the earth, metallic
piping, equipment and through the earth causing problems
with personnel safety, electrical equipment, etc.,

Donald Zipse , would like to do away with the multi grounded neutral system

http://www.mikeholt.com/documents/strayvoltage/pdf/MultiGroundedNeutralFinal5-3-03.pdf
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top