• We will be performing upgrades on the forums and server over the weekend. The forums may be unavailable multiple times for up to an hour each. Thank you for your patience and understanding as we work to make the forums even better.

Tiny RC snubber, LC Filter for GFCI outlets?

Merry Christmas
Status
Not open for further replies.

tersh

Senior Member
Location
new york
What's the tiniest 240v RC snubber or LC Filter have you professionals used in your customers or seen in the industry that one can plug into existing GFCI receptacle that can nuisance trip on any motors.

Kjrbmo.jpg


My elderly bathroom 240v GFCI receptacle kept tripping on the small black electric fan. They want me to remove the outlet, but I need it as backup to the full house GFCI breakers (in case they fail).

However, in the previous discussions with others here. If I add an LC filter, it no longer trip. But the LC filter I had was huge (a long power strip, not appropriate for bathroom used as it can cause shock).

The LC filter works because gar explained it can flatten the energy of the magnetic field.

Btw.. I have a related question. In normal GFCI circuit, it works like this:

QfoD47.jpg


In my case, gar told me to put the ac input to the load side with ac input open. And it still tripped:

yaYgZ2.jpg


Say. Can transient still affect the sense coil even if the input ends are open and no load to cause current flow??

My motor and gfci sample is already with gar however he couldn't test it with oscilloscope yet because of some unrelated problems.
I was not supposed to start this thread and just append to existing gfci threads but then a tiny RC snubber or LC filter to plug into existing nuisance tripping GFCI outlet would be very useful for many to stop all the trippings cause by faulty circuit design (I say faulty because it is possible to design GFCI products that never trip like the Siemens GFCI breakers. This is one reason I want the motor and gfci sample analyzed fully so the nuisance tripping circuit fault design details can be shared to IEEE and they make sure manufacturers would never create faulty gfci products again. Don't you consider it faulty, Nuisance tripping without actual current leakage is not supposed to happen as it can mask real current leakage that one can blame on nuisance tripping. Very dangerous.
 

tersh

Senior Member
Location
new york
By saying it's a 240V GFCI, do we take it that it is outside the US?

Yup. European LC filter or RC snubber will do.

But in the US. What is the smallest LC filter you have seen or available that can be plugged to an outlet with the appliance plugging into the back of it?
 

kwired

Electron manager
Location
NE Nebraska
Occupation
EC
Yup. European LC filter or RC snubber will do.

But in the US. What is the smallest LC filter you have seen or available that can be plugged to an outlet with the appliance plugging into the back of it?
Will the answer really matter since it won't physically plug into your receptacle?
 

tersh

Senior Member
Location
new york
Is even code compliant to have 240V receptacles for general purpose use under the NEC?

Outside the US, it's not controlled by NEC.

Someone just suggested I replace the small black fan. Yeah. The fan has probably shaded pole motor that can cause inductive kickback that can messed up the GFCI circuitry.

This was also the reasons my two fridges tripped twice a day because they have shaded pole motors inside.

Does anyone know of small fan that doesn't use shaded pole motor? Maybe just replacing the small fan will solve it, if there is no tiny pluggable LC filter.

What are the different kinds of motors that are used in small fan? It never tripped on big electric fan that uses normal rotor and stator.
 

tersh

Senior Member
Location
new york
It's an L filter, not an LC, but it's probably small enough for your liking.
http://www.farnell.com/datasheets/2189017.pdf

An LC filter may have excessive capacitive current from hot to ground and may trip a GFCI.

The following LC filger is tested not to trip the gfci outlet:

re9j5n.jpg


o1eoCy.jpg



They marketed LC filter as Surge Protector Device maybe because Metal Oxide Varistor is more expensive or not available:

AxrPKF.jpg


It's selling like pancakes for people who need to protect their equipments from surges. But I no longer use it because the metal frame is not grounded. What if one wires inside contacts the chassis.
 
Location
NE (9.06 miles @5.9 Degrees from Winged Horses)
Occupation
EC - retired
The following LC filger is tested not to trip the gfci outlet:

re9j5n.jpg


o1eoCy.jpg



They marketed LC filter as Surge Protector Device maybe because Metal Oxide Varistor is more expensive or not available:

AxrPKF.jpg


It's selling like pancakes for people who need to protect their equipments from surges. But I no longer use it because the metal frame is not grounded. What if one wires inside contacts the chassis.

Aren’t you using GFCIs? You have no equipment grounds anyway. The energized metal frame will hurt you when touched. Maybe one of the two GFCI products you use will trip, if you haven’t managed to defeat it with add on garbage from a company that makes junk.
 

tersh

Senior Member
Location
new york
Aren’t you using GFCIs? You have no equipment grounds anyway. The energized metal frame will hurt you when touched. Maybe one of the two GFCI products you use will trip, if you haven’t managed to defeat it with add on garbage from a company that makes junk.

I know the product above is junk that's why I'm not using it.

I'm arguing that all GFCI outlets that can nuisance trip from inductive kick and not leakage current are junk too hence must be removed from the market.

I'm saying this because the Siemens 2-pole GFCI breakers never tripped. The only time it tripped was when old circuit were plugged to it and it tripped when there is existing short from wire to concrete.

So all products must be like the Siemens breakers, never nuisance tripping. Is IEEE in charge of the standards. Want to write them and lobby for the removal of all junk gfci outlets in the market worldwide.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top