Tom, Dick and Harry/Don't Complicate Things

Status
Not open for further replies.

jmellc

Senior Member
Location
Durham, NC
Occupation
Facility Maintenance Tech. Licensed Electrician
A scenario I am witnessing that makes me cringe for the customer.

Customer is Tom, he built a new structure across parking lot from main building. Has Dick who manages the phone/data systems. Dick advised Tom to get someone else to run cables to new building, that his co. would have to charge a fortune. He gave a list of needed cables, CAT 5 among them. Tom gets Harry to run the cables. Harry thought CAT 5 was boring, asked "why not run fiber optics?" They called Dick, who wasn't sure about that. After consulting with his boss, he said OK. So Harry ran fiber & various other needed cables. He provided a terminal board & phone switch box, etc. Now, it turns out that some of the terminals & switches in the main phone room are not compatible, so new ones have to be ordered.

I stayed out of that dispute, as I know little detail on data/com eqpmt, but I had a thought that something like this could happen. I ignored it, figured I was inviting trouble. Now I wish I had simply suggested sticking to the plan. Whether Dick's co was on the cutting edge or not, they would be the ones to maintain the system. If they specified a certain cable, that's what should have been installed. Now Tom, the customer, is faced with new delays and further expense. Harry meant well but I think he got too ambitious. He did work very cheap, so Tom won't push him to cover expense of extra stuff.

At any rate, I hope I remember that well enough to put in my 2 cents on a similar situation in the future.
 

ceb58

Senior Member
Location
Raeford, NC
A scenario I am witnessing that makes me cringe for the customer.

Customer is Tom, he built a new structure across parking lot from main building. Has Dick who manages the phone/data systems. Dick advised Tom to get someone else to run cables to new building, that his co. would have to charge a fortune. He gave a list of needed cables, CAT 5 among them. Tom gets Harry to run the cables. Harry thought CAT 5 was boring, asked "why not run fiber optics?" They called Dick, who wasn't sure about that. After consulting with his boss, he said OK. So Harry ran fiber & various other needed cables. He provided a terminal board & phone switch box, etc. Now, it turns out that some of the terminals & switches in the main phone room are not compatible, so new ones have to be ordered.

I stayed out of that dispute, as I know little detail on data/com eqpmt, but I had a thought that something like this could happen. I ignored it, figured I was inviting trouble. Now I wish I had simply suggested sticking to the plan. Whether Dick's co was on the cutting edge or not, they would be the ones to maintain the system. If they specified a certain cable, that's what should have been installed. Now Tom, the customer, is faced with new delays and further expense. Harry meant well but I think he got too ambitious. He did work very cheap, so Tom won't push him to cover expense of extra stuff.

At any rate, I hope I remember that well enough to put in my 2 cents on a similar situation in the future.

It is best,if it doesn't involve you, to stay out of it. Now in hind sight Tom should be looking at Dick since he agreed to the upgrade. Harry was just trying to make a dollar. Dick's position should have been. Pull what we say nothing more nothing less and let it be.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top