Triplen Harmonics

Status
Not open for further replies.

timm333

Senior Member
Location
Minneapolis, MN
Occupation
Electrical Design Engineer
I have a question about triplen harmonics. Triplen harmonics are: 3rd, 9th, 15th, ....
The harmonics generated by variable frequency drive (VFD) are: (5th, 7th, 11th, 13th, 17th, .....)
VFD does not produce triplen harmonics.
As VFD does not produce triplen harmonics, so which equipment produces the triplen harmonics?
 
Quora says: "Single-phase power supplies for equipment such as electronic ballasts and PCs are the most significant source of Triplen harmonics. "

Wikipedia says: "In a normal alternating current power system, the current varies sinusoidally at a specific frequency, usually 50 or 60 hertz. When a linear electrical load is connected to the system, it draws a sinusoidal current at the same frequency as the voltage (though usually not in phase with the voltage).

Current harmonics are caused by non-linear loads. When a non-linear load, such as a rectifier is connected to the system, it draws a current that is not necessarily sinusoidal. The current waveform can become quite complex, depending on the type of load and its interaction with other components of the system. Regardless of how complex the current waveform becomes, as described through Fourier series analysis, it is possible to deconstruct it into a series of simple sinusoids, which start at the power system fundamental frequency and occur at integer multiples of the fundamental frequency.

Further examples of non-linear loads include common office equipment such as computers and printers, Fluorescent lighting, battery chargers and also variable-speed drives.

In power systems, harmonics are defined as positive integer multiples of the fundamental frequency. Thus, the third order harmonic is the third multiple of the fundamental frequency. This type of harmonics is generated in non-linear loads. Semiconductor devices like transistors, IGBTs, MOSFETS, diodes etc are all non-linear loads. Transformers on saturation can also generate harmonics. Electrical motors do not contribute to harmonics generation. Motors needs to reach saturation level to generate harmonics current which is a very very rare occurrence. So semiconductors are the major contributors to harmonics generation. Non-linear loads create disturbances in the fundamental harmonic, which produce all types of harmonics. However, in this section we focus on the 3rd order harmonic due to its certain special characteristics in the context of powers systems.[1]




3rd Order Harmonic Addition

Power is supplied by a three phase system, where each phase is 120 degrees apart. This is done for two reasons: Firstly it is because generators/motors that use three phases are more efficient due to the constant torque the phases supply, and secondly, after power is supplied to a load, the three phases can theoretically be added onto a neutral wire and cancel each other out. This saves the utility from creating return wiring to the power plant. However, if the three phases contain 3rd order harmonics, the currents will not fully add to zero. As seen in the figure, the 3rd harmonic will add constructively with the 3rd harmonics within the other phases. This leads to an oscillating current in the neutral wire, which can be dangerous since it is designed (i.e. small-size conductors) to carry minimal current.[1] To avoid 3rd order harmonics adding together delta connections are used, and the current is cycled around the connection instead of combining into the neutral of a wye connection."
 
Simple one liner: Diode rectification without power factor correction circuits are the largest common source of triplens.
 
As the triplen harmonics of the three phases cancel each other out, so why is it said that the 3rd harmonic is more dangerous than 5th harmonic. I think 5th harmonic is more dangerous than 3rd harmonic, because 3rd harmonic gets cancelled out anyway. Is it correct ?
 
As the triplen harmonics of the three phases cancel each other out, so why is it said that the 3rd harmonic is more dangerous than 5th harmonic. I think 5th harmonic is more dangerous than 3rd harmonic, because 3rd harmonic gets cancelled out anyway. Is it correct ?
No. The triplen harmonics, because of the tripled frequency, peak at the same time.

triplen.png
 
So the reason why VFD does not produce 3rd harmonics is that the motor is wired in delta, is it correct ?

Mostly is that most VFD incorporate pulse width boost power factor correction circuits that supply the DClink.
 
It’s incorrect to say that a VFD does not CREATE triplen harmonics, but in a 3 phase system, they cancel each other out. On a SINGLE phase system they do not. So any kind of non-linear loads such as power supplies, electronic ballasts, LED drivers and UPS connected to a single phase system are where triplen harmonics become problematic.
 
It’s incorrect to say that a VFD does not CREATE triplen harmonics, but in a 3 phase system, they cancel each other out. On a SINGLE phase system they do not. So any kind of non-linear loads such as power supplies, electronic ballasts, LED drivers and UPS connected to a single phase system are where triplen harmonics become problematic.
Wait, triplens, which are zero sequence currents, aren’t carried by the neutral in a three phase system Because they cancel out?
 
It’s incorrect to say that a VFD does not CREATE triplen harmonics, but in a 3 phase system, they cancel each other out. On a SINGLE phase system they do not. So any kind of non-linear loads such as power supplies, electronic ballasts, LED drivers and UPS connected to a single phase system are where triplen harmonics become problematic.
The opposite is true; triplen harmonics are more of an issue on three-phase systems.

Wait, triplens, which are zero sequence currents, aren’t carried by the neutral in a three phase system Because they cancel out?
No, they actually add in phase because of the frequency. Look again at the pic I posted, at the dotted-line column.
 
No. The motor is basically isolated from the power grid by the DC portion of the VFD.
If it a three phase 6-pulse unit the harmonics are 6n +/1. That's where the 5th, 7th, 11th, 13th, 17th come from. To a first approximation, their amplitude is the reciprocal of the harmonic number. But worse if there is no DC reactor.
 
The only thing which I am not able to understand is that how a 6 pulse VFD automatically removes the 3rd harmonic ?
 
The only thing which I am not able to understand is that how a 6 pulse VFD automatically removes the 3rd harmonic ?
It doesn't remove it. It just doesn't create it.
The VFD doesn't draw current in a way that sucks the sin wave in that type of frequency. Due to the 6 pulse rectification, it grabs it power in the 5th, 7th, 11th, 13th, 17th ....
 
Also as there is no triplen harmonic in VFD circuits, so in which circuits does the triplen harmonic exist?
Other types of non-linear loads that do draw frequencies in that way, such as many computer power supplies used to. Now many computer power supplies are power factor corrected, so it is not that big of a deal. So that is why you don't see as much discussion of the accommodations we used to install for triplens, such as oversized neutral conductors.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top