What is My Fault Current?

Status
Not open for further replies.
sparkyrick

sparkyrick

Senior Member
Location
Appleton, Wi
Anyone care to figure the fault current for me. I'm just making sure the inspector isn't messing with me.

208/120 75KVA 3 phase POCO transformer, 3.6% impedance.
3 parallel runs of 350Kcmil Al, 68' tansformer to tap box on service.
 
I ran the numbers and got 5,784 amps at the utility transformer and 5,430 at the tap box.

I used the available fault current calculator that you can download here at Mike's site.

What is the inspector telling you?

Chris
 
Why do you have 750 amps of wire for a circuit with a current of 260 amps? Something doesn't look right to me.
 
sparkyrick said:
Multi meter stack. One 400 serving a resturaunt, two 200A for future build-outs and a 100A house panel.
Click to expand...

Utility companies often size transformers a lot smaller than the service conductor rating. It's a good idea to add some extra AIC rating just in case they replace the transformer in the future. Still, 65K would be a real stretch.

Are you sure the inspector had all the same info. you have? If he doesn't know what size tranformer the utility is installing, or what the impedence is, he is probably figuring everything on a worst case basis.
 
I come up with with 5781 line to line and 8672 line to neutral at the transformer. At those values I wouldn't even worry about further calculations for conductors if you have 10K equipment.
 
sparkyrick said:
He's telling me I need to add a 65K main breaker inside my SqD panel, trying to tell my the available fault current is 65K.
Click to expand...

Just divide the transformer secondary FLA by the impedance to get a first approximation - 75 kVA @ 208V = 208A. 208A/0.036 = 5,787. If the 400A service feeds a 400A motor, the motor contribution would be about 400A x 4 or 1,600A. The most conservative estimate I can make for this service is 5,787 + 1,600 = 7,387 A. 65 kAIC makes no sense at all.
 
steve66 said:
Utility companies often size transformers a lot smaller than the service conductor rating. It's a good idea to add some extra AIC rating just in case they replace the transformer in the future. Still, 65K would be a real stretch.
Click to expand...

The utility serving the OP uses 'design level' fault currents for determining the SCCR rating of service entrance equipment 9I live in their coverage area). They do not care about what is installed today, they are worried what their transformer may be sized as in the future. The OP said (1) 400A +(2) 200A meters

Assuming 800A service 208V:
If the utility is WPS, they would say the SCA could be 42,100, which would require 65kAIC equipment.
If the utility is We Energies, it is hard to guess their design level, but I have seen 29,700A.
Xcel Energies would list it as 52,100A

So what is the utility, and how big of a service did you order?
 
jim dungar said:
The utility serving the OP uses 'design level' fault currents for determining the SCCR rating of service entrance equipment 9I live in their coverage area). They do not care about what is installed today, they are worried what their transformer may be sized as in the future. The OP said (1) 400A +(2) 200A meters

Assuming 800A service 208V:
If the utility is WPS, they would say the SCA could be 42,100, which would require 65kAIC equipment.
If the utility is We Energies, it is hard to guess their design level, but I have seen 29,700A.
Xcel Energies would list it as 52,100A

So what is the utility, and how big of a service did you order?
Click to expand...

I found out the fault current of the service equipment is specified by the power company, Alliant Energy. I talked with a rep today and he said 3 phase commercial services up to 800 amps require AIC rating of 42,000 and services over 800 amps require AIC ratings of 65,000. The inspector was stating their requirements, but did so in such a way that made it sound like his requirement.

Thank you everyone for the input. I'm changing the panel tomorrow to a main breaker panel with a 65K main, plus a few more breakers will need to be 22K rated (sub-panel, and roof-tops).
 
sparkyrick said:
I found out the fault current of the service equipment is specified by the power company, Alliant Energy. I talked with a rep today and he said 3 phase commercial services up to 800 amps require AIC rating of 42,000 and services over 800 amps require AIC ratings of 65,000. The inspector was stating their requirements, but did so in such a way that made it sound like his requirement.

Thank you everyone for the input. I'm changing the panel tomorrow to a main breaker panel with a 65K main, plus a few more breakers will need to be 22K rated (sub-panel, and roof-tops).
Click to expand...

But that number should only be what is available at the transformer terminals. Length, size and type of conductors after the transformer are still going to drop what is available at the load end of those conductors:(

In your case there was not a really long run but it was long enough that 42K rated equipment would likely still be ok if they ever did install a transformer with a full load rating approximately same as service equipment capacity.
 
kwired said:
Length, size and type of conductors after the transformer are still going to drop what is available at the load end of those conductors:
Click to expand...

Can that reduction use the actual distance from the service transformer, or would you have to only use the minimum distance from the POCO right of way to the
panel, in case POCO decided to move the transformer or put in a new one? :huh:
 
kwired said:
But that number should only be what is available at the transformer terminals. Length, size and type of conductors after the transformer are still going to drop what is available at the load end of those conductors:(

In your case there was not a really long run but it was long enough that 42K rated equipment would likely still be ok if they ever did install a transformer with a full load rating approximately same as service equipment capacity.
Click to expand...

I agree that 42K should be just fine, but my hands are tied because of their requirements. Maybe it's for when that 75KVA poco transformer smokes and they have to install a bigger one :)
 
kwired said:
But that number should only be what is available at the transformer terminals.
Click to expand...

Be careful, many utilities provide fault currents which are based on some amount of secondary conductors. Make sure you understand their reference point. The WPS value in my example was for 50' of their sized conductor, if the transformer were closer the fault current would be higher, while the Xcel example was at the terminals.
 
jim dungar said:
Be careful, many utilities provide fault currents which are based on some amount of secondary conductors. Make sure you understand their reference point. The WPS value in my example was for 50' of their sized conductor, if the transformer were closer the fault current would be higher, while the Xcel example was at the terminals.
Click to expand...
Good point. If asking POCO for a value, you need to know just what point that value is valid for. If you have conductors between that point and equipment that needs to be rated for interrupting capacity then you will have a lower available fault current at the load end of those conductors.

I guess I can understand there may be local rules that may say you need equipment rated at a higher level like in the OP's install where the service capacity is much higher than the output rating of the supplying transformer. Or it may even be a reasonable design practice to figure you may need higher rating some time down the road and install proper rated equipment now. NEC has no such rule though.
 
kwired said:
NEC has no such rule though.
Click to expand...
You are correct.

However, many electricians need to remember, the NEC is not the one 'allowing' equipment to be connected to its grid. The NEC and the AHJ don't come into play until there is an have an approved service point.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top