Yes it's while using an ATS. I know what should be done but that's not the question. My question is can you use a 20kw gen with an ATS under the 2005 code to power a 200amp residential service. Inspector is making me do a load calculation but I feel it's not required under the 2005. Again we all know what should be done but is it allowed under this code. The ATS has a 200 amp service rated disconnect in it, if it draws more then it should what's the worse that can happen it will trip the gen breaker.
Well, if you're lucky it will trip the breaker. If you're unlucky, your load might be large enough cause the generator to go in an undervoltage condition and maybe damage some appliances, unless it has an undervoltage trip.
From the 2005 Edition:
702.5 Capacity and Rating. An optional standby system
shall have adequate capacity and rating for the supply of all
equipment intended to be operated at one time. Optional
standby system equipment shall be suitable for the maxi-
mum available fault current at its terminals. The user of the
optional standby system shall be permitted to select the
load connected to the system.
If you intend to comply with 702.5 and it's for the whole house, how do you know it has adequate capacity without doing a load calculation? In point of fact, even if you're doing only 1 or 2 loads, you still need to do a calc to comply.