High lumen recessed

electrofelon

electrofelon

Senior Member
Location
Cherry Valley NY, Seattle, WA
Hey guys, I have a lab I need to provide and install lighting for. Owner wants recessed. We typically install about 85-90 lumens per SQ foot for these spaces. The framing is 16" OC, so I am looking at maybe an 80" pattern which puts me at 3500-4000 lumens per fixture. I'm not dead set on that 80", but I don't want to install 3.74 zillion fixtures either. Here are a couple products I am looking at:

3200 Lumen Max, 40W Max, Wattage and Color Selectable Architectural LED Light Engine, 27-34-40W, 3000-3500-4000K, Trim Sold Separately, 120-347V, PLT PremiumSpec, PLT-90288 | 1000Bulbs.com

Select the perfect color, brightness, and accessories with this PLT PremiumSpec LED downlight. Go to 1000Bulbs.com for more housing-free downlights!
www.1000bulbs.com www.1000bulbs.com

www.superbrightleds.com

8" LED Commercial Recessed Downlight - Selectable CCT - Selectable Wattage - Dimmable - Up to 3,960 Lumens

The 8" LED commercial recessed downlight is a versatile lighting solution for commercial and residential spaces. The fixture has two slide switches; one selects from five CCT options and one from three wattage options. Spring clips allow for easy installation in commercial downlight frames. The...
www.superbrightleds.com www.superbrightleds.com


Any opinions on these or any other ideas?
 
L

letgomywago

Senior Member
Location
Washington state and Oregon coast
Occupation
residential electrician
electrofelon said:
Certainly a possibility. Was just trying to keep the number of fixtures down a bit, not just for labor but also didn't want the ceiling to look too busy. Would give me a lot more options though going with 6's.
Click to expand...
I personally think in high lumen areas 48" centered cans look best. It gives more even light. Its really fast to lay out. And yes more fixtures but not so much to be busy and you can set the ladder to work on 2 at a time so to me the labor is about the same only slightly more than one that needs it moved twice to set a fixture and wire it up. If using a lift the cutoff is 72in where you can set a can and wire between it and the last can if daisy chaining.
 
electrofelon

electrofelon

Senior Member
Location
Cherry Valley NY, Seattle, WA
letgomywago said:
I personally think in high lumen areas 48" centered cans look best. It gives more even light. Its really fast to lay out. And yes more fixtures but not so much to be busy and you can set the ladder to work on 2 at a time so to me the labor is about the same only slightly more than one that needs it moved twice to set a fixture and wire it up. If using a lift the cutoff is 72in where you can set a can and wire between it and the last can if daisy chaining.
Click to expand...
Good points thanks. Have you done something like this before in a big space? This is prolly 50x60
 
Knightryder12

Knightryder12

Senior Member
Location
Clearwater, FL - USA
Occupation
Sr. Electrical Designer/Project Manager
electrofelon said:
Hey guys, I have a lab I need to provide and install lighting for. Owner wants recessed. We typically install about 85-90 lumens per SQ foot for these spaces. The framing is 16" OC, so I am looking at maybe an 80" pattern which puts me at 3500-4000 lumens per fixture. I'm not dead set on that 80", but I don't want to install 3.74 zillion fixtures either. Here are a couple products I am looking at:

3200 Lumen Max, 40W Max, Wattage and Color Selectable Architectural LED Light Engine, 27-34-40W, 3000-3500-4000K, Trim Sold Separately, 120-347V, PLT PremiumSpec, PLT-90288 | 1000Bulbs.com

Select the perfect color, brightness, and accessories with this PLT PremiumSpec LED downlight. Go to 1000Bulbs.com for more housing-free downlights!
www.1000bulbs.com www.1000bulbs.com

www.superbrightleds.com

8" LED Commercial Recessed Downlight - Selectable CCT - Selectable Wattage - Dimmable - Up to 3,960 Lumens

The 8" LED commercial recessed downlight is a versatile lighting solution for commercial and residential spaces. The fixture has two slide switches; one selects from five CCT options and one from three wattage options. Spring clips allow for easy installation in commercial downlight frames. The...
www.superbrightleds.com www.superbrightleds.com


Any opinions on these or any other ideas?
Click to expand...
Why don't you go with a 2x2 flat panel? You could do a lot better light layout and get a better distribution with a 2x2 then a can.
 
electrofelon

electrofelon

Senior Member
Location
Cherry Valley NY, Seattle, WA
electrofelon

electrofelon

Senior Member
Location
Cherry Valley NY, Seattle, WA
Ok guys well I settled on these fixtures:

2640 Lumen Max, 30W Max, Natural Light, 8 in. Selectable New Construction LED Downlight Fixture, Hardwire, 2700-3000-3500-4000-5000K, Round, White Trim, 90 CRI, 120-277V, Halco 88986 | 1000Bulbs.com

Spread versatile lighting throughout your home easily with this selectable LED downlight by Halco. Find more ceiling mount fixtures at 1000Bulbs.com!
www.1000bulbs.com www.1000bulbs.com

I like that they have a whip built in and have 0-10 dimming. We havnt dimmed any of the other labs, but I will probably do it here since it is minimal extra work.

I didnt realize but 1000bulbs has a nice lighting layout tool, here is a picture of what I am leaning towards. Basically its a 64" pattern. That is only half the space, separated by a soffited HVAC duct. Other half is a bit funkier, has some bumpouts and different dimensions, but mostly the same.
 

Attachments

  • layout.jpg
    layout.jpg
    117.7 KB · Views: 16
electrofelon

electrofelon

Senior Member
Location
Cherry Valley NY, Seattle, WA
Ok update:

We changed to these lights:


These have substantially more at 5200 lumens each. I think I can reduce the number of lights. If i bumped up to an 80" pattern, that would be 9x4 and about 115 lumens /sq ft which seems about right (I know i said 85-90 in the OP, but I cant remember the exact lights we used there. They could have been as high 123 lm/sq ft, or the next one would be 103). I am concerned with having them be annoyingly bright to look at however, which makes me wonder if I should stick to the 64" pattern and dim them down. That is 19 more lights to make up though. Advice? 😟 :unsure:
 
G

Geber

Member
Location
Vermont
Occupation
PE, retired electronics engineer
I would expect a lab to have many computer screens. A fixture with a more downward pattern may create less reflections on the screens.
 
electrofelon

electrofelon

Senior Member
Location
Cherry Valley NY, Seattle, WA
I think I am going to stick with the 64" spacing even though that is more light than we need. I would rather have more and dim them down. I did a mock up of one row today, and they are a bit bright to look at. The mock up is the 64" spacing, it would be 4 fixtures for the 80"
 

Attachments

  • lights.jpg
    lights.jpg
    189.3 KB · Views: 21
F

farmantenna

Senior Member
Location
mass
those fixtures you posted are some of the brightest recessed I've seen. The one at 1000bulbs is cheap, too. Wow! How high are the ceilings?
 
F

farmantenna

Senior Member
Location
mass
I had to upgrade the recessed lighting in a new, brand new, multimillion dollar home because the EContractor installed 4" GU10 LED fixtures with 480 lumens in a 20-22' ceiling!
 
F

farmantenna

Senior Member
Location
mass
wow! that is going to be extremely bright! I would make sure they are sure they need those lumens and install 0-10 dimming wire just in case.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top