3 ways

Status
Not open for further replies.
Re: 3 ways

Roger being another one that has to deal with nonenglish speaking shoddy tradesmen (has nothing to do with lack of speaking english more to do with there work.) I would not work for someone who is in this country but choses not to speak the adopted language of this country. If I chose to relocate to a foriegn country I would do so only after having learned enough of that countrys language to handle my daily job tasks. I have also taken a spanish language course to simpily try to speak to them on a daily basis. It is simple respect to learn anothers language. I have no problem with one bettering himself just give me and others in the field the common courtesy of speaking this countrys adopted language
 
Re: 3 ways

Southernboys, don't be like many and post without reading others posts.

Did you read the information provided in the link or were you just in a hurry to post?

Roger
 
Re: 3 ways

Would i work for a spanish speaking foreman.NO,NOWAY.Why would i even think of learning spanish if he came to this country and didn't think he should learn english ? Has nothing to do with race and everything to do with speaking english. :mad:
 
Re: 3 ways

Jim, you obviously didn't read the information in the link either.

Roger
 
Re: 3 ways

Well Jim, what don't you understand about this,
as well as build their working vocabulary in English.
wouldn't you think this would mean they would be speaking english when they gave you your instructions for a task?

BTW, remember you are an immigrant to FL from the North. :D

Roger

[ December 25, 2005, 09:15 PM: Message edited by: roger ]
 
Re: 3 ways

For my own safety i want to understand and be understood by my coworkers.Roger,can you risk a fellow worker not understanding your directions ? This is not about race but simply speaking same language.If the whole crew speaks spanish then fine no problems.
 
Re: 3 ways

Once again, what don't you understand about this
as well as build their working vocabulary in English
?

Roger
 
Re: 3 ways

" as well as build their working vocabulary in English."
Just what does that mean ? They either speak english or they don't.If still learning then let them work with you and not me.
 
Re: 3 ways

Originally posted by roger:
Just a different perspective on the immigrant stance.

Rick, let's say on the day you immigrated to FL from the North a (legal) Spanish speaking person from the South did too, who has more of a right to be there?

Now, let's say he is a graduate of This Tech School and is a master in the knowledge of the trade, would you or Jim work for him?

Not trying to start anything with the questions, just asking.

Roger
firstly what i want everyone to realize is that i did not intend to turn this into an anti spanish speaking campaign. living in south florida i have a great deal of respect for spanish speaking people and many of them are my friend. my reference to our mexican crew was meant to be an icon. it was just one experience that i had that others across the country in this profession have daily. i am not talking specifically about a language barrier, i'm talking about ignorance. ignorance to think you can float through it all because its a job. ignorance to think that you know everything. ignorance to think you can do as you please. ignorance to be ignorant.

ignorance is consuming almost everything in the world today and our trade is not exempt. that is where my problem lay.

if me and a spanish speaking person immigrated to florida at the same time and applied for the same job i would expect the most qualified for the position applied for to get the job. by most qualified i am not talking only about the technical aspects of the job. there are many more angles to being a productive employee then simply doing the task at hand. you are a direct representation of your company, of your trade, of yourself. your social manifestation is as much important to your everyday job duties as your technical knowledge.

the link you provided is a prime example of someones ability to rise above ignorance. i would be more then happy to work with anyone who went through that program simply because they are trying. in fact i would be willing to meet them in the middle and learn spanish so i can better help them. just the simple effort on thier part even null of thier actual abilities shows me someone who legitimatly wants to be doing what they are doing.

my problem is with the people who do not put forth the effort, and i am not only talking about language now. the plain truth is nobody can help you unless you want help. white guys who cant wire 3 ways, or hispanics who cant wire them it doesnt matter. its the people white, hispanic, black, indian etc.. who treat this as an 8-3:30 job and cant wait for lunch and then cant wait for the day to be over that i do not want around me and i do not want to help. how can i work with them, for them, or over them if they do not mutually wish the same?

i know this is going to be a hell of a bad example but look at rap music. why can someone play sweet home alabama 20 years after it was made and people say nothing about it. and in the same repect someone plays a rap song from 2 years ago and its old news and people look like what the hell are you playing that for? because rock music has traditionally been treated as an art while rap music is marketed as a product.

as bizarre as it sounds in my period of time in this trade which is eclipsed by many of our other members i see the same thing, only a transition. what once was considered an art in respect is now being formed into a product. with that transition your finding an inrush of the ignorant.

a good quote that makes me put the whole thing retrospect

"thier once was a dream that was rome"

sounds corny as hell but its how i feel.

as a side note i chose this profession in my junior year of college for organic chemistry. i love what i do and no matter how bad it may become i will continue to do it and defend it.
 
Re: 3 ways

Gee Jim, it's debateable if many here speak (or at least type in) english, so what's your point?

Didn't you say "Blowed" a while back? :roll:

Roger
 
Re: 3 ways

more quotes in reference to how i have ruined this thread.

I am become Death, the Shatterer of Worlds.
The Bhagavad Gita

I fear all we have done is to awaken a sleeping giant
Admiral Isoroku Yamamoto
 
Re: 3 ways

Rick, thank you for your reply. I agree and offer my respect to you for your views and stance.

Roger
 
Re: 3 ways

IMO, the recent influx of hispanics flooding into our country is no different than other immigrations in history, and the people who take advantage of them are no different today than those who took what the Chinese and Irish and others had to offer, and gave them a slap in the face for their labor.

From then to now, the government and society at large, both here and abroad, have slowly attempted to stop this abuse, but it is one caveat of the free market system that requires constant supervision and an educated populace to control.

If it were fixed with the stroke of Lincoln's pen, or Theodore Roosevelt's, or anyone who has sat in that chair since, we wouldn't have this issue today. But it exists, and requires management the same now as it did then.

Employers need to not dip there finger into that illegal pie voluntarily, and the courts need to punish those that do.

It's not about race or lack of education: it's about the rape of an undervalued group of people, which has been practiced probably since man entered the stone age. It's an inherent component of our nature, bred for thousands of years.

We will never be able to eliminate it, but oh boy, can we make it painful to practice. There's a vested interest in it for every legitimate business: If legitimate businesses don't report unethical business practices, then they will lose business to the unethical businesses. The unethical ones have a distinct market advantage, their illegal labor is half the cost.

Enough of a sermon, my point's across.
 
Re: 3 ways

Roger, let's try it this way.If half of the post here were in spanish what would happen ? For some reason you support speaking spanish.Maybe someday soon you will see this happening where you live.I don't mean dealing with 2 or 3 on a job site.I am talking about it hitting over 50 %.I have had some great helpers that were cubans,but they did one thing that made them great and that was learning to speak english.The same guy that can't or won't speak english is of no value to me.He might work out fine with someone who will learn spanish.
 
Re: 3 ways

Originally posted by jimwalker:
For some reason you support speaking Spanish.
Please enlighten me, where have I "supported" this?

Once again, it appears as though you read things the way you want them to be.

It may not just be a problem of understanding Spanish Jim.

Furthermore, many of our sheet-rockers, block masons, landscapers, roofers, asbestos abater's, painters, carpenters, plumbers and electrical workers are Mexicans, so quit giving us that "if they were in your area" spiel.

Roger
 
Re: 3 ways

;) I just wanted to say , we all learned spanish so we could communicate better with not only our workers but some of our customer base as well...
I agree that if you move to a country you should know or learn the language but we dont live in a perfect world... so sometimes we have to adjust.

Anyway...isnt this the 3way board? I didnt realize switches were language dependant......
Just a joke guys. Happy New year to you all
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top