Bath fan exhaust into attic space

Status
Not open for further replies.
Here's an interesting hypothetical: say the OP is responsible for just the fans, so he installs standard 50-60cfm fans. Inspection fails (exhaust vented to attic) but it's mechanical, not electrical. So an HVAC co puts in new ductwork to the eaves. Ductwork is up to code, however the inspection fails again because the airflow rate is not the minimum 50 cfm intermittent. Who is now on the hook for the job, the EC who put in the fans, or the HVAC who did the ductwork?
To be honest with you, in all my years doing this I have never had an inspection where an AHJ checks the exhaust volume. From what I'm told an architect spec'd these fans and that's what's going in. I don't remember the model # but I will get it on monday and I'll post it here. I do know they were purchased from HD by the property management and are fan/light units.
 
My question is, was it ever an acceptable practice to vent bathroom air and moisture into attic spaces ? I contacted the NJ Div of Codes and Standards who basically referred me to the local AHJ for his opinion. I'm hesitant to contact him because I'm sub-contracting for another contractor on this job. It should be his place to make that call. I was just curious to know if any of you had an opinion on this. Thanks.

In Jersey Did a bath in 88 The inspector said to me there was a time when bath exhaust could be vented into a non habitable attic space. Not sure the year it was permitted but that's what he told me.
 
In Jersey Did a bath in 88 The inspector said to me there was a time when bath exhaust could be vented into a non habitable attic space. Not sure the year it was permitted but that's what he told me.

It's certainly not the case anymore. I know when I was looking to buy a house in 1986 that one of the properties I looked at was a converted lake house (seasonal) that had the stack vent in the attic. The sheets of plastic everywhere suggested there was an issue, and the inspection report I received indicated that this was a deficiency. I suppose it might not have been much of a problem if the attic was very "leaky" so that there was no buildup of moisture, but I'd think that warm moist air + attic in winter = rain in the space. Maybe if it froze fast enough...:(
 
You cannot vent exhaust fan into the attic. That's residential code but you can vent it all the way over to the screens on the eaves


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I can't say I know what codes are but basic physics tells me that the properties of convection that naturally ventilate that attic will draw that humidity back into the attic space anyway, so why bother ducting it to the eaves? When it is cold enough maybe you get some of it to condense before it is drawn into the attic is about the only advantage I see, but this is mostly when there is extreme cold of like zero and below temps.

It's certainly not the case anymore. I know when I was looking to buy a house in 1986 that one of the properties I looked at was a converted lake house (seasonal) that had the stack vent in the attic. The sheets of plastic everywhere suggested there was an issue, and the inspection report I received indicated that this was a deficiency. I suppose it might not have been much of a problem if the attic was very "leaky" so that there was no buildup of moisture, but I'd think that warm moist air + attic in winter = rain in the space. Maybe if it froze fast enough...:(
In extreme cold conditions I have been in attics that have frost coating the underside of the roof, that all "rains" down when temps rise enough to thaw it. Similar happens frequently in non insulated steel buildings where someone is using non ventilated portable heaters, water vapor in the exhaust of those heaters condenses on cold steel roof and rains on the inside of building when it does reach melting temperature.
 
If you do a good job attaching it and make sure it's vented to the outside I suppose some of it might return and go up into the vents but I do believe you'll be code compliant. Doesn't sound like OP has a lot of options. Punch a hole in the roof maybe put on the whirlybird vent.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top