Battery backup only

I agree with JB. That's what got me thinking about this, I mean you're probably looking at 10K minimum for a small generator installed, maybe more for gas hookup. If you're not looking to back up a lot of load, I think battery would be competitive.
Keep in mind the OP said "portable generator" so we are not talking about having to install a generator, connect a gas line, and wire it into the house electrical system. We are talking about a smaller generator that can either be carried or is on a wheeled cart. Connect that with an extension cord to the refrigerator and a few backup loads and I do not think you are going to get a permanently installed BESS wired into the house with an ATS cheaper.
The whole concept also depends on how often and for how long someone needs backup. In the last five years there has been one time when my power was out for more than a few hours. For me the cost to install any kind of fixed backup is way more than the usage I will get out of it. For me a small portable generator that can sit untouched for years in my garage and was just enough to run the refrigerator and a few lights would be more than enough. Now for someone who has a week long blackout once a year they should be looking at a more permanent fixed generator wired into the house to get a whole house backup. A BESS would be a good consideration here.
 
Last edited:
Keep in mind the OP said "portable generator" so we are not talking about having to install a generator, connect a gas line, and wire it into the house electrical system. We are talking about a smaller generator that can either be carried or is on a wheeled cart. Connect that with an extension cord to the refrigerator and a few backup loads and I do not think you are going to get a permanently installed BESS wired into the house with an ATS cheaper.
I think you might be mixing up with a different thread?
 
I think you might be mixing up with a different thread?
Yeah, the other thread. But the points are similar. Whole house backup, BESS or generator. I have yet to see anyone run the numbers and show that a BESS costs less than a generator for this application. It would be great if it worked out. And I'll stick with, it depends on utilization. A backup that is needed once every 5 years for a couple of days to keep food in the fridge from going bad is going to be different than a whole house backup that is needed every year for a week. If the homeowner has money to burn, and there are plenty of high net worth homeowners out there, then they can have a whole house backup BESS that they never use but talk about at parties.
 
I would go with either Sol-Ark (with a Discover Helios battery), FranklinWH, or Tesla. We have done lots of all three of these. But there are loads of other options out there.
 
Way too many IMO, I dread what will happen when a bunch of them go out of business and leave customers hanging.
Customers who like to walk the bleeding edge of technology are going to suffer cuts. The trick is to understand your place in that ecosystem and not make commitments that could be economically fatal.
 
Customers who like to walk the bleeding edge of technology are going to suffer cuts. The trick is to understand your place in that ecosystem and not make commitments that could be economically fatal.

My frustration is that this ecosystem was well developed 5-7 years ago by the successors of American and German pioneers but the Chinese came in and upset the apple cart totally, threw all the good knowledge out the window and the pioneer/legacy companies are shells of their former selves. And now we are in pioneering part 2 and I predict bad things from it.
 
The simple answer is that I would not use a BESS just for backup. A natural gas generator is much cheaper. With a BESS you would be paying for a lot of functionality that would never be used.
How is a natural gas generator much cheaper? The smallest Generac 10kW whole house generator is around $5k, plus probably $2k to install.

You can buy a battery and an inverter (example links below) that ties it all together, for around $5k, and probably $2k to install. Price becomes very comparable. And the running costs will almost certainly be lower with the battery system. Not to mention no maintenance needed every certain amount of hours. That's definitely a convenience as well.

 
Top