Delta and Wye Systems

Status
Not open for further replies.

Hv&Lv

Senior Member
Location
-
Occupation
Engineer/Technician
That is cool. Pretty much all the POCOs I work with are all about obsolete voltages and wont give you anything interesting. Numerous times Ive wanted a 480 or 600 V single phase service for long runs so I coud just have a customer owned step down transformer instead of a step up/step down which is super annoying (If I do that I go up to MV).
We will do 480 single phase for something light ballfield or racetrack lights where we wire all lights from one delivery point. Makes for some pretty long secondarys.
 

Hv&Lv

Senior Member
Location
-
Occupation
Engineer/Technician
Just for giggles heres another one…
Sorry for the picture quality. Its early and i sketched it out on whats available..

E5EDC0BA-CC26-4F54-86E1-0D8E23B3EC36.jpeg
 

jim dungar

Moderator
Staff member
Location
Wisconsin
Occupation
PE (Retired) - Power Systems
Just for giggles heres another one…
Sorry for the picture quality. Its early and i sketched it out on whats available..
Yep, you can be very creative when interconnecting single-phase transformer especially if they have taps which can be modified.

Alas, to many electricians are exposed only to factory built three-phase transformers using three sets of windings on a common core.
 

Hv&Lv

Senior Member
Location
-
Occupation
Engineer/Technician
Yep, you can be very creative when interconnecting single-phase transformer especially if they have taps which can be modified.

Alas, to many electricians are exposed only to factory built three-phase transformers using three sets of windings on a common core.
We have 3 (i believe) of these built along our system. Rural area, and they HAD to have 208.
It only works for light loads. Anything above about 50 kVa needs the third primary phase pulled in. Then it gets costly.

Interesting to note here, you can also get 120/240 single phase for your house from this configuration.
 
Location
Houston
Occupation
Electrician
Hi
We came across a delta service from provider. A=120 to N B=120 to N C=213 to N Customer is wanting to add some equipment that requires 460 volts three phase. Everything in the shop is listed 240 volts 3 phase. It is a mess. What are our options?
 

roger

Moderator
Staff member
Location
Fl
Occupation
Retired Electrician
Hi
We came across a delta service from provider. A=120 to N B=120 to N C=213 to N Customer is wanting to add some equipment that requires 460 volts three phase. Everything in the shop is listed 240 volts 3 phase. It is a mess. What are our options?
Step up transformer. You should probably start a new thread.
 

kwired

Electron manager
Location
NE Nebraska
Hi
We came across a delta service from provider. A=120 to N B=120 to N C=213 to N Customer is wanting to add some equipment that requires 460 volts three phase. Everything in the shop is listed 240 volts 3 phase. It is a mess. What are our options?
as mentioned step up transformer, but make sure to use one that is 240/480 and not 208/480.

Other options are to add additional 480 service or even switch service to 480 and separately derive and supply the 240 from the new service.

If the new equipment is significant enough load you might be doing some upgrading to service anyway.

Also depending on that equipment if it is dual volt capable you could configure it for 240 volts.
 
Location
USA
Occupation
EE
I am beating my head against this one (probably for no reason): What if you connect a Delta transformer to a Wye source? Say you have a medium voltage multi-grounded wye distribution system and someone decides to connect a delta txfr up to the three phases. P2P voltage will be the same but would it create some crazy circulating current? Similar to this with the wye neutral grounded.
3phase4Ydelta1.jpg


 

jim dungar

Moderator
Staff member
Location
Wisconsin
Occupation
PE (Retired) - Power Systems
I am beating my head against this one (probably for no reason): What if you connect a Delta transformer to a Wye source? Say you have a medium voltage multi-grounded wye distribution system and someone decides to connect a delta txfr up to the three phases. P2P voltage will be the same but would it create some crazy circulating current? Similar to this with the wye neutral grounded.
3phase4Ydelta1.jpg


Transformers with delta primaries are regularly connected to Wye sources, such as a typical 480V primary with a 208Y/120V secondary.
 

gar

Senior Member
Location
Ann Arbor, Michigan
Occupation
EE
230208-2254 EST

If you have three wires going to a location, either fed from 2 phases of a 3 phase source, or 3 phases of a 3 phase source, you can have 3 phase wye or delta at the load end if desired.

.
 
Utilities will almost always use a wye primary on an MGN distribution system. If I remember correctly the reasons are they are a little bit cheaper and less likely to suffer ferroresonance. That said, I'm sure a Delta would be fine. Of course for low voltage, Delta primaries are fed off of wye systems all of the time.
 

kwired

Electron manager
Location
NE Nebraska
I am beating my head against this one (probably for no reason): What if you connect a Delta transformer to a Wye source? Say you have a medium voltage multi-grounded wye distribution system and someone decides to connect a delta txfr up to the three phases. P2P voltage will be the same but would it create some crazy circulating current? Similar to this with the wye neutral grounded.
3phase4Ydelta1.jpg


I don't get the + and - indications in that wye side at all. Sure you could show such polarity for an instant in time, but in such arrangement those are 120 degrees apart at any given moment in time, here they are all shown as having the neutral side being negative which would never happen simultaneously.

They also kind of indicating direct current flow, reality is at the wye point as well as each corner of the delta there is currents flowing in three different directions at all times.
 
I don't get the + and - indications in that wye side at all. Sure you could show such polarity for an instant in time, but in such arrangement those are 120 degrees apart at any given moment in time, here they are all shown as having the neutral side being negative which would never happen simultaneously.

They also kind of indicating direct current flow, reality is at the wye point as well as each corner of the delta there is currents flowing in three different directions at all times.

Transformer polarity has a certain specific meaning and is important in some situations:

 

jim dungar

Moderator
Staff member
Location
Wisconsin
Occupation
PE (Retired) - Power Systems
Transformer polarity has a certain specific meaning and is important in some situations:
Text books regularly show all power sources, both AC and DC with some type of polarity marking. They also usually consider AC values as being 'frozen' in time based on those markings.
 
Location
USA
Occupation
EE
Transformers with delta primaries are regularly connected to Wye sources, such as a typical 480V primary with a 208Y/120V secondary.
Thanks for the insight! I guess I am surprised by this and my gut is telling me this is a bad idea but I am having trouble coming up with any legitimate reasons. The first thing I think of is losses. The conductors themselves between the substation wye txfr and the distribution delta acting as a resistive load and enabling a circulating current. Maybe an inherent impedance mismatch between the transformers? I mean, transformers that convert from wye to delta exist all over just fine but they also have a core that acts as the interface. But here the interface is distribution lines, which I suppose in this case, is forced to act like a core?

The other thing is... why? Why connect a delta txfr to a 4-wire wye distribution system only to convert it to wye again on the secondary side? Just to avoid having to run a neutral? Work practice/safety?

I haven't even begun to think about the implications of taking a single phase lateral off this setup. But again, I'm an idiot and I am probably just creating some high school drama in my own head. I mean, these systems have been in operation for ages.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top