Electric Baseboard Heat Calculation

Status
Not open for further replies.

kwired

Electron manager
Location
NE Nebraska
That would be the worst selection possible. This basement will need heat only on the coldest days of the year, during which a mini split (or any other heat pump) will switch over to resistance heat.
Only if you have a lot of cold days where it must depend on the back up heat, one day here and there may not be that bad.
 

mkgrady

Senior Member
Location
Massachusetts
I'm told the new mini splits are effective to several degrees below zero now. I don't think there is any backup resistive heaters in these newer units
 

K8MHZ

Senior Member
Location
Michigan. It's a beautiful peninsula, I've looked
Occupation
Electrician
Having a house in Michigan with a basement, I can tell you this: Even in the worst winters, the basement will very seldom get cold enough to freeze the pipes in the winter, and it gets below 0F. The reason is the fact that the ground around and under the basement stays about 54 degrees. People around here have their water pumps in unheated pump houses that are partially underground to take advantage of that.

A heater set at 40F in a basement would hardly ever need to be on.
 

K8MHZ

Senior Member
Location
Michigan. It's a beautiful peninsula, I've looked
Occupation
Electrician
Insulating and vapor proofing the area above the block walls will help, and it's not that hard to do. Also, if there are windows in the basement, make sure they are tight, if not, put some in that are. It is much cheaper to keep heat in the room than to 'heat the outdoors'.
 

GoldDigger

Moderator
Staff member
Location
Placerville, CA, USA
Occupation
Retired PV System Designer
... There are also things you can put in your dryer ducts to vent the warm air from the dryer into the house.

Which, although it may warm the house, may also raise the humidity to the point that harmful condensation occurs in visible or hidden parts of the building.
There may be heat exchangers available instead, but they are likely to be inefficient and to easily clog with lint.

Sent from my XT1585 using Tapatalk
 

K8MHZ

Senior Member
Location
Michigan. It's a beautiful peninsula, I've looked
Occupation
Electrician
Which, although it may warm the house, may also raise the humidity to the point that harmful condensation occurs in visible or hidden parts of the building.
There may be heat exchangers available instead, but they are likely to be inefficient and to easily clog with lint.

Sent from my XT1585 using Tapatalk

Here in the winter, the air is usually so dry we need humidifiers. At it's worst, I was using over a gallon a day. You do have a good point though, pretty much all the water from the wet clothes will go into the air.
 

kwired

Electron manager
Location
NE Nebraska
Here in the winter, the air is usually so dry we need humidifiers. At it's worst, I was using over a gallon a day. You do have a good point though, pretty much all the water from the wet clothes will go into the air.
Some of the newer washers spin at even higher speeds then they used to and extract even more water from clothes. I've noticed some come out not needing much drying .
 

mkgrady

Senior Member
Location
Massachusetts
Thanks for all the responses guys. I will probably install 4kw of baseboard heat and tell the customer to insulate the block walls and keep out any drafts. I don't think there is a line volt tstat that goes as low as 40 so I will use a low volt and have it turn on a relay. I will also give him an indoor/outdoor wireless thermometer so he always knows the the temp is in the basement without going down there
 

K8MHZ

Senior Member
Location
Michigan. It's a beautiful peninsula, I've looked
Occupation
Electrician
Thanks for all the responses guys. I will probably install 4kw of baseboard heat and tell the customer to insulate the block walls and keep out any drafts. I don't think there is a line volt tstat that goes as low as 40 so I will use a low volt and have it turn on a relay. I will also give him an indoor/outdoor wireless thermometer so he always knows the the temp is in the basement without going down there

I have a LUX line volt tstat that goes as low as 45.
 

Electric-Light

Senior Member
Like K8 said, the lows and highs don't matter much. Concrete has a lot of thermal mass. The temperature tends to reflect the daily average as long as draft is kept out. Radiant heater is effective for human comfort when its not practical to heat the air.

Air that dryer vents out has to come in from somewhere so you have to be careful to avoid drawing air with dew point higher than the wall surface behind the insulation. This is especially in the shoulder season when the average temperature is quite low but it gets warm and humid in the day.
 

kwired

Electron manager
Location
NE Nebraska
Like K8 said, the lows and highs don't matter much. Concrete has a lot of thermal mass. The temperature tends to reflect the daily average as long as draft is kept out. Radiant heater is effective for human comfort when its not practical to heat the air.

Air that dryer vents out has to come in from somewhere so you have to be careful to avoid drawing air with dew point higher than the wall surface behind the insulation. This is especially in the shoulder season when the average temperature is quite low but it gets warm and humid in the day.
If you are discharging dryer heat into the space, it is not drawing any fresh air from outside
 

Electric-Light

Senior Member
If you are discharging dryer heat into the space, it is not drawing any fresh air from outside

If you discharge it into the space, you dump humidity into the air. If you discharge it outside, the air is drawn in from somewhere. If the outdoor air at the time has a higher dew point than the basement wall surface it will condense.
 

kwired

Electron manager
Location
NE Nebraska
If you discharge it into the space, you dump humidity into the air. If you discharge it outside, the air is drawn in from somewhere. If the outdoor air at the time has a higher dew point than the basement wall surface it will condense.
Correct, but also consider that zero degree air won't hold as much moisture as 40 degree air. Bring that same air inside without adding any moisture to it, as it heats up it's dew point goes lower not higher.

Open a door on a cold day, any "fog" you see is existing primarily existing indoor moisture condensing in the cold air that entered.

Add: you can't have dew point higher then actual temperature - you will be under water if you did.
 
Last edited:

Electric-Light

Senior Member
Correct, but also consider that zero degree air won't hold as much moisture as 40 degree air. Bring that same air inside without adding any moisture to it, as it heats up it's dew point goes lower not higher.

Open a door on a cold day, any "fog" you see is existing primarily existing indoor moisture condensing in the cold air that entered.

Add: you can't have dew point higher then actual temperature - you will be under water if you did.

You're forgetting that heavy thermal mass lags behind significantly such as heavy concrete walls below the frost line.
Low average temperature will keep basement walls chilled but the local dew point can swing rapidly along ground level as sunshine hits the ground. When you use your dryer, the negative pressure draws in the make up air.

The airflow stops when dryer stops but the remaining moisture gives plenty of chance for things to grow.
 

kwired

Electron manager
Location
NE Nebraska
From Wikipedia - "Dew point is the temperature to which air must be cooled to become saturated with water vapor. When further cooled, the airborne water vapor will condense to form liquid water (dew). When air cools to its dew point through contact with a surface that is colder than the air, water will condense on the surface"

Warm air is capable of holding more water vapor then cold air. You take cold air into a warm space and it will absorb what moisture was in there easily, it will not condense. If any condensation occurs it is moisture that was already in the warm air condensing when it hits the cold air.

Condensation on a foundation wall would be from the wall temperature being below dew point of whatever mixture of air is near the wall.
 

Electric-Light

Senior Member
From Wikipedia

Condensation on a foundation wall would be from the wall temperature being below dew point of whatever mixture of air is near the wall.

Where do you you bathroom fans and dryers get the air they exhaust?

Warm, moist shoulder season air from outside or upper living area that flows around behind insulation when the dryer is running will condense out onto the interior facing foundation wall and the insulation will get wet. Insulation is for the cold season but since it stays year around, it has an influence all year long.

Leave something like a big gallon jug of water on a plate of starch in the shed. in a box. The jug will chill nice and cold when the average temperature is low but but when moist outside air wafts around the ground, it will condense and drip down the side and wets the flour and high humidity will slow down drying. Eventually the starch can get moldy. The worst happens when slow warm moist air is drawn around it when the container is still cold but without free airflow during the time it's above dew point to dry it out. Like the area in between vapor barrier and cement.

https://www.extension.umn.edu/envir...t/moisture-in-basements-causes-and-solutions/

Exterior humid air that enters the basement and condenses on cooler surfaces.
 
Last edited:

kwired

Electron manager
Location
NE Nebraska
Where do you you bathroom fans and dryers get the air they exhaust?

Warm, moist shoulder season air from outside or upper living area that flows around behind insulation when the dryer is running will condense out onto the interior facing foundation wall and the insulation will get wet. Insulation is for the cold season but since it stays year around, it has an influence all year long.

Leave something like a big gallon jug of water on a plate of starch in the shed. in a box. The jug will chill nice and cold when the average temperature is low but but when moist outside air wafts around the ground, it will condense and drip down the side and wets the flour and high humidity will slow down drying. Eventually the starch can get moldy. The worst happens when slow warm moist air is drawn around it when the container is still cold but without free airflow during the time it's above dew point to dry it out. Like the area in between vapor barrier and cement.

https://www.extension.umn.edu/envir...t/moisture-in-basements-causes-and-solutions/

Exterior humid air that enters the basement and condenses on cooler surfaces.
I do not see any examples in the link of cold outside air coming in and condensing, just warm moist outside air coming in and condensing on cooler surfaces.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top