Put myself through college (I'm an electrical engineer) working on cars. Had a myriad of Craftsman, Matco, Mac, Snap On. Whenever there was an issue with Craftsman, exchange has been made with NO problems. Snap On was always a hassle, Matco/Mac was 50/50. Snap On was by far the most expensive and I will never buy them again. Their chrome finished wrenches and sockets were slippery when they got a little bit of grease on them (imagine that happening working on a car!). The Craftsman have a little rougher texture so this doesn't happen.
You know you buy a lot of tools when the snap on truck makes a regular route stop to your house. Which happened until they started giving me issues on replacing de-chromed sockets, broken hammer handles, etc.
Recently had a driving rain in the morning that drove through the gasketed sides of my truck top. Tool bag got soaked. Ever single Klein (screwdrivers, needlenose, linesman, channel locks) in the bag rusted within the 8 hours when I discovered the problem when I went to get a tool about 4 PM. All Craftsman A-OK. But I still will only use Klein linesman pliers.
For hand wrenches, try Gear Wrench. Have used these working on changing transmissions, engine swaps (once a gear head, always a gear head), etc. and have only had one failure, which was quickly replaced. They are a ratcheting wrench which is really great when you're in a tight place and nto enough room for a ratchet and socket. Craftsman also has a version of these, but mine are over 10 years old when they were over $150 a set for SAE and metric. Now they're down to $35 or so per set
Husky (Home Depot) - have a couple of their socket sets - is also pretty good, but beware now you have to keep your receipt to prove the lifetime warranty.
Stanley Fat Max extreme 16' tape measure
For cordless over the years, I've owned Makita (what a piece of crap - batteries lasted about 10 minutes after a full charge and drive 3 screws), Bosch, Porter Cable, Hitachi, Craftsman and Dewalt drills. Preference is the Hitachi for shooting a lot of screws as it just conforms to my hand really nicely. For the most torque and longest battery life, Dewalt. Building a house where I drove over (300) 3 1/2" screws before the battery died. But the 19.2V Craftsman is a really good value.
Now having worked with my hands for over 25 years as a field service engineer, electrical contractor, etc. and based on your comments that these tools probably will only be used casually, stay with Craftsman. Regardless of when your son goes to, there will be a Sears around to exchange any problems. Unlike other replies, I have had great success with Craftsman - most of the tools are still the originals, while I am on my 2nd or 3rd Klein. And exhanging Klein is a pain in the ass!