Machine Disconnecting Means

Status
Not open for further replies.
B

bthielen

Guest
I have been trying to clarify the specific requirements for the use of supply power disconnects on industrial machinery and thought I'd ask the experts in this forum.

I work for a company that builds packaging machinery and my responsibilities center around modifications and rebuilds. Occasionally, I find that a modification to a machine requires enough additional equipment that the FLA of the machine will exceed the supply rating of the machine. When I approach our customer with this dilemma and suggest that the machine?s supply circuit will require upsizing, the cost and work involved causes issue. One solution that is often suggested is providing another power drop to supply power to the added components, which many times include servo drive systems. This is a concern for me because now there are multiple disconnect switches that must be opened in order to completely isolate the supply power to the machine for servicing.

NEC 2005
670.4 (B) indicates that a machine shall have a disconnecting means but it does not indicate if it must have only one.


NFPA79, 2002 Edition:
5.1 Indicates that ?where practicable?, the machine shall be connected to a single power supply circuit but it does not seem to forbid multiple supply circuits.

5.3.1.1 (1) does indicate that each power supply circuit must have a disconnecting means.

5.3.1.1.2 requires labeling the location of other disconnecting means.

5.3.1.2 seems to require some form of interlocking of the multiple supply circuits, in particular when it
comes to control circuits but I am not completely sure I understand this code.

This how I understand it. Multiple power supply circuits to an industrial machine are discouraged but acceptable. Each supply disconnect must be marked to identify the location of all other supply disconnect switches on the machine. Each disconnect must open all control voltage related to all equipment and components supplied by the disconnect.

Am I on the right track?

Bob
 
Re: Machine Disconnecting Means

maybe the answer is to split the thing into two chunks and look at it as two machines.

really, this problem happens a lot on big transfer lines that are really one system, but its broken down into chunks that are fed and controlled seperately.

i'd be a bit leery of having two power sources just to avoid upping my incoming feed from 30A to 60A though.
 
Re: Machine Disconnecting Means

Sounds like you're thinking is on the same lines as mine. I usually push quite hard to discourage the additional power supplies because of safety concerns. Sometimes I find I am against very stubborn resistance and decided to try and find code references to use as support for my objective. I am finding the codes to be somewhat vague or perhaps I am not fully understanding.

Thanks for your input.

Bob
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top