meggers

Status
Not open for further replies.
electricalperson said:
do you prefer analog or digital? i like analog myself
Click to expand...
It's easier to see if the measurement is trending upward, downward, or bouncing around during the test with the analog meter. Easier to get the actual reading at any particular point in time with a digital. The newer Megger brands feature both scales, with the analog being sort of "fake" on a digital screen.
 
mdshunk said:
It's easier to see if the measurement is trending upward, downward, or bouncing around during the test with the analog meter. Easier to get the actual reading at any particular point in time with a digital. The newer Megger brands feature both scales, with the analog being sort of "fake" on a digital screen.
Click to expand...


I agree with ya on the analog thing, but one of my favorite meters I have had is a cheapie craftsman that had a analog needle and a digital readout, not a high end meter, but I dont really need one for what I do, I have an assortment of meters on my truck, and a bunch here and there in my shop, im kinda a tool junkie.... I have fluke, amprobe, wavetek, sperry, and other brands I cant think of, some good, some cheapies....
 
BK Precision 306{/quote]
I love that they put PRECISION ion the name of the instrument

500 V / 1000 MW Megohmeter
Tests insulation resistance
Measures AC voltage to 600 V
Battery powered
500 V, 1000 MW
Selectable 250 V, 500 V, or 1000 V insulation test
Click to expand...

If it has a 500 VDC output how do you test 1000 V with it as noted in the last line above.
Click to expand...
 
mdshunk said:
It's easier to see if the measurement is trending upward, downward, or bouncing around during the test with the analog meter. Easier to get the actual reading at any particular point in time with a digital. The newer Megger brands feature both scales, with the analog being sort of "fake" on a digital screen.
Click to expand...

I have no experience with a megger. I only know what I have learned from this site. I can think of so many times I could have used one and I can think of alot of times I will use one. Comparing the megger brand with digital/"analog" (mit410) vs. the fluke (1507) I see a $200 price difference. Other than a 3 yr. warranty and the analog scale and assuming that I use each to their fullest ability do you see any advantage in the megger? I guess I should have asked first if you have experience with either. Having read this thread and the other started by brianjohn I'm having trouble making a decision. It seems that alot of people prefer to see analog. Thank you in advance to anyone who replies.
 
For the savings I would use the Fluke. Check their product line and see if there is one they offer with the analog scale. But while nice IMO not a deal breaker.

The analog scale is icing on the cake. I often use this feature on the voltage setting, along with my analog Simpson for checking phasing between a generator and utility. Not an issue many face regularly. Get familiar with the meter by playing with it (carefully) and you'll do find with either choice.
 
Thanks, Brian, for your reply. I haven't made a choice just yet but I feel pretty good about the fluke. I've seen it mentioned several times and the reviews are positive. This makes me wonder, is there any site or magazine that does reviews on the tools of our trade?
 
I would look at what I wanted to use it for. if it is just basic testing to find bad insulation, you can get by with the cheaper ones with limited features. If you plan to get into the business of cable testing, it may make sense to get a full featured unit.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top