Motor slip

Status
Not open for further replies.

Jraef

Moderator, OTD
Staff member
Location
San Francisco Bay Area, CA, USA
Occupation
Electrical Engineer
...
The OP was respectfully coming here to ask a very basic question, "What is motor slip." So I am pretty sure he didn't understand the difference between asynchronous and synchronous.
Actually, the discussion, being that it would pertain to his question about SLIP, should preclude discussing synchronous motors at all. "Slip" ONLY pertains to asynchronous motors, so essentially the OP had delineated the discussion from the outset. That however didn't stop it from heading off into the weeds.

An induction motor CANNOT run at synchronous speed. There was no point in bringing it up. The word "synchronous" was originally brought into this as part of the discussion about what the definition of slip is. It's as if someone were describing the color orange by saying that it is a combination of yellow and red, then people started talking about red things. Not germane to the original issue. Let's all drop it now before the thread has to be closed due to acrimony.
 

mivey

Senior Member
I don't have a minor problem and this is very frustrating. Read the thread.
No worries mate. I understand the point you were making. I was just trying to convey why your point may have been missed.

I miss-read it when I first read it and just assumed it was a typo because I know what you were driving at did not match how I read it.
 

winnie

Senior Member
Location
Springfield, MA, USA
Occupation
Electric motor research
Okay, so to summarize for the OP after all of the discussion:

'Slip' is a description of the speed of an induction motor in operation. Induction motors are sometimes called 'asynchronous' motors.

Induction motors are among the most common industrial motors, but there are other types; slip only applies to some types of motor.

Induction motors have stator windings which produce a rotating magnetic field. The speed of this rotating field is called 'synchronous speed'. In order to produce torque, the rotor of an induction motor must spin at a different speed than synchronous speed.

If the rotor is spinning at synchronous speed, slip is _0_ and no torque is produced. A completely unloaded motor can spin very close to synchronous speed, but there will always be just a bit of slip, to produce enough torque to overcome friction.

If the rotor is locked, then slip is defined as 1.

Common induction motors will have full load slips somewhere in the 0.01 to 0.05 range, or 1-5%, but greater slip is certainly possible for some systems.

Motors can operate with negative slip, meaning that the rotor speed is greater than synchronous speed. In this case the machine is actually operating as a generator.

Slip greater than 1 is possible, and may be used in some systems for rapid braking.

Some types of motor operate _at_ synchronous speed. These are commonly called 'synchronous' motors, and produce torque using a different rotor magnetic field.

-Jon
 

kwired

Electron manager
Location
NE Nebraska
That doesn't jive with this statement that you made "So synchronous motors can't produce any torque? :?" If the discussion was only about asynchronous motors by assumption then that statement wouldn't have been made. Because it was in response to a statement that an asynchronous motor theoretically running at synchronous speed would produce no torque. So you are the one who dispelled the "assumption that the discussion was limited to asynchronous induction motors in the first place, and the sole reason I said what I did.

The OP was respectfully coming here to ask a very basic question, "What is motor slip." So I am pretty sure he didn't understand the difference between asynchronous and synchronous.
The synchronous motor has current injected into the rotor making it a different animal then when rotor current is only induced into it.

You could have a high inertia type of load that at times is feeding energy back to the motor, and could be running at, near, or even beyond synchronous speed. Closer you get to synchronous speed the less torque the motor is putting out, at sync speed there is no torque, beyond sync speed the motor becomes a generator.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top