Six Switch Rule vs Main Breaker

Status
Not open for further replies.

hillbilly1

Senior Member
Location
North Georgia mountains
Occupation
Owner/electrical contractor
I thought you can still use the six disconnect rule, you just can’t have six in one enclosure any more. And yes, it is used to get out of the GF rule, but still can be, it’s just more expensive now with the 2020.
 

Dennis Alwon

Moderator
Staff member
Location
Chapel Hill, NC
Occupation
Retired Electrical Contractor
I thought you can still use the six disconnect rule, you just can’t have six in one enclosure any more. And yes, it is used to get out of the GF rule, but still can be, it’s just more expensive now with the 2020.


That is correct. You would need 6 separate enclosures
 

hillbilly1

Senior Member
Location
North Georgia mountains
Occupation
Owner/electrical contractor
The main buss can't be denergized, presenting a shock and arc flash hazard. How many electricians would have the POCO deenergize power to replace a breaker?
Even with the separate disconnects, still would need a poco deenergization. Line side still hot. Just not as much of a incentive to work hot, Square D iLine is probably the safest, though not recommended, hot swappable. Damaged buss can change all of that in short order. Had a customer that changed to a single main because they didn’t want to schedule with the poco every time they replaced one of the six. After putting in the single service disconnect, found the buss was burnt on the breaker they wanted changed. Removing it hot could have been catastrophic.
 

jap

Senior Member
Occupation
Electrician
We need a distribution panelboard with an integrated single rated main switch (no overload protection ) to reduce expense.

JAP>
 
What is the thinking on this change?
I read one where the proposer said MLO's "are longer relevant" - whatever the hell that means. Yet another case of these idiots not taking into account cost with their code changes. On a recent job I did, the cost to go from a MLO to main breaker for a thousand amp mdp would have been twice as much, from about $4,500 to $9000. the existing equipment was way underrated for fault current, and one of the poles on the main breaker didn't open. $4,500 could easily be the difference between them deciding not to upgrade it. Genius move NFPA.
 

jap

Senior Member
Occupation
Electrician
I read one where the proposer said MLO's "are longer relevant" - whatever the hell that means. Yet another case of these idiots not taking into account cost with their code changes. On a recent job I did, the cost to go from a MLO to main breaker for a thousand amp mdp would have been twice as much, from about $4,500 to $9000. the existing equipment was way underrated for fault current, and one of the poles on the main breaker didn't open. $4,500 could easily be the difference between them deciding not to upgrade it. Genius move NFPA.

Make that a 480v Panelboard and add the GFI protection to the main and it gets even better. :)

JAP>
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top