The taste of Crow

Status
Not open for further replies.

jwelectric

Senior Member
Location
North Carolina
Thank the Lord we had a safe trip home.
We had a blast while we were gone seeing friends that we hadn?t seen over the past year. The wife won a couple of door prizes and seemed to have a great time.

While I was at the meeting I learned a few things that I thought I already knew the answer to. I was so convinced that I knew what that I was talking about that I ask for a side bar where I could have more explanation. Here is what I learned about article 210.

The question that brought me to the microphone and subsequently the side bar is as follows:

116. The owner installed an appliance garage on the kitchen countertop. Does the NEC require a receptacle inside the appliance garage? Could a receptacle installed within an appliance garage be supplied by a dedicated 120-volt 15-ampere branch circuit.

Answer: John Minick- No and No
I hit the floor running with my explanation of just what the NEC said about these circuits and receptacles as outlined in 210.11(C) and 210.52(B). At this point Jim Pauley (on panel 2) chimed in with the explanation as follows to the best of my ability.

210.11(C) states that two or more 20-ampere small-appliance branch circuits shall be provided for all receptacle outlets specified by 210.52(B).
Here we are told that at least two, but we can use more, circuits SHALL be provided for ALL the receptacles specified in .52(B)

In 210.52(B) states, circuits required by 210.11(C)(1) shall serve all wall and floor receptacle outlets covered by 210.52(A), all countertop outlets covered by 210.52(C), and receptacle outlets for refrigeration equipment. There are two exceptions, one for a required lighting outlet and the other for the refrigeration equipment that can be installed on a 15 ampere circuit.
Here again we are told that ALL the receptacles are to be supplied by these 20 amp circuits. Here there is a key word that is used that I have over looked for a long time.
It states that these circuits are to supply the receptacles that are COVERED by (B) and (C). Jim Pauley stated that the word ?covered? was chosen so it wouldn?t be confused with the word ?required.?

In summation of what I have learned is that any receptacle that is installed in the rooms specified in 210.52(B) which will include those on the wall and the countertops weather island, peninsular or wall counter will be required to be supplied by a 20 ampere circuit and this is all encompassing. Appliance garages are included.

My side bar was with Jim Carpenter and Ron Chilton and was about the use of under cabinet lights. Much to my surprise I learned that a cord and plug light is nothing more than a listed piece of equipment and can be plugged into any receptacle outlined in 210.52(B) with out being a violation. Instead it would be a violation to install a 15 amp receptacle over the countertop and use it for the light. I was also told that any receptacle within 12 inches below and 20 inches above a countertop was a countertop receptacle no matter if it is inside, under, over or behind did not take away it?s use as a countertop receptacle but that it could not be counted as one of the ones that would otherwise be required (2 ft. and 4 ft. rule).

At this point I could hardly stay in my seat so I ask about the famous Iwire and JW discussion about ?direct connection? of these fixtures. They said in not so many words, ?Set down, shut up and listen when Bob speaks.? Cord and plug is not a direct connection and direct connection has nothing to do with OCPD.

Well after being whipped so badly I was reaching for anything that I could grab hold of and look good so I ask about calculations and here is what I got.

When doing the calculations for the service we only use the two required small appliance circuits unless we decide to use the exception in 210.52(B) and install a 15 ampere circuit for the refrigeration equipment or have more than one kitchen. Then we would include these in our calculations at 1500 volt amperes each.

Now if I could get you all to excuse me for a period of time I have a pot of crow and dumplings cooking that must be eaten.

Good to be home.
:)
 
Re: The taste of Crow

Welcome back. I seem to recall having had my share of crow dishes, in both the recent and distant past. It's not too hard on the digestive system, if properly prepared. I prefer mine sauteed in good Kentucky bourbon. :D :D
 
Re: The taste of Crow

Mike I am glad you started posting again I was beginning to think you had disappeared like Sam.

I was starting to think of conspiracy theories against forum members. :( I must say I have a great deal of respect for anyone that can come here and admit a mistake. :cool:
 
Re: The taste of Crow

Hello Mike, I garnish my crow with an orange slice, it seems to make it taste a little better. :D

Welcome back, glad you had a good time.

Roger
 
Re: The taste of Crow

A Few thoughts come to mind.
#1- I knew these things all along. Nobody listened. :D
#2- This is what happens when we OVERthink what is pretty clearly stated.
3#- This would have been really fun to watch. :D
 
Re: The taste of Crow

Oh, sure, you'll listen to Code Making Panel members and not us, thanks Mike. :D

For anyone with time to sift through a 35 page decathlon of epic proportions, click here. And may God have mercy on your soul. :D

Welcome back, Mike. ;)
 
Re: The taste of Crow

Jeez George, you had to dredge that one up, didn't you? :D

[ October 13, 2005, 10:04 PM: Message edited by: peter d ]
 
Re: The taste of Crow

Thank you all for the welcome back.

If any are wondering how hard it is for a man that stands 5 foot 8 inches tall to hide in the threads of the carpet, just ask. I didn?t have any problem at all.

Should any of you know anyone that was at the Southern Sectional all you have to do is ask if I didn?t make a good fight of it. I will have to admit that I was hard to convince.
One of those that sit me at the table is also the one I have to answer to about the Inspector classes that I teach. No, strike through the word teach and replace with hold.
:)
 
Re: The taste of Crow

Young man, this self pity is no way to act. Stand up straight, brush the dust off your shoulders, and next year march right back in there and enlightnen those dolts about all the rest of your theory's. We will all root for you.
 
Re: The taste of Crow

JW,
I went to my first Section Meeting just a few weeks ago, up here in New Hampshire. As a virgin at these things, I decided that I would take the sit down and listen approach, for I have had my share of NH crow. Maybe next year in Philadelphia, I will try the crow down there. I here it taste like chicken!

NH crow gets a good wash down with a little help from the "Captain". Private Stock that is.

Jim
 
Re: The taste of Crow

Originally posted by jwelectric:
Should any of you know anyone that was at the Southern Sectional all you have to do is ask if I didn?t make a good fight of it. I will have to admit that I was hard to convince.
I can't picture that. :)
 
Re: The taste of Crow

Originally posted by jwelectric:
Thank you all for the welcome back.

If any are wondering how hard it is for a man that stands 5 foot 8 inches tall to hide in the threads of the carpet, just ask. I didn?t have any problem at all.

Should any of you know anyone that was at the Southern Sectional all you have to do is ask if I didn?t make a good fight of it. I will have to admit that I was hard to convince.
One of those that sit me at the table is also the one I have to answer to about the Inspector classes that I teach. No, strike through the word teach and replace with hold.
:)
Hey Mike:

I have attended the Southern Section meeting in the past, and they do a great job, the Eastern Section with the Tuxedos and Code breakfasts is fun too, I attended the Northwestern Section Meeting this year and they too had a great program.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top