trade or code?

Status
Not open for further replies.
QES said:
in some country their some "great" electrical work but those work does not follow any standard or codes.
Click to expand...

If you do "great" Electrical work you have a standard, while it may be self imposed it is still a standard. It is the government that has set standards and codes on us to protect people from hacks. Yet people still insist on hiring hacks to save a dollar. I could design and build an electrical system for a home that wasn't code compliant but was a better install and system than some may put in that was code compliant. When I say not code compliant I could simply leave out a receptacle on a 6' section of wall space where one would never really be needed. Look you can have both it is important to know both and as others have said not all guys out there installing electrical systems are electricians some are simply hole drillers and wire pullers.
 
QES said:
which is more important? to know the codes or know the trade? can't have both!
Click to expand...

At 90.1, the purpose of the code is stated. Namely, to safeguard persons and property from hazards that might arise from the use of electricity.
To "know"a trade suggests to me that one would "know" the hazards involved, such as overloaded wiring, or inadequate ground-fault current paths, etc., which would fail to provide against shock, etc. "Knowing" your trade in not only safety from fault currents, but protection from overcurrent, thermal effects and overvoltage as explained in the FPN of 90.1(D) is all part of the relationship between work ethics and standards.

When you say "Can't have both", I say "Must have both". :)
 
My uncle wanted me to put up a light in the yard for him (flood light). He knows how to put black to black white to white. bare to nothing.... I refused to do it because he piece milled this thing together. meaning Yes it would work but not to code. I told him to call someone in the yellow pages. He got mad at me and told me "Not everyone can pay that kind of money". I wonder if he put it up yet.
 
Which One?

Which One?

I have always been a proponent of education and training.
That being said, I don't know how anyone can call themselves an "electrician" if they don't have a thorough working knowledge of the NEC.
We have alot of very good "mechanics" down here who can run pipe, pull wire, install equipment, etc. but don't ask them to size a conduit or feeder.
There is a place for everyone on a crew but don't give yourself a title unless it is deserved.
Put in your time to learn the foundation of our trade and you will be rewarded.
 
iwireHammurabi's Code[/QUOTE said:
46 ?So why do you keep calling me ?Lord, Lord!? when you don?t do what I say? 47 I will show you what it?s like when someone comes to me, listens to my teaching, and then follows it. 48 It is like a person building a house who digs deep and lays the foundation on solid rock. When the floodwaters rise and break against that house, it stands firm because it is well built. 49 But anyone who hears and doesn?t obey is like a person who builds a house without a foundation. When the floods sweep down against that house, it will collapse into a heap of ruins.?

Better reading.
Click to expand...
 
I work with both skilled electricians and installers. Installers require supervision and only do what they're told and don't know the code. They know enough "trade" to do their jobs. Skilled electricians know the code and know the trade to do their jobs without supervision or outside guidance.

So to answer your question: Both are essential!
 
peter d said:
So to answer your question: Both are essential!
Click to expand...
Right! From a business standpoint, there's no merit in wasting a good "electrician" on installing 300 lay-in fixtures, when that's a task perfectly suited to an "installer" (I call them "electrical laborers"). Put the good electricians on piping up the mechanical equipment and the other odd tasks where the mind for code is also needed.
 
bikeindy said:
If you do "great" Electrical work you have a standard, while it may be self imposed it is still a standard.
Click to expand...
New International Version (NIV)

Passage Colossians 3:23:
23Whatever you do, work at it with all your heart, as working for the Lord, not for men,
 
My old boss hardly ever looked in a code book but we always seemed to get it right. Occasionally an inspector would tell him to correct something. When I started going to school I had my own code book that I would take to work.
He started relying on me to look up things in question. On one hand he probably should have kept himself up to date. On the other hand having me looking up codes helped me learn them and helped "us" do the work right.
He was the kind of guy that introduced me to his customers as, "This is Jay, he works with me." Never reduced me to his helper or apprentice.

That is my long way of saying that you need the skills set to accomplish anything, but what is it worth if you don't make it code compliant?

Response to electricmanscott!
 
Last edited:
After 30 some years I ONLY know the trade. Actually I only know SOME of the trade.

I understand the basics of the code but honestly, when I try to look something up and try to understand the verbage....I usually end up confused.


My most recent question was regarding derating conductors when you had a bunch of them in a single conduit. I got 3 different answers online, another from the engineer (glad I didn't listen to HIM) and the final answer from the inspector. He pointed of the code section to me but I thought it was not at ALL clear, and he didn't consider neutrals as current carrying conductors.
 
JohnConnolly said:
After 30 some years I ONLY know the trade. Actually I only know SOME of the trade.

I understand the basics of the code but honestly, when I try to look something up and try to understand the verbage....I usually end up confused.


My most recent question was regarding derating conductors when you had a bunch of them in a single conduit. I got 3 different answers online, another from the engineer (glad I didn't listen to HIM) and the final answer from the inspector. He pointed of the code section to me but I thought it was not at ALL clear, and he didn't consider neutrals as current carrying conductors.
Click to expand...

John, your not alone with having problems understanding the intent, years ago, many just gave up and lost intrest in trying to understand the intent, since then code instruction is easily accessed thru community vocational school offerings and private instruction, offering CEU classes, if derating is one of your intrests, you can find a class covering it, and have a chance to see that your not alone in your quest for understanding the intent.

Sign up for a course, and meet everyone else that has problems understanding derating. if nothing else, it a chance to meet others in your craft.
 
JohnConnolly said:
. . . he didn't consider neutrals as current carrying conductors.
Click to expand...
That actually applies to neutrals that carry only unbalanced current in MWBC's.
 
Hmmm...

Hmmm...

QES said:
it rephase that, to know the trade meaning know to do electrical skills not to code stardard.
Click to expand...

Back in the days I spent with my Uncle, Sam (maybe you know him.)
I learned a lot about electricity. More than most electricians would ever know. I mean a lot.
We learned how to install wiring too, but I never even knew there was a NEC until 2000.
Now, I've been doing this since 1991 (I know, I'm a pup to a lot of you out there), that makes 9 years of doing a lot of electrical work without knowing what the heck a code was, let alone following it.

In all that time, I misjudged my ampacity once. Unfortunately for me, I was in charge, and it was a BIG misjudge. But, statistics are on my side, because I only had 1 fault in 9 years. Yet, I knew nothing about code.

So, my answer is, to know your trade is more important.

Really, I would like both, but if I had to choose one over the other, I would choose: know your trade.

Being in your position, you can probably train the person on the code, because they would not be in a leadership position, that means everything they do would be monitored. Therefore, training possibilities are nearly endless.

Good question.
 
hardworkingstiff said:
Being able to know your trade without knowing your code seems to be incongruous (IMO).
Click to expand...

I agree.

I once met a "electrician" who stated that he had never owned a code book.
He "did it the way he was taught".
I've often wondered how he kept up to date on code changes.

As the government imposes more and more rules and regulations on the construction industry, guys like him will become extinct unless their "teaching" steadily progresses with the times.

For most of us (me anyway) that teaching is self imposed, and it's up to me to keep up, or fall behind.

Since the postman still keeps coming by my house everyday and bringing bills, I've got no choice.

Luckily, I love what I do and am always ready to learn.

The "way I was taught" will either get on the train before it leaves the station, or be left behind.

"All aboard!".

steve
 
Greg Swartz said:
Back in the days I spent with my Uncle, Sam (maybe you know him.)
I learned a lot about electricity. More than most electricians would ever know. I mean a lot.
We learned how to install wiring too, but I never even knew there was a NEC until 2000.
Now, I've been doing this since 1991 (I know, I'm a pup to a lot of you out there), that makes 9 years of doing a lot of electrical work without knowing what the heck a code was, let alone following it.

In all that time, I misjudged my ampacity once. Unfortunately for me, I was in charge, and it was a BIG misjudge. But, statistics are on my side, because I only had 1 fault in 9 years. Yet, I knew nothing about code.
Click to expand...

I am going to guess you had some form of tech data to install by, My uncle sam had lots for me to read.
 
Greg Swartz said:
Now, I've been doing this since 1991 (I know, I'm a pup to a lot of you out there), that makes 9 years of doing a lot of electrical work without knowing what the heck a code was, let alone following it.
Click to expand...

While you may not have known the NEC, I'll bet that your Uncle Sam had other written regulations (codes) that you did have to know by heart.
 
bikeindy said:
I am going to guess you had some form of tech data to install by, My uncle sam had lots for me to read.
Click to expand...

C'mon, we're Marines... we don't know how to read!
(and if you asked us for a set of Kliens, we would of looked at you with a deer in the headlights sorta look!)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top