Transformer xo bonding

Status
Not open for further replies.

nickelec

Senior Member
Location
US
So I just want to check my thoughts here
Below is a picture of a step up transformer being fed via 120/208 800 amp
To 277/480. As you can see the neutrals are not even hooked up nor is the transformer bonded. Even though there are no neutral loads.To my knowledge this is a dangerous set up as the falut current can not be carried back to trip the breaker. am I right here or over thinking this. We will be replacing all this anyway but I just want to make sure I'm thinking correctly here
Thanks
39b4c835e01e0b9b1703a7c480510aeb.jpg
fc86dd56c230c043de237623b28e8d67.jpg
ff88f61bf8e9ecf33851b0709fe466f6.jpg
809a9b99b85a8cb5e1b85b9a6af1d676.jpg


Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
 

texie

Senior Member
Location
Fort Collins, Colorado
Occupation
Electrician, Contractor, Inspector
So I just want to check my thoughts here
Below is a picture of a step up transformer being fed via 120/208 800 amp
To 277/480. As you can see the neutrals are not even hooked up nor is the transformer bonded. Even though there are no neutral loads.To my knowledge this is a dangerous set up as the falut current can not be carried back to trip the breaker. am I right here or over thinking this. We will be replacing all this anyway but I just want to make sure I'm thinking correctly here
Thanks
39b4c835e01e0b9b1703a7c480510aeb.jpg
fc86dd56c230c043de237623b28e8d67.jpg
ff88f61bf8e9ecf33851b0709fe466f6.jpg
809a9b99b85a8cb5e1b85b9a6af1d676.jpg


Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

This sounds like a standard 480 delta to 208Y transformer used in reverse. In that case the XO (now on the primary side) should absolutely not be connected to anything. The now 480 delta secondary side would either need ground detection or be corner grounded. Both options have negative issues though. A better choice would be to get a 208 delta to 480Y transformer for a number of reasons.
 

nickelec

Senior Member
Location
US
The trany is being fed via 120/208 wye I honestly am not sure of it's a wye delta or not I was there briefly

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
 

LarryFine

Master Electrician Electric Contractor Richmond VA
Location
Henrico County, VA
Occupation
Electrical Contractor
The X-0 terminal indicates the 208/120 side is wye, and when used as the primary, as Nick stated, it should be left floating.
 

ActionDave

Chief Moderator
Staff member
Location
Durango, CO, 10 h 20 min from the winged horses.
Occupation
Licensed Electrician
So I just want to check my thoughts here
Below is a picture of a step up transformer being fed via 120/208 800 amp
To 277/480. As you can see the neutrals are not even hooked up nor is the transformer bonded. Even though there are no neutral loads.To my knowledge this is a dangerous set up as the falut current can not be carried back to trip the breaker. am I right here or over thinking this.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

You are correct that without a bond on the secondary there is no way to trip a breaker on the first fault. After the first fault you have a grounded system just not a solidly grounded system.

Dangerous is in the eye of the beholder. The reason ungrounded systems are used is to allow for an orderly shutdown of equipment instead of a sudden one. The one in your picture looks like a set up that was not done to code.
 

nickelec

Senior Member
Location
US
So regardless my two neutrals from the feed. should be landed on XO and boned to the tranny case and a rod. The seconderies stay isolated from XO

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
 

ActionDave

Chief Moderator
Staff member
Location
Durango, CO, 10 h 20 min from the winged horses.
Occupation
Licensed Electrician
So regardless my two neutrals from the feed. should be landed on XO and boned to the tranny case and a rod. The seconderies stay isolated from XO

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

No. First thing, there should be no neutral on the primary side.

Second thing, what you do on the secondary differs depending on how the transformer is wound.
 

MTW

Senior Member
Location
SE Michigan
Reverse Connected 480V Delta to 208Y Transformer

Reverse Connected 480V Delta to 208Y Transformer

So I just want to check my thoughts here
Below is a picture of a step up transformer being fed via 120/208 800 amp
To 277/480. As you can see the neutrals are not even hooked up nor is the transformer bonded. Even though there are no neutral loads.To my knowledge this is a dangerous set up as the fault current can not be carried back to trip the breaker. am I right here or over thinking this. We will be replacing all this anyway but I just want to make sure I'm thinking correctly here
Thanks

So regardless my two neutrals from the feed. should be landed on XO and bonded to the tranny case and a rod. The secondaries stay isolated from XO

For what its worth, here's what I see from the provided photos. A transformer nameplate would have been good, to see the type and size for sure. At 800A 208V feeder, that would equate to a 300KVA rated transformer, at 832A on the 208 side and 360A on the 480V side.

It looks to be a standard 480V delta primary, and a 208V Wye secondary, used in reverse as others have suggested. Cant be much else, because it doesn't have terminals for anything else. The XO terminal is definitely on the 208Y side, due to the size of the common bus strap and welded connections from each Y connected coil.

So as it sits, its an ungrounded 480V delta output. It doesn't appear that it has ground fault monitoring, nor is it corner grounded. What's worse is that your 208V Wye neutrals from the supply side are spliced to the load neutrals going to the 480V load side, completely bypassing the transformer coils and frame connections.

This can be a very bad thing, for a couple reasons. First one is, that there is no low impedance fault current path from the 480V load side, back to the 480V delta output coil. Second is that the fault current, if and when it happens, will be directed back to the 208V Wye supply source, likely the service transformer, because the neutrals and grounds are spliced back through.

What this does is make a high impedance connection, for fault current, to get back to the 480V delta primary winding. The only way that current can get back to that 480V delta coil is through the magnetic induction of the transformer core, and stray capacitive coupling of the windings and conductors. An arcing fault, on the 480V side, under these conditions can produce some high ringing voltages in the circuits, as well as not trip the overcurrent devices.

The 208V feeder, did not require neural conductors to supply the transformer windings, and should not be connected to it either. Large circulating currents will result, if you do so.

The 480V delta side can only be corner grounded, since that's all the terminals you have to connect to, the corners of the delta.

The transformer case and core appear to be bonded to the grounding conductor from the 208V side. A lug to the case in the right rear corner, and a case to core strap in the right front corner. Then the bonding jumpers to the conduits. Most of the bonding jumpers appear to be undersized, as compared to the ungrounded conductors.

The other thing that appears missing is a grounding electrode conductor and connection to the 480V delta coil. The delta coil is a separately derived system and should be bonded back to the building steel, water service entrance or main ground buss in the service where the electrode conductors terminate, unless there is a ground detection system installed.

For all practical purposes the existing transformer should be corner grounded or replaced with a 208 delta primary /480V Wye secondary and wired correctly. The way it is existing, could be a serious hazard during a fault conditions, especially an arcing fault. Personally I wouldn't touch it if I couldn't get the OK to fix it properly, one way or the other.

MTW
 

nickelec

Senior Member
Location
US
The neutrals are not even hooked up to anything in the tranny the load side has no neutrals

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
 

MTW

Senior Member
Location
SE Michigan
The neutrals are not even hooked up to anything in the tranny the load side has no neutrals

Nor does it have a ground connection. Is the supply neutrals connected to a neutral buss at the load side? Is that neutral buss bonded to the enclosure on the load end?

If you have a bonded neutral buss at the load end, you still have the same issue. Fault current from load side, going through the magnetic connection.

MTW
 

packersparky

Senior Member
Location
Wisconsin
Occupation
Inspector
If its wye-delta there should not be anything connected to XO on the primary (208/120) side. The secondary will not have an XO. You either corner ground the secondary or use a ground detector system.
 

packersparky

Senior Member
Location
Wisconsin
Occupation
Inspector
You can see in the pic in my 2nd post the neutrals are just floating

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

Yes, I see that. If it is the primary of a wye-delta transformer is should be floating. The XO on the primary side of a wye-delta transformer should not be connected to anything. As I said before the secondary is where the grounding would take place, or ground detectors installed.
 

MTW

Senior Member
Location
SE Michigan
I wouldn't call them floating, to me their spliced through, co-mingling the primary supply side neutral , with the secondary load side neutral.

The 2 sides of the 3Φ isolation transformer should be isolated from each other, except for the grounding connections.

Show us what the neutral connections look like in the load side gear.

I'll insert a couple sketches here that I did a while back, to illustrate the problem of an ungrounded delta secondary.

Each of these has a different primary arrangement that your 208 Wye, but the delta output coil remains the same, like yours.

First one is a center tapped delta supply, feeding a delta input and a deriving a delta output.

DeltaStepUpUngrounded.jpg

Second one is a center tapped open delta supply, feeding a Wye input and deriving a delta output.
Notice on this Wye input, there is no neutral connection to the XO Wye input, just like yours.

Mud Equipment Layout.jpg
Both of these were examples with an ungrounded delta output coil, that had site problems. Just had them handy to illustrate the issue. Its basically the same type setup you have going on there.

Looking at the drawings, how would fault current from the delta output coil, in both cases, get back to that delta output coil, in sufficient magnitude to trip the overcurrent device?

MTW
 

mbrooke

Batteries Included
Location
United States
Occupation
Technician
No. First thing, there should be no neutral on the primary side.

Second thing, what you do on the secondary differs depending on how the transformer is wound.



That neutral MUST go at all cost on the primary if the secondary is closed delta. Not doing so can burn up the transformer or cause nuisance tripping of the OCPDs/main.
 

mbrooke

Batteries Included
Location
United States
Occupation
Technician
Don't you mean "must not"?

It must go. Meaning it must leave the the XO and the XO must remain floating.


The only* time you ground a wye delta transformer is at levels above 5kv to prevent voltage stress and ferroresoance during single phase switching (ie fuses). Once switching is completed the neutral is floated via jumper removal or opening a cutout.



* There is an exception and thats when a zero sequence source is needed, but goes past the intent of this discussion.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top