All of the above - especially Gar's & mivey's.... Now.... When you say "Old House" - you mention romex - but not if it has a EGC or not. AN EGC is the best to check voltage H-G, N-G - it is a good reference point IMO. (If originally wired proper)
I will ad this - map the circuit on paper with a
line diagram as you go along - I find this helps to visualize the circuits operation.
I usually take one one dead outlet or light and follow box to box and open the hot splices and ring out to the nearest adjacent box as I go to confirm.
Then ask myself - "How would I wire it?" Use my imagination and try to picture whats in the walls.
One of the dead items is the last in the line on the circuit - another is the last before you find the problem. (Highlight my signature below :wink: )
For this type of problem - just put the volt tick away - it will only confuse you. It is only made to warn you of "possible voltage" while working for safety reasons - not to measure or confirm such - for instance - rub it against your shirt....
Anyway.... Confused by something here...
I checked every box. There is now power. All connections are good.
If there is "now" power - whats the problem?
If there is
"NO" power - You may not have checked every box and the connections must not be all that great.... (Rare but not impossible for cables to go bad in the wall)
And I will repeat - what-ever the owner says about lightning or 'power surges'
must be looked at as a red herring until confirmation is made by the pro - you.... Whenever I hear that type of tripe I think to myself - I bet that 'Joe HO' replaced a switch or outlet himself and it too weak to admit he has no idea what he did to mess it up....