A local jurisdiction near mine once commissioned an engineering group to perform a study on the effects of the 6 mil vapor retarder and the use of a concrete encased electrode. I don't have nor can locate a copy of that report. I do know that it basically indicated that even with the vapor retarder in place, the earth resistance of the electrode was still on average better than your typical 8' ground rods.
I agree with Chris though. The code is clear as to what qualifies for a CEE.