Why?

Status
Not open for further replies.
J

john_axelson

Senior Member
Location
MN
Why does this forum frown on Do-It-Yourselfers, but then totally embrace the Do-It-Yourself contractor? We constantly answer the "How much?" question on this forum without addressing what should be the real question and it doesn't matter if you are from Mn or La, "How Long?" should be the only question that should be answered.

If we continue to answer the How Much question in the dollar amount instead of the Labor Time required, no one is going to take the time that they really should to become a successful contractor.

If we want to promote successful contracting, let's really enforce the principle that the only true way to become a successful contractor is to know your Costs. All contractors have to determine their own labor rates, not follow the lead of all of the others. I lease a space, you may work out of your home, until a time you need more space. I provide a different benefit package or maybe, I provide the package required by the local, doesn't matter, I still need to determine my own costs.

So, let's start answering the Contractor who is working hard during the day and trying to estimate at night (with the estimates we are providing) with more valuable information - "How Long?"
 
We don?t ?frown on? DIYs. Rather, the owner of this forum has decided not to allow forum members to provide advice and assistance to a DIY. It is a liability concern, and it is his money that pays for this forum. Therefore, he gets to make the rules.
 
I see a huge difference. DIY electricians can and do kill themselves, others, and even catch things on fire.

Bad business practices never got anyone killed - short of Mafia dealings of course...
 
john_axelson said:
Why does this forum frown on Do-It-Yourselfers, but then totally embrace the Do-It-Yourself contractor?
Click to expand...

Can I assume you're referring to a new member who has posted twice about an upcoming job, once in the NEC forum asking for the nitty gritty on subpanel basics and then in this forum asking for how to price it?

If so, you may notice that we haven't exactly "totally embraced" his questions yet. :)
 
My point is....

My point is....

I haven't been a member of this forum as long as most of you, but it appears that whether someone is asking "How much would you charge for...?" most of you answer that question with a dollar value. This is not information that is going to help, it is just going to help the OP to determine, oh ok, $500 for 5 cans in the kitchen is what they charge in New Jersey, so here in Utah I should charge $500 for 5 cans. You can't make that comparison.

I am merely suggesting that we answer the question, with what we would estimate the hours to be, and let them finish the rest of the estimate on their own. Just trying to help provide useful information.
 
One of the reasons to come here is to learn stuff. Whether a poster is being provided with how long something should take, OR how much you would charge, he or she is still learning stuff.
 
I learned something from an old remodeling contractor about 15 years ago that seems to be a major problem when estimating job cost. He said that most people with any real experience can break a job down to it's individual components and and give a reasonable estimate of how long it will take to complete a job but the real problem occcurs when they add up the numbers and they exceed a preconceived idea of what the job should cost. At this point the contractor starts to re-evaluate the time needed for each component of the job to and to reduce the numbers in order to reach the preconceived idea of job cost.

His advice ( the best I have ever herd ) was to never go to a job site to estimate a job with any sort of idea of what the job should cost. Break the job down to component level then add up the numbers and let the chips fall where they may. Never assume that you are going to save time somewhere and actually come in at less than the total.

The fear of over estimating a job is what gets most contractors. :smile:
 
His advice ( the best I have ever heard ) was to never go to a job site to estimate a job with any sort of idea of what the job should cost. Break the job down to component level then add up the numbers and let the chips fall where they may. Never assume that you are going to save time somewhere and actually come in at less than the total.

The fear of over estimating a job is what gets most contractors.
Click to expand...


Well said.


In regard to the original post I understand your point. Personally, I'm more willing give a turn-key price than provide a break down of labor units.

Labor units aside, I really enjoy the "what would you charge" posts as it gives me an opportunity to hypothetically bid something I normally might not bother with.:)
 
john_axelson said:
most of you answer that question with a dollar value.
Click to expand...


I know there are times when the dollar value is discussed a lot, too much. But many times the advise is good. Some of the first posts are you can't price per square foot, you must break things down and price individually. Maybe we should emphasize that it varies with location and other variables more.

You could almost make growler's statements a sticky. That's especially true today with input costs rising quickly. Price it and walk away.

Tim
 
john_axelson said:
We constantly answer the "How much?" question on this forum without addressing what should be the real question and it doesn't matter if you are from Mn or La, "How Long?" should be the only question that should be answered.
Click to expand...
We have just upgraded all our "HOW MUCH..." type posts.

In addition to showing the price, you are now required to also:
- indicate your State
- indicate the time

In this thread here: I think I lost it... , this forum's most censored member made a simple request :
#6
LarryFine said:
Would any of you be willing to "show your work" as to how you reached your numbers?
Click to expand...
..one that I agree with here:
#31
celtic said:
I think a more accurate question would be:

How long would it take?
​

Regional figures and all that jazz make the numbers in the metro areas seem staggeringly profitable.
Click to expand...
:grin:


The queston of "HOW LONG?" rather than "HOW MUCH ?" has been addressed before....but we cannot force people to respond in a way that we want.
 
A DIY'er is not going to get the subtleties of terminology, or understand broader scope of involvement.

For instance:
This morning I go to a clients home after he called last night. He is living through a remodel, and decided to trim some of it out himself, WHICH HE FELT CONFIDENT ENOUGH TO DO - he called because he couldn't get some SABC's working - He doesn't know line from load, He didn't know much of the make-up was not done yet. He didn't know it wasn't landed in the panel - he just figured he'd install some outlets himself as he has guests coming for the holidays, and figured he wouldn't get on the schedule - nor did he or the GC indicate that he was ready to be on the schedule... All he had to do was call - instead he calls for advice instead... :confused: :roll: :confused:

So I go there - wires on screws backwards, hot - neutral reversed, line / load reversed. He found the HR's and landed the hots on a different manufacturer breaker he bought - stuck it in the panel and hooked up the MWBC and forgot to connect the neutral or ground.... Luck enough that the make up in a J-box was not done....

Should I warrantee or accept liability for anything in that building now - HELL NO! :mad:

But here on the forum, and others like it, when I spot someone asking about say a service and they clearly have no clue - what should we do? Load the gun for them? A service short is no little spark, think grenade - and in most areas there is no OCP what-so-ever - not that one should rely on such for safety.

FYI on another forum - I once spotted this; 'the lights are acting funny, it smells wierd - what should I do?????' :rolleyes:

Not that our trade is that difficult - but neither is brain surgery... But most would accept that there are subtlties that would make them think twice about performing brain surgery. And most brain surgeons would think twice about doing most electrical work.
 
john_axelson said:
Why does this forum frown on Do-It-Yourselfers, but then totally embrace the Do-It-Yourself contractor? We constantly answer the "How much?" question on this forum without addressing what should be the real question and it doesn't matter if you are from Mn or La, "How Long?" should be the only question that should be answered.

If we continue to answer the How Much question in the dollar amount instead of the Labor Time required, no one is going to take the time that they really should to become a successful contractor.

If we want to promote successful contracting, let's really enforce the principle that the only true way to become a successful contractor is to know your Costs. All contractors have to determine their own labor rates, not follow the lead of all of the others. I lease a space, you may work out of your home, until a time you need more space. I provide a different benefit package or maybe, I provide the package required by the local, doesn't matter, I still need to determine my own costs.

So, let's start answering the Contractor who is working hard during the day and trying to estimate at night (with the estimates we are providing) with more valuable information - "How Long?"
Click to expand...
Most people are conscious of the fact that price is regional and it has been emphasized. I don't know if you have seen the "I think I have lost it ..." thread or not. There was a lot of talk about regional differences, I actually like finding out what the going rates are in different parts of the country (in case I ever think of relocating !). But your point is well taken about the fact that even in one and the same location, your overhead and mine are not the same, and there will be variations in bids and estimates. e/m.
 
With this day and age I bet you could get manslaughter charges if you give advice to someone and they get killed. I know if you wire something up wrong that is not code, You could get that charge.

I've notice most guys don't post labor units here. I guess that is a secret science.
 
Estimating a job is tough for all of us. It is mostly science but it still requires a bit of magic too. I don't want to be too high so I don't get any work, but I don't want to leave too much money "sitting on the table" either. I enjoy and learn from reading about how my fellow contractors go about it. I want to know every thing because as one of our members says "It's all about the money.":smile:
 
Sorry, but most of these small jobs have the risk of the owner or GC demanding out of sequence work or stack other trades in small area to work together, schedule poorly or other ways to get into your pocket.
Residential service changes, home additions and kitchen remodels are the types of jobs most electricians do as side jobs when they are apprentices.
As a professional, good or bad, you have an idea of a base price before you even get there.
Discovery of the schedule, complexity and volume of the work will lead you to your price. Most of these jobs blossom into changes. The most important thing you can do is address how these changes will be handled. I try to make all changes separate from the initial project agreement and send a separate bill for the extra work.
The amount of trips out to these types of jobs, if not managed, can be a killer to your labor hours
 
jrannis said:
Sorry, but most of these small jobs have the risk of the owner or GC demanding out of sequence work or stack other trades in small area to work together, schedule poorly or other ways to get into your pocket.
Residential service changes, home additions and kitchen remodels are the types of jobs most electricians do as side jobs when they are apprentices.
As a professional, good or bad, you have an idea of a base price before you even get there.
Discovery of the schedule, complexity and volume of the work will lead you to your price. Most of these jobs blossom into changes. The most important thing you can do is address how these changes will be handled. I try to make all changes separate from the initial project agreement and send a separate bill for the extra work.
The amount of trips out to these types of jobs, if not managed, can be a killer to your labor hours
Click to expand...
I put it in my bids exactly what change orders will cost and I always have the blank forms with me in the truck. There are some jobs that are extremely profitable just because of the change orders, and I get no grief from the HO as they know up front that changes of mind entail changes of money from thier pockets to mine.:smile:
 
iaov said:
I put it in my bids exactly what change orders will cost and I always have the blank forms with me in the truck. There are some jobs that are extremely profitable just because of the change orders, and I get no grief from the HO as they know up front that changes of mind entail changes of money from thier pockets to mine.:smile:
Click to expand...

*That is the most valuable lesson new contractors can learn.
Also dont do free work because they "like" you. Some people will try to charm you to the food bank.
Dont do free or cheap work because they promise you a spot in that next big job.

*Unless of course if your wife is a nurse:smile:
 
"How long" won't help. 'Cause I can wire anything faster than anyone else.:grin:

Just kidding. But if someone doesn't know their true costs, then "how long" isn't going to help them. Giving them "how much" might still be beneficial in one way or another.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top