Wire & breaker size for water heater

Status
Not open for further replies.
infinity said:
Internet searches can just give you the result of what it finds on the internet. There is more wrong information on the internet than correct information. YouTube has the same problem.
Click to expand...
Facebook supposed "electrician pages" are horrible for bad information.
 
infinity said:
The bold is the way I read it but after reading it again maybe I read it incorrectly. Maybe jbflex will come back and clarify.
Click to expand...
Yes hypothetically it’s 3,000 watts running on 120 volt supply. If taking the journeyman’s test i wanted to be sure my answer was correct but when i check online my answer doesnt match
 
Jpflex said:
Doesn’t NEC code consider water heaters 120 gallons or less as continuous?
Click to expand...
422.13 is titled "Storage-type water heaters" and is where this 120 gallon or less is mentioned to be considered continuous load.

The one in post 18 would typically be an on demand or instantaneous type water heater and would not be required to be considered as a continuous load.
 
kwired said:
Facebook supposed "electrician pages" are horrible for bad information.
Click to expand...
I generally didn’t have problems with online info in the past. Most info especially from well written online educational articles have been spot on in my past experience.

I’m starting to see flaws in google and Wikipedia now however. Both Wikipedia and google are politically biased and partial without giving both sides of an argument. It’s now propaganda and brainwashing for one political side. For example, if you google or search Wikipedia for Donald trump you will get a biased biography with opinion replacing facts. No longer do readers get both sides of a debate before concluding their stance
 
kwired said:
422.13 is titled "Storage-type water heaters" and is where this 120 gallon or less is mentioned to be considered continuous load.

The one in post 18 would typically be an on demand or instantaneous type water heater and would not be required to be considered as a continuous load.
Click to expand...
Storage water heater = a water heater which stores water, by reading NEC the way it’s wrote I wouldn’t think this didn’t apply to all
 
Jpflex said:
Storage water heater = a water heater which stores water, by reading NEC the way it’s wrote I wouldn’t think this didn’t apply to all
Click to expand...
Instantaneous water heaters (also called tankless) do not store water and are not storage type water heaters.
 
infinity said:
Instantaneous water heaters (also called tankless) do not store water and are not storage type water heaters.
Click to expand...
I guess the way to describe it is they don't store water that is heated and ready for use at desired temp.

Yes they store some water in the heating chamber when not in use but are only intended to heat water when there is demand for hot water and not to preheat/store hot water.
 
kwired said:
I guess the way to describe it is they don't store water that is heated and ready for use at desired temp.

Yes they store some water in the heating chamber when not in use but are only intended to heat water when there is demand for hot water and not to preheat/store hot water.
Click to expand...
Storage type means that they store the hot water and they heat the water even when there is no hot water in use.
 
kwired said:
I guess the way to describe it is they don't store water that is heated and ready for use at desired temp.

Yes they store some water in the heating chamber when not in use but are only intended to heat water when there is demand for hot water and not to preheat/store hot water.
Click to expand...
They obviously can't have zero volume, but the heating chambers can hardly be called storage.
 
infinity said:
Instantaneous water heaters (also called tankless) do not store water and are not storage type water heaters.
Click to expand...
kwired said:
I guess the way to describe it is they don't store water that is heated and ready for use at desired temp.

Yes they store some water in the heating chamber when not in use but are only intended to heat water when there is demand for hot water and not to preheat/store hot water.
Click to expand...
These are the more modern smaller water heaters that are installed in modern homes that are replacing older large tank water heaters?

The code described water heaters 120 gallons or less being considered a continuous load and so the 3000 watt 120 volt standard water tank heater and all of this type is what I was referring to. In these cases we use 125% ampacity?
 
LarryFine said:
They obviously can't have zero volume, but the heating chambers can hardly be called storage.
Click to expand...
Yes I wasn’t thinking of these smaller modern water heaters when describing tank storage water heaters
 
Jpflex said:
3000 watt 120 volt standard water tank heater
Click to expand...
Just a nit pick but I have never seen such a waterhetater and doubt they even make them even if someone manufactured one I would never consider it standard to have such a large 120V load.
I'd say 'standard' for a residential / light commercial storage type resistance electric water heater the would be 50 gallon 4500W 240V, or 80 Gallon 5500W 240V, and yes that would be a continuous load, 10AWG wire 25A breaker and 10 AWG 30A breaker respectively.
 
tortuga said:
Just a nit pick but I have never seen such a waterhetater and doubt they even make them even if someone manufactured one I would never consider it standard to have such a large 120V load.
I'd say 'standard' for a residential / light commercial storage type resistance electric water heater the would be 50 gallon 4500W 240V, or 80 Gallon 5500W 240V, and yes that would be a continuous load, 10AWG wire 25A breaker and 10 AWG 30A breaker respectively.
Click to expand...
They do make 1500 watt 120 volt elements though and I suppose could be possible to have a unit that is capable of running both upper and lower element at same time. Probably not common factory configuration though.

A place I am working on has a WH on site though not plumbed or wired yet. It is 80 gallon tank, can't recall exact watt rating but it is @ 277 volts and both upper and lower elements operate independent of one another, so both can be on at same time. However it will be connected @ 240 volts. Converting from 277 volts, again can't recall exact watt rating but do recall it will need a 50 amp circuit @ 240 volts, so it is like 9600 watts or a little less.

I wasn't convinced this is the way to go, but that's what the plumber thought we should use. I think he will be putting in a circulating pump as well :unsure:

If it were my place I would have put typical 4500 watt in the basement where this one is going, (maybe still 80 gallon) and another 4500 watt in mechanical room that is on the second story. Still looking at similar overall capacity but putting some of it closer to point of use and possibly can eliminate the circulating pump.
 
Rheem makes a 20 gallon with a 2KW, 120V element. I have one in my pool house.
The continuous load factor puts the required circuit size just over 20A. In real life, the thing would operate perfectly fine on a 20A circuit.
 
retirede said:
Rheem makes a 20 gallon with a 2KW, 120V element. I have one in my pool house.
The continuous load factor puts the required circuit size just over 20A. In real life, the thing would operate perfectly fine on a 20A circuit.
Click to expand...
Think I have run into one like that before.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top