Wire

Status
Not open for further replies.

LarryFine

Master Electrician Electric Contractor Richmond VA
Location
Henrico County, VA
Occupation
Electrical Contractor
fernandozavala_1 said:
Is it true that you can save money by using #12 in the entire house instead of #14?
Not enough to cover the difference in cost of the wire.

Such upsizing might, for a load such as resistive heating, save a pittance because a voltage drop might be compensated for by the heat running a few seconds more, but if the warm wire is in the heated space, it's not really a loss.

For other types of loads, such as lighting, voltage drop might even save you a smidgen, unless you went to a higher-wattage bulb to compensate. A motor load also depends on whether there is a performance-related effect to voltage drop.

Added: I like 15a lighting circuits and 20a receptacle circuits. The former loads are predictable, but the latter not so much.
 
Last edited:
I believe that over the lifetime of the house, the upsizing, even one size can have a cost benefit. The actual cost of the difference between 14 and 12 is not that significant for a standard house. The life of the house is what can make the difference.


There are engineers on this site who may be able to figure out the cost benefits over years.


In case some of you have forgotten, the costs of electric have been going up, up, up. Think of the next fifty years.
 

HighWirey

Senior Member
Pierre C Belarge said:
I believe that over the lifetime of the house, the upsizing, even one size can have a cost benefit. The actual cost of the difference between 14 and 12 is not that significant for a standard house. The life of the house is what can make the difference.
There are engineers on this site who may be able to figure out the cost benefits over years.
In case some of you have forgotten, the costs of electric have been going up, up, up. Think of the next fifty years.

I completely concur with your statements. Unfortunately, most questions posted here are set in a competetive arena, and 12awg over 14 may lose you that project.

Best Wishes Everyone
 

don_resqcapt19

Moderator
Staff member
Location
Illinois
Occupation
retired electrician
Given the small and mostly non-continuous loads in a dwelling unit, I have my doubts that the increased material costs would ever be covered the the decrease in energy costs. I'd have to see some hard numbers.
 

wireguru

Senior Member
is he talking about saving $ by eliminating voltage drop? Or is he asking about saving money by through the design phase, for example using #12/20a cir to get more rooms on a single AFCI vs #14/15a, getting more lighting on one circuit, etc.
 
L

Lxnxjxhx

Guest
cost benefits over years

cost benefits over years

The average midwest person uses 800 watts, continuously.
1 kW is probably more representative.

How many people in the average house?

1000' of #12 at 5 A dissipates 40 watts.

1000' of #14 at 5 A dissipates 63 watts.

How many feet of wire in a house?
 
L

Lxnxjxhx

Guest
Furthermore, the local power company, Pepco, (localpocopepco) sort of says that 1/3 of the power goes to wires larger than #12.

So the answer is obvious. . .!
 

Podagrower

Member
Location
Central Fl
With all that being said, if it was your house, would you use 14 or 12 for the branch circuits?
For years and years, I said 14. But when it was time to build, it was nothing smaller than 12, no aluminum, including service cable. Of course, I timed my house building out to right before copper went balistic.
 
Chicago influence

Chicago influence

Podagrower said:
With all that being said, if it was your house, would you use 14 or 12 for the branch circuits?

Don't know that I will actually do it but I designed my new place using emt. ;) Based on that you can assume it would be all copper including panel buss and pulling 12's for everything.

But I know someone who will do the work for beer and pizza so I'll be saving a ton on labor!
 

iwire

Moderator
Staff member
Location
Massachusetts
Podagrower said:
With all that being said, if it was your house, would you use 14 or 12 for the branch circuits?

Both, 12 where required 14 where it's allowed and I have been re-wiring my home.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top