1? / 3? Neutral Amp Question

Status
Not open for further replies.
Re: 1? / 3? Neutral Amp Question

Originally posted by charlie b:
I would also like to see anyone show that derivation.
Ok. I won't show all the details because it is too much to type. The rest is an exercise for the reader. :) The basis for the formula is the "vector" addition In = Ia + Ib + Ic. I put vector in quotes, because it is really a phasor. They can be represented in polar format (magnitude and angle) and rectangular format (real and imaginary) as complex numbers. The "vector" addition is really the addition of complex numbers. To get just the magnitude of In you take the square root of the real part squared plus the imaginary part squared.

The real part of X at Y degrees is X cos Y and the imaginary part is X sin Y. So the magnitude of In is (using capital for magnitude and small for the phase angle, and just ^ for squared):
sqrt( (Acosa+Bcosb+Ccosc)^ + (Asina+Bsinb+Csinc)^)
Then multiply the squares out to get terms like
A^cos^a + 2AcosaBcosb + etc
Then group the common parts for A, B, and C, like
A^(cos^a+sin^a) + 2AB(cosacosb+sinasinb) + etc
then use trig identities: sin^x + cos^x = 1
and sinxsiny+cosxcosy = cos(x-y)
and you get:
sqrt(A^ + B^ + C^ + 2ABcos(a-b) + 2BCcos(b-c) + 2ACcos(a-c) )
This is general for any angles. Assume the angles are a=0, b=120, and c=-120 (no attempt to match actual wiring practices for the angles ;) ), plug those numbers in and you get (all the cos are -0.5):
sqrt(A^ + B^ + C^ - AB - BC - AC)

Q.E.D.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top