Day lite control

Status
Not open for further replies.

Toros

Senior Member
Location
Tujunga, CA
Hi
I have a large size warehouse with sky lights all over
and suspended dimmable led lights

now I want design a system
where lights in the space dimm automaticaly when enough natural lighting is available

is it o.k to you if i used,
ceil. regular photo cells that cross-talk (thru l.volt wires) with a low voltage wall swith that is capable of dimming the lights

ALL BY LEVITON"

is there other brands doing that???

tanx
 

Sierrasparky

Senior Member
Location
USA
Occupation
Electrician ,contractor
You will need to follow the 2013 California Energy code requirements.
You will have several zones and multilevel switching.
a 0-10v dimming may work best.
a acceptance test by a certified tester will be required at the time of completion and prior to final.
You should consult a title 24 expert so you don't get into a bind at the end.
 

donaldelectrician

Senior Member
You will need to follow the 2013 California Energy code requirements.
You will have several zones and multilevel switching.
a 0-10v dimming may work best.
a acceptance test by a certified tester will be required at the time of completion and prior to final.
You should consult a title 24 expert so you don't get into a bind at the end.



Sierrasparky ; Is CA . the only state with tough Title 24 Requirements ? Is any other State requiring similar ?




Don
 

Sierrasparky

Senior Member
Location
USA
Occupation
Electrician ,contractor
Sierrasparky ; Is CA . the only state with tough Title 24 Requirements ? Is any other State requiring similar ?




Don

Don't know for sure but there are new federal regulations ( adoption of the new ASHRE standards) I read about that may exceed current CA requirements. Ca is probably exempt be cause CA already had a energy code in place. However CA will be or exceed the federal standard by 2017 with the new title 24.
 

kwired

Electron manager
Location
NE Nebraska
I can't speak for other states, but I have never ran into any kind of inspector that enforces any energy codes. AFAIK there are no state level codes, and if there are Federal codes that apply there just is nobody enforcing them. Doesn't mean there are not some designers designing to certain standards but no third party AHJ is ensuring final installs meet such requirements.
 

steve66

Senior Member
Location
Illinois
Occupation
Engineer
AFAIK there are no state level codes, and if there are Federal codes that apply there just is nobody enforcing them.

This link shows which states have adopted energy codes:

https://www.energycodes.gov/status-state-energy-code-adoption

Enforcement varies, and my personal experience is there tends to be more enforcement on the plan review side, and less enforcement by the inspectors that actually look at the installations. I think this is a known problem, and the States are trying their best to make sure local AHJ's enforce the adopted energy code. It basically boils down to individual States getting federal cash for compliance, so its in each States best interest to get compliance as high as possible.

There is an exception in the energy code that says something to the effect that if a permit or inspection isn't required for construction, the energy code doesn't apply.
 

ron

Senior Member
If you are interested, Friday, August 21st at 10:00am PT, free Webinar

Learn about the requirements for energy-efficient lighting controls for restaurants mandated in ASHRAE 90.1 2010 and California Title 24 2013. Discover how to bring any project up to the standard with an overview of the guidelines, considerations for compliance and examples of restaurant applications.

  • Review lighting control requirements, changes and the current status of the adoption of energy codes across the US
  • Understand lighting control requirements including automatic receptacle control and automatic daylight control
  • Identify how to easily select, plan and implement solutions to meet energy code standards



https://attendee.gotowebinar.com/register/2143255294346282242

This is from Leviton http://ashrae.leviton.com/
 

mwm1752

Senior Member
Location
Aspen, Colo
I can't speak for other states, but I have never ran into any kind of inspector that enforces any energy codes. AFAIK there are no state level codes, and if there are Federal codes that apply there just is nobody enforcing them. Doesn't mean there are not some designers designing to certain standards but no third party AHJ is ensuring final installs meet such requirements.

The Energy code is a building code so electrical permits are not subject to the violations -- FYI places like Las Vegas are exempt from lighting power use in casino's -- hows that for being consistant with saving our planet :?
 

ron

Senior Member
The Energy code is a building code so electrical permits are not subject to the violations -- FYI places like Las Vegas are exempt from lighting power use in casino's -- hows that for being consistant with saving our planet :?

I work in lots of jurisdictions and some even require that we put the compliance documents (Comcheck) pasted on the electrical drawings for permit application.
 

mwm1752

Senior Member
Location
Aspen, Colo
I work in lots of jurisdictions and some even require that we put the compliance documents (Comcheck) pasted on the electrical drawings for permit application.

Ron, One of my duties is to review lighting ComChecks -- we require bunch of stuff - fixture schedule, fixture specs, allowance display figures(if taken), lighting plans, ComCheck complete - all with fixture labeling that matches in each document.

I just find it interesting that special circumstances (Vegas Baby)have become exempt through lobby of goverment, even though the concept is to lower energy consumption and use less rescources.
 

Sierrasparky

Senior Member
Location
USA
Occupation
Electrician ,contractor
The Energy code is a building code so electrical permits are not subject to the violations -- FYI places like Las Vegas are exempt from lighting power use in casino's -- hows that for being consistant with saving our planet :?


so electrical permits are not subject to the violations- How does that work!

In Kalifornia the energy code is code and subject to violations just as any other code. However most AHJ don't view it as life safety so will rarely write you with a violation. Most just look the other way. This is why the energy code is getting so cumbersome and onerous.
Us contractors are at fault for the code being more strict as compliance has been very lax in the past. ( General contractors too)
 

donaldelectrician

Senior Member
so electrical permits are not subject to the violations- How does that work!

In Kalifornia the energy code is code and subject to violations just as any other code. However most AHJ don't view it as life safety so will rarely write you with a violation. Most just look the other way. This is why the energy code is getting so cumbersome and onerous.
Us contractors are at fault for the code being more strict as compliance has been very lax in the past. ( General contractors too)




I think that is all in the process of changing ... and CA is stepping up .





Don
 

Sierrasparky

Senior Member
Location
USA
Occupation
Electrician ,contractor
I think that is all in the process of changing ... and CA is stepping up .





Don

It would really be nice if Kali just stayed out of it. If a owner wants to comply and save then fine. If another does not want to then fine also as long as they are aware they are going to spend a substantial amount more in usage in the long run.

Real Estate brokers need to stress the financial difference.
 

Fulthrotl

~Autocorrect is My Worst Enema.~
Hi
I have a large size warehouse with sky lights all over
and suspended dimmable led lights

now I want design a system
where lights in the space dimm automaticaly when enough natural lighting is available

is it o.k to you if i used,
ceil. regular photo cells that cross-talk (thru l.volt wires) with a low voltage wall swith that is capable of dimming the lights

ALL BY LEVITON"

is there other brands doing that???

tanx

what AHJ is the under? about 1 in 3 building departments in calif don't enforce the
T24:2013 certification requirements........ yet.

that's probably going to change in the next few months... i suspect the CEC will take steps
to compel the certification to be enforced. if that happens, i'd expect building departments
to send out nice form letters requiring people who've done work that was not certified in the
last year, to please send in their certifications for that completed work. if it happens, it's not
going to be pretty.

so, you have sidelight, and skylight daylight harvesting. there are rules for calculating the zones,
and formulas and allowance, and when it's all said and done, it needs to be certified. if that is enforced.

my suggestion to you is to have a licensed EE produce drawings, you permit the job, install the system as
shown on the approved drawings, and have it certified, and get a final inspection. the main reason you want
an EE blessing the system, is to limit YOUR liability from installing a system that can't be certified.

this stuff is snarky expensive. i've got a itty bitty box in the back of my van with some bits and pieces,
that got missed on a job, and it's $2k worth of stuff, on a $10k job. a couple daylighting sensors, two
power packs that'll do 0-10v and line dimming, a 365 day timeclock, and three wattstopper dm100 motion sensors,
and a few other things..... well, not $2k, but 1,400 with tax.

i looked at a job in central california, that was a homebrew deal. try as i might, i couldn't find a way to
certify it as compliant. a $5k lighting upgrade to an existing nationwide restaurant chain. they put some
notes on an existing set of drawings, and permitted it. didn't want to spend the time and money to draw
a set of prints up.

the AHJ made them into a chew toy. first, no cert. i couldn't certify it cause no permit, and it was a bogus
install. owners panicked and threw $10k at it, buying a lighting control panel that wasn't listed.
then the AHJ said that the poorly drawn unengineered drawings threw the entire occupancy into a
requirement to comply with T24:2013. full compliance

the lighting package for that, not including labor to install it, is over $120k. it's been three months, and they
are still chewing over how to fix it.

wattstopper, lutron, and nLight all make systems to do what you are trying to do. nLight is the best i've seen,
and the most expensive.

you can't get a certification without a permitted set of drawings. so you need the following:

current C-10
approved drawings
electrical permit
completely installed system
proper set up or commissioning
certification of compliance of the install.
final inspection by AHJ

in that order.

and yeah, i have the certificate for blessing the install. there are not
that many of us around. send me a PM if you want more info.

my advice is not to bid your own design without an EE to give you a
stoploss. opening a permit you can't close sucks.

people are twitchy enough about it that i have an EE who wants me
to consult on a seven story in downtown LA, so there won't be any
problems with certification, at $165 an hour. no way i'm signing up
for that. i don't have errors and omissions insurance on design.


randy
 
Last edited:

kwired

Electron manager
Location
NE Nebraska
The Energy code is a building code so electrical permits are not subject to the violations -- FYI places like Las Vegas are exempt from lighting power use in casino's -- hows that for being consistant with saving our planet :?

so electrical permits are not subject to the violations- How does that work!

In Kalifornia the energy code is code and subject to violations just as any other code. However most AHJ don't view it as life safety so will rarely write you with a violation. Most just look the other way. This is why the energy code is getting so cumbersome and onerous.
Us contractors are at fault for the code being more strict as compliance has been very lax in the past. ( General contractors too)
Don't know how CA makes it work, but the State Electrical Act here is all about safety to people and property not about the efficiency of the installations. If they want to pass laws and put energy code enforcement on that same department that is currently doing electrical inspections then the lawmakers would also need to have plans on how that extra task from that department would be funded or it won't work out. But they also would need to figure out how to fund it anyway even if a new department would be made to manage this code. I promise you the State Electrical Division will not be intentionally looking into adding energy code enforcement to their duties, it will be more less forced on them by lawmakers if it ever does happen.

Energy efficiency does go beyond electrical energy as well and you don't need to know NEC to be able to be involved in enforcement of such codes either. I don't think it necessarily belongs on the shoulders of an electrical inspector either.
 
The California energy code is just another book of codes not just lighting.
The way California is trying to do it is by this special testing done only by certified people. You have to sign off the project under penalty of perjury that :
The design is correct.
The plans are correct.
The installed components are correct.
The lighting system is adjusted and working correctly.
The project is registered in a database with the permit number.
All the inspector needs to verify is that all the paperwork is signed by the acceptance tester. So basically a AHJ has no reason to pass a job if the paperwork does not say PASS.
So in a nutshell that is how it works, Supposedly.

I just got my certification in the mail. I'll see how it goes.
 

kwired

Electron manager
Location
NE Nebraska
The California energy code is just another book of codes not just lighting.
The way California is trying to do it is by this special testing done only by certified people. You have to sign off the project under penalty of perjury that :
The design is correct.
The plans are correct.
The installed components are correct.
The lighting system is adjusted and working correctly.
The project is registered in a database with the permit number.
All the inspector needs to verify is that all the paperwork is signed by the acceptance tester. So basically a AHJ has no reason to pass a job if the paperwork does not say PASS.
So in a nutshell that is how it works, Supposedly.

I just got my certification in the mail. I'll see how it goes.

Maybe I missed something in there, but who is verifying any actual performance requirements are being met? All I am seeing is that the owner, contractor or whoever is signing the paperwork is the one that is taking on any risk of not being in compliance should something come up at a later time.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top