Member rating

Status
Not open for further replies.
goldstar

goldstar

Senior Member
Location
New Jersey
Occupation
Electrical Contractor
What is member rating and what does it mean to have 5 stars under your name ? Does that make you a 5-star general ? Is it a prestige thing ? Many of the members in the "old forum" had the number of posts they've submitted adjacent to their names. How do I improve my rating ? Does it entitle me to anything that 5-star members have ?
Also, in the old forum, when you posted a message, the column on the left indicated who posted the message. Now it uses your "sign-on" name. Is this the right thing to do ?

Just curious,

Phil Bufis
Gold Star Electric
Ringwood, NJ

[ February 24, 2003, 07:26 AM: Message edited by: goldstar ]
 
charlie

charlie

Senior Member
Location
Indianapolis
Re: Member rating

I am assuming (that is a word that always gets me into trouble) the object is to get you to rate the answers and/or helpfulness of the respondents. Those with lesser amounts of stars would be disregarded while those with lots of stars will be more highly regarded. Give a bad answer or p _ _ _ someone off and get one star . . . HMMM.

Is this really a good system? :confused:
 
iwire

iwire

Moderator
Staff member
Location
Massachusetts
Re: Member rating

I think all the rating system will do is discourage people from asking questions, or posting replies. :(
Bob
 
L

Len_B

Member
Location
New Hampshire
Re: Member rating

Perhaps we could turn it into a "Reality Forum" --- we could call it "CODE QUOTIN' SURVIVOR". Every day we could vote someone out... ;) ...nevermind.
 
N

nosparks

Member
Location
Massachusetts
Re: Member rating

;) Regardless of our differences I think that the member rating is crap. We have and always will disagree (well not always). But this was designed for learning and sharing. The rating system has got to go!
 
L

Len_B

Member
Location
New Hampshire
Re: Member rating

We have and always will disagree (well not always). But this was designed for learning and sharing.
Click to expand...
An open forum such as this is one of the best ways to learn. Open debate requires us to examine our position/opinion and logically defend it. Right or wrong, we are forced to learn. Members should never afraid to post their thoughts because of "five star ratings" or fear of being ridiculed for an "incorrect response". When this happens we lose the benefit of the members' combined knowledge, which is the forum's fundamental purpose.

Len
 
roger

roger

Moderator
Staff member
Location
Fl
Occupation
Retired Electrician
Re: Member rating

Charlie, you must have done that, you're way to respected for anyone to rate you below five.

Roger
 
mikeames

mikeames

Senior Member
Location
Germantown MD
Occupation
Teacher - Master Electrician - 2017 NEC
Re: Member rating

Ill be the lone ranger with no stars. I hope the majority of us kept a similar name. I just got to know everyone and their posts.
 
davedottcom

davedottcom

Senior Member
Re: Member rating

Stars...we don't need no stinkin stars!

I went to my "Profile" and chose to Not have my member rating displayed...that pretty much took care of that!!!

To whom ever designed this new forum:
Good Job...I give you 5 stars!

:D

Dave
 
T

tim

Senior Member
Re: Member rating

Give me the old forum back. This is to d_mn hard. Plus, can I rate myself? :) :p
 
T

tim

Senior Member
Re: Member rating

Give me the old forum back. This is to d_mn hard. Plus, can I rate myself? :eek: :roll:
 
G

gardiner

Senior Member
Location
Canada
Re: Member rating

Not that I post much here other then asking questions and trying to learn but this star rating is really not the way to go. I thought this forum was to discuss question not a popularity contest.
 
J

john

New member
Location
Louisiana
Re: Member rating

I dont visit the forum as much as I use too.
Its to hard to browse thru all the topics.
If the last one wasnt broke, why did they fix it.
In my opinion it was a bad move to change it.
 
C

chris white

Member
Location
Pennsylvania
Re: Member rating

The star thing has pretty much turned into a joke. I made a comment about not having any stars, then the next day I had 5. Whatever...

I think if everybody here was in agreement that the rating system is meaningless, and that we don't want to cause confusion among new members, we can all just turn that feature off in our profiles. Then we'll all have no rating. Those of us who have been reading and/or posting for a long time know who the real experts are. By clicking on the member's name you can still see their profile, even without the rating feature.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top