AFCI BREAKER PROBLEM - NEED CONFIRMATION.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Cybatrex said:
e85e82b0a055b7e6246709f6845d3b90.jpg



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Click to expand...


Note the round yellow sticker. The OP confirmed this fed from a 208Y/120v service.
 
mopowr steve said:
So does Sq D offer a 2pole AFCI or GFCI that will operate on a 120/208 Y system?
Click to expand...

Your question got me curious. Click here for the Schneider Electric Catalog section. Go to page 1-12. All they show, in the two pole AFCI is limited by footnote 16. 120/240 single phase only. No 208Y/120 allowed.

So, no.
 
al hildenbrand said:
Your question got me curious. Click here for the Schneider Electric Catalog section. Go to page 1-12. All they show, in the two pole AFCI is limited by footnote 16. 120/240 single phase only. No 208Y/120 allowed.
Click to expand...

Unbelievable - SQ-D is incompatible with MWBC's in all 208Y/120 residential sectors.

Page 12, footnote 16 for QO. Page 22, footnote 5 for HOM.
 
Interesting!
how are people handling this when an apartment complex service is fed by a 3phase 208/120 Y system but then individual units are fed only diversified single phase 120/208?
 
Id see if the panel can is the same dimensions of the Sq d, remove all the sqD and replace with GE guts and cover.

Or cut in some afci dead front receptacles fed with one on the approved methods.
 
mopowr steve said:
Interesting!
how are people handling this when an apartment complex service is fed by a 3phase 208/120 Y system but then individual units are fed only diversified single phase 120/208?
Click to expand...

al hildenbrand said:
There is one way to handle these existing multiwire branch circuits (short of refeeding them as a pair of two-wire branch circuits). Add a GE suppanel and handle tie a pair of single pole CAFCIs. You see, GE is the only CAFCI that does not require the LOAD neutral to be connected to the load terminal of the breaker. The GE CAFCI is purely arc fault sensing without any ground fault sensing component.
Click to expand...

The problem, in a single phase panel, like that shown in the OP, is that the neutral current is not the arithmetic sum of the difference between L1 and L2 (the two hot phase leg currents.) Rather the neutral current is the result of the vector sum of two currents at 120 degrees of each other.

All AFCIs, except those made by GE, have a ground fault sensing component. So, Square D, Siemens, and Eaton AFCIs will all trip because the ground fault sensing component in them will be triggered.

So, handle-tied single-pole GE CAFCI breakers will work with an existing MWBC. The alternative is to refeed the MWBC with two two-wire branch circuits thus removing the shared neutral.
 
al hildenbrand said:
The problem, in a single phase panel, like that shown in the OP, is that the neutral current is not the arithmetic sum of the difference between L1 and L2 (the two hot phase leg currents.) Rather the neutral current is the result of the vector sum of two currents at 120 degrees of each other.

All AFCIs, except those made by GE, have a ground fault sensing component. So, Square D, Siemens, and Eaton AFCIs will all trip because the ground fault sensing component in them will be triggered.
Click to expand...
I'm having a little trouble with this explanation. Won't the GF component of the AFCI simply pass all three conductors (L1, L2, and N) through a toroid to detect any instantaneous current imbalances? That will be the equivalent of doing the vector sum you describe.

I would think the limitation arises from the AFCI side of things (which is a black box), rather than from the GFCI side of things. Won't a standard 2 pole GFCI breaker work properly on a 120/208 3-wire circuit?

Cheers, Wayne
 
wwhitney said:
I'm having a little trouble with this explanation. Won't the GF component of the AFCI simply pass all three conductors (L1, L2, and N) through a toroid to detect any instantaneous current imbalances? That will be the equivalent of doing the vector sum you describe.
Click to expand...
Thank you Wayne, you are correct. My explanation about the ground fault sensing component in the AFCI being to blame is wrong.

wwhitney said:
I would think the limitation arises from the AFCI side of things (which is a black box), rather than from the GFCI side of things.
Click to expand...
I agree that the "black box" is where the incompatibility has to be coming from.

wwhitney said:
Won't a standard 2 pole GFCI breaker work properly on a 120/208 3-wire circuit?
Click to expand...
Yes.

SqD GFCI 2-pole.jpg
 
mopowr steve said:
Interesting!
how are people handling this when an apartment complex service is fed by a 3phase 208/120 Y system but then individual units are fed only diversified single phase 120/208?
Click to expand...
by not using MWBC's for any circuits requiring AFCI protection. Singe pole AFCI's will still work on these systems.
 
kwired said:
by not using MWBC's for any circuits requiring AFCI protection. Singe pole AFCI's will still work on these systems.
Click to expand...

That. And i can’t remember the last time I worked on or bid an apartment complex that was 208Y/120. It’s not a popular setup in the south.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Cybatrex said:
Florida now uses 2014 NEC which introduced a series of pain in the but situations with AFCI Breakers. Good luck when trying to find a 2 PULL CAFCI breaker.

Q: 2 - 20A 2P CAFCI breakers I installed are both not tripping with the test button when pressed. It seems odd that both of them are doing it. When the test button doesn’t work but the breaker trips during an ARC the breaker is defective, correct? If you have any suggestions that I can learn from, I’m all ears.
ae75a199ed80b7f1fee7e1d328887b1a.jpg
e85e82b0a055b7e6246709f6845d3b90.jpg



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Click to expand...

2 pole AFCI circuit breakers are available for most if not all current electrical panels. You probably defective two pole breakers. What brand are you using?
 
chris1971 said:
2 pole AFCI circuit breakers are available for most if not all current electrical panels. You probably defective two pole breakers. What brand are you using?
Click to expand...

No defective components here, SQD wont work on a multiwire circuit fed by a 3phase wye system.

See the sticker on the breaker NO 208! ;)
 
brantmacga said:
That. And i can’t remember the last time I worked on or bid an apartment complex that was 208Y/120. It’s not a popular setup in the south.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Get big enough complex and it kind of becomes necessary.

chris1971 said:
2 pole AFCI circuit breakers are available for most if not all current electrical panels. You probably defective two pole breakers. What brand are you using?
Click to expand...
You copied the pictures and still can't tell which brand they are??
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top