I'll take hardboard siding over vinyl any day, but Cladwood is garbage, I was being cheap & bought some for my shop regretted it right away it was eventually replaced with rough sawn fir plywood siding, pretty sure Cladwood was withdrawn from the market, was searching for info a few years ago and a lot of stories came out about class action lawsuits came up, in my case though it was spending a dollar to save a dime.I'll agree that Masonite siding is awful. Not familiar with Cladwood.